Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedaudited 2026-10-02
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The Cartier-to-Weil map respects addition and principal divisors

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Dependent Choice (The axiom of dependent choice: a relation in which every element is related to something admits an N-indexed chain). Let X be a normal Noetherian integral scheme (Weil divisor normal noetherian scheme), with group of Cartier divisors CaDiv⁡(X) (Cartier divisor), group of Weil divisors Div⁡(X) and Weil divisor class group Cl⁡(X)=Div⁡(X)/P(X) (Principal weil divisor and class group), and let cyc⁡:CaDiv⁡(X)⟶Div⁡(X) be the assignment sending a Cartier divisor to its associated Weil divisor (Cartier divisors on a normal Noetherian scheme give Weil divisors). Then:

  1. (additivity) cyc⁡ is a homomorphism of abelian groups: cyc⁡(D+E)=cyc⁡(D)+cyc⁡(E) for all Cartier divisors D,E on X, and cyc⁡(0)=0;
  2. (principal divisors) cyc⁡(div⁡C(f))=div⁡W(f) for every f∈K(X)× (Principal cartier divisor), so cyc⁡ carries the subgroup of principal Cartier divisors into the subgroup P(X) of principal Weil divisors;
  3. (the induced map) there is a canonical homomorphism of abelian groups Pic⁡(X)⟶Cl⁡(X), the Cartier/Picard class map, which carries the isomorphism class [OX(D)] of a Cartier divisor to the class of cyc⁡(D) in Cl⁡(X) (Picard group of a scheme).

The Axiom of Dependent Choice is inherited from the two suppliers that construct the Weil divisor cyc⁡(D) and the principal Weil divisor div⁡W(f); no further choice is used.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: a normal Noetherian integral scheme X, with its groups CaDiv⁡(X), Div⁡(X) and Cl⁡(X)=Div⁡(X)/P(X), and the assignment cyc⁡.

[F1]

Assume DC. For a normal Noetherian scheme X and a Cartier divisor D represented by local equations fi∈KX(Ui)× on an open cover, and for every prime divisor Z with generic point ξ and every index i with ξ∈Ui, the value vξ(fi,ξ) of the normalized valuation of the discrete valuation ring OX,ξ is independent of i and of the local-equation datum; the sum cyc⁡(D)=∑Zvξ(fi,ξ)[Z] is a well-defined Weil divisor on X; and if X is integral then cyc⁡(div⁡C(f))=div⁡W(f) for every f∈K(X)× (Cartier divisors on a normal Noetherian scheme give Weil divisors).

[F2]

For a prime divisor Z with generic point ξ the order of vanishing is ord⁡Z(f)=vξ(fξ), where vξ is the normalized discrete valuation of OX,ξ; vξ is a group homomorphism K×→Z, so ord⁡Z(fg)=ord⁡Z(f)+ord⁡Z(g), ord⁡Z(1)=0 and ord⁡Z(f−1)=−ord⁡Z(f) (Order codimension one rational function).

[F3]

Cartier divisors on X form an abelian group CaDiv⁡(X): a sum D+E is represented on a common open cover by the products figi of local equations of D and E, passing to a refinement or replacing equations by unit multiples does not change the divisor, and the zero element is the class of the constant equation 1 (Cartier divisor).

[F4]

For a global meromorphic unit f∈K(X)× the principal Cartier divisor div⁡C(f)=qX(f) is represented by the single global equation f on the open set X, and div⁡C(fg)=div⁡C(f)+div⁡C(g); the principal Cartier divisors form a subgroup of CaDiv⁡(X) (Principal cartier divisor).

[F5]

Assume DC. The principal Weil divisor div⁡W(f)=∑Zord⁡Z(f)[Z] defines a group homomorphism div⁡W:K(X)×→Div⁡(X) whose image is the subgroup P(X) of principal Weil divisors; the class group is Cl⁡(X)=Div⁡(X)/P(X), and two Weil divisors have the same class exactly when their difference is div⁡W(f) for some f∈K(X)× (Principal weil divisor and class group).

[F6]

A Weil divisor on a Noetherian normal scheme is a formal sum ∑ZnZ[Z] over the prime divisors with locally finite support, and addition is coefficientwise; in particular two Weil divisors are equal if and only if their coefficients at every prime divisor agree (Weil divisor normal noetherian scheme).

[F7]

For a normal subgroup N⊴G the quotient group G/N has product (gN)(hN)=ghN, and the quotient map G→G/N is a homomorphism (The quotient group G/N and coset product (gN)(hN)=ghN).

[F8]

If N⊴G and f:G→H is a homomorphism with N⊆ker⁡f, then f factors uniquely as f=fˉ∘π with fˉ:G/N→H a homomorphism, fˉ(gN)=f(g) (A homomorphism that kills a normal subgroup factors uniquely through the quotient group).

[F9]

On an integral scheme X the rule D↦[OX(D)] is a group homomorphism CaDiv⁡(X)→Pic⁡(X) with kernel the principal Cartier divisors, and it is surjective; hence the induced map CaDiv⁡(X)/Prin⁡C(X)→Pic⁡(X) is an isomorphism of abelian groups (On an integral scheme, Cartier divisors modulo principal divisors compute the Picard group).

