Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedaudited 2026-10-02
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Under AC, the Picard-to-class-group map is injective on normal Noetherian integral schemes

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Choice (The Axiom of Choice). Let X be a normal Noetherian integral scheme (Weil divisor normal noetherian scheme, Integral schemes). Then the canonical homomorphism Pic⁡(X)⟶Cl⁡(X) of The Cartier-to-Weil map respects addition and principal divisors, which sends the class [OX(D)] of a Cartier divisor to the class of its associated Weil divisor cyc⁡(D) (Cartier divisors on a normal Noetherian scheme give Weil divisors), is injective. Moreover, the Cartier-to-Weil cycle homomorphism itself is injective: if a Cartier divisor E satisfies cyc⁡(E)=0, then E=0.

The Axiom of Choice is used exactly through the normality and (S2) inputs normal domain implies s two, r one s two intersection of height one localisations and A domain is integrally closed if and only if its prime localisations are, equivalently if and only if its maximal localisations are, which assume it, and through the implication AC⇒DC (AC implies DC implies countable choice) that makes the Dependent-Choice suppliers available.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: a normal Noetherian integral scheme X and an invertible OX-module L whose class in Pic⁡(X) lies in the kernel of the canonical homomorphism Pic⁡(X)→Cl⁡(X).

[F1]

The Axiom of Choice is the statement that every family of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Choice).

[F2]

AC⇒DC, and DC includes a prescribed initial point (AC implies DC implies countable choice).

[F3]

Assume DC. For a normal Noetherian integral scheme X, the associated Weil divisor satisfies cyc⁡:CaDiv⁡(X)→Div⁡(X), and cyc⁡(D+E)=cyc⁡(D)+cyc⁡(E) for Cartier divisors D,E, while cyc⁡(div⁡C(f))=div⁡W(f) for f∈K(X)×; there is a canonical homomorphism Pic⁡(X)→Cl⁡(X) carrying [OX(D)] to the class of cyc⁡(D) (The Cartier-to-Weil map respects addition and principal divisors).

[F4]

Assume DC. Let X be a normal Noetherian scheme and let D be a Cartier divisor represented by local equations fi∈KX(Ui)×. For every prime divisor Z with generic point ξ and every index i with ξ∈Ui, the coefficient of cyc⁡(D) at Z is vξ(fi,ξ), the value of the normalized valuation of the discrete valuation ring OX,ξ, and this is independent of i and of the local-equation datum (Cartier divisors on a normal Noetherian scheme give Weil divisors).

[F5]

Let X be an integral scheme with generic point η and L invertible. Then KX(L)=L⊗KX is the constant sheaf with value the stalk Lη, a one-dimensional K(X)-vector space, so it is nonzero; a rational section of L is by definition a nonzero element of this vector space (Rational section line bundle).

[F6]

Let X be integral, L invertible and s a rational section of L. Then D=div⁡C(s) is a well-defined Cartier divisor on X, there is a canonical isomorphism OX(D)→L carrying 1D to s, and for every Cartier divisor D the canonical section 1D satisfies div⁡C(1D)=D (Rational sections of line bundles are Cartier divisors).

[F7]

For f∈K(X)× the principal Cartier divisor div⁡C(f) is represented by the single global equation f, and principal Cartier divisors form a subgroup of CaDiv⁡(X) (Principal cartier divisor).

[F8]

Cartier divisors on X form an abelian group and are represented on open covers by meromorphic units with unit ratios; a divisor represented by unit equations is the zero divisor, and a divisor whose restriction to every member of an open cover is zero is zero (Cartier divisor).

[F9]

The Picard group Pic⁡(X) is the group of isomorphism classes of invertible OX-modules, with identity [OX] (Picard group of a scheme).

[F10]

Assume DC. On a normal Noetherian integral scheme X one has Γ(X,KX×)=K(X)×, the map div⁡W:K(X)×→Div⁡(X) is a group homomorphism with image the subgroup P(X) of principal Weil divisors, and Cl⁡(X)=Div⁡(X)/P(X); consequently a Weil divisor has zero class exactly when it is of the form div⁡W(f) for some f∈K(X)× (Principal weil divisor and class group).

[F11]

For a prime divisor Z with generic point ξ the order of vanishing is ord⁡Z(f)=vξ(fξ), and in the case of an integral normal locally Noetherian scheme vξ(g)=0 for g∈K(X)× if and only if g is a unit of OX,ξ (Order codimension one rational function).

[F12]

Assume AC. Every commutative Noetherian integrally closed domain satisfies (S2) (normal domain implies s two).

[F13]

Assume AC. If R is a commutative Noetherian domain satisfying (S2), then inside its fraction field K one has R=⋂ht⁡p=1Rp; for a field the empty intersection is interpreted as K=R (r one s two intersection of height one localisations).

[F14]

Assume AC. A domain A is integrally closed if and only if every localisation Ap at a prime ideal is integrally closed (A domain is integrally closed if and only if its prime localisations are, equivalently if and only if its maximal localisations are).

[F15]

An integral scheme is nonempty, reduced and irreducible; equivalently every nonempty affine open subscheme is the spectrum of a domain (Integral schemes).

[F16]

A Noetherian normal scheme has a finite affine open cover by spectra of Noetherian rings; normal means every local ring OX,x is an integrally closed domain, and the local ring at the generic point of a prime divisor is a one-dimensional local ring (Locally Noetherian and Noetherian schemes, Weil divisor normal noetherian scheme).

[F17]

On an integral scheme, D↦[OX(D)] is a homomorphism CaDiv⁡(X)→Pic⁡(X) with kernel exactly the principal Cartier divisors; hence every principal Cartier divisor has trivial associated invertible sheaf (On an integral scheme, Cartier divisors modulo principal divisors compute the Picard group).

[F18]

Every point of an open subset of an affine spectrum has a distinguished-open neighbourhood contained in that subset; localizations of Noetherian rings are Noetherian. (Every point of a Zariski-open set has a distinguished-open neighbourhood inside it, Every quotient and every localisation of a Noetherian ring is Noetherian)

Proof

1.1F1F2F5F15

Setup and a rational section. Assume AC; by [F2] DC holds, so the DC-based statements [F3], [F4] and [F10] apply. Since X is integral and nonempty by [F15], and L is invertible, [F5] makes KX(L) the constant sheaf with value the one-dimensional nonzero K(X)-vector space Lη; choose a nonzero element s of Lη, viewed as a rational section of L (a single selection from a nonempty set).

1.2F4F8F11F12F13F14F15F16F18

A Cartier divisor with zero associated Weil divisor is zero. Let E be any Cartier divisor with cyc⁡(E)=0. By [F8] it has an open cover on which it is represented by single meromorphic equations. Intersect this cover with a cover by Noetherian affine charts from [F16]. Within each such chart, [F18] refines the intersections by distinguished opens, whose coordinate rings are Noetherian localizations. Since X is quasi-compact by [F16], a finite subcover X=U1∪⋯∪Uk suffices. Write Uj=Spec⁡Rj, with Rj Noetherian, and retain on Uj the equation restricted from its containing Cartier-trivializing open; each Rj is a domain by [F15], and each Rj is integrally closed: every localisation Rj,p=OX,p is integrally closed by the normality in [F16], so Rj is integrally closed by [F14]; in particular each Rj satisfies (S2) by [F12]. Fix j and restrict E to Uj; by the chosen refinement and [F8], this restriction is represented by a local equation g∈KX(Uj)×=K(X)×, the equality holding because X is integral by [F15]. For every height-one prime q of Rj the closure Zq of q in X is a prime