[F10]

The Picard group Pic⁡(X) is the group of isomorphism classes of invertible OX-modules under tensor product, with identity [OX] (Picard group of a scheme).

[F11]

The Axiom of Dependent Choice (DC) is the statement about entire relations and sequences recorded in The axiom of dependent choice: a relation in which every element is related to something admits an N-indexed chain; the statements [F1] and [F5] are available under it, and no other choice principle is used here.

[F12]

A subgroup of an abelian group is normal, and a composite of group homomorphisms is a group homomorphism (Normal subgroup: invariance under conjugation, Monoid homomorphism and group homomorphism).

Proof

1.1F1F2F3F6F11

Additivity of the associated Weil divisor. Assume DC, as in [F11] and through the supplier [F1]. Let D,E be Cartier divisors on X; refining their representing covers if necessary, represent both on a common open cover {Ui} by local equations fi and gi, so that D+E is represented on Ui by the product figi by [F3]. For a prime divisor Z with generic point ξ choose an index i with ξ∈Ui; then the coefficient of cyc⁡(D+E) at Z is vξ((figi)ξ)=vξ(fi,ξ)+vξ(gi,ξ) by the additivity of the valuation in [F2], and these two summands are exactly the coefficients of cyc⁡(D) and cyc⁡(E) at Z by [F1]. Since the coefficients agree at every prime divisor, [F6] gives cyc⁡(D+E)=cyc⁡(D)+cyc⁡(E); in particular cyc⁡ is a group homomorphism and cyc⁡(0)=0.

1.2F1F2F4F5F6

Principal Cartier divisors map to principal Weil divisors. Let f∈K(X)×. By [F4] the principal Cartier divisor div⁡C(f) is represented by the single global equation f, so by [F1] its associated Weil divisor has at a prime divisor Z with generic point ξ the coefficient vξ(fξ)=ord⁡Z(f) by [F2]; the right hand side is by definition the coefficient of div⁡W(f) at Z by [F5]. As the coefficients agree at every prime divisor, [F6] gives cyc⁡(div⁡C(f))=div⁡W(f), and since div⁡W(f)∈P(X) by [F5], the image of the subgroup of principal Cartier divisors lies in P(X).

2.1F4F5F7F12step 1.1step 1.2

The class homomorphism. Let ψ:CaDiv⁡(X)→Cl⁡(X) be the composite of cyc⁡ with the quotient map Div⁡(X)→Cl⁡(X)=Div⁡(X)/P(X). By step 1.1 and [F7] both maps are group homomorphisms, so ψ is a group homomorphism by [F12], and by step 1.2 it kills every principal Cartier divisor: ψ(div⁡C(f)) is the class of div⁡W(f), which lies in P(X), hence is the zero class of Cl⁡(X). In other words Prin⁡C(X)⊆ker⁡ψ.

3.1F3F8F12step 2.1

Factoring through the quotient by principal divisors. The subgroup Prin⁡C(X) of the abelian group CaDiv⁡(X) is normal by [F3] and [F12], so by the universal property [F8] applied to ψ and Prin⁡C(X)⊆ker⁡ψ there is a unique homomorphism ψˉ:CaDiv⁡(X)/Prin⁡C(X)→Cl⁡(X) with ψˉ(D+Prin⁡C(X))=ψ(D)=[cyc⁡(D)] for every Cartier divisor D.

4.1F9F10F12step 3.1∎

The induced map Pic⁡(X)→Cl⁡(X). Since X is integral, [F9] says that D↦[OX(D)] induces an isomorphism φˉ:CaDiv⁡(X)/Prin⁡C(X)→Pic⁡(X) of abelian groups. Let Pic⁡(X)→Cl⁡(X) be the composite of the inverse of φˉ with ψˉ: it is a group homomorphism by [F12], and for every Cartier divisor D it carries [OX(D)]=φˉ(D+Prin⁡C(X)) to ψˉ(D+Prin⁡C(X))=[cyc⁡(D)] by step 3.1. In particular the prescription [OX(D)]↦[cyc⁡(D)] is well defined, because two Cartier divisors with the same image in Pic⁡(X) differ by an element of ker⁡φ=Prin⁡C(X), where φ:CaDiv⁡(X)→Pic⁡(X) is the original class map by [F9], on which ψ vanishes, so they determine the same quotient class and the same value of ψˉ.

The Axiom of Dependent Choice is used exactly through the two supplier statements [F1] and [F5]: it produces the local finiteness of cyc⁡(D) for an arbitrary Cartier divisor D and the analogous finiteness for div⁡W(f); no sequence is built and no family is selected anywhere in this proof. The construction is the divisor-class companion of the classical map of the Weil divisor class associated to an invertible module; when X has no prime divisors the groups Div⁡(X), P(X) and Cl⁡(X) are trivial and the induced map is the trivial homomorphism, and the computation is compatible with the identification CaDiv⁡(X)/Prin⁡C(X)≅Pic⁡(X) of [F9], under which [cyc⁡(D)] is the class of the invertible sheaf OX(D).

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

81 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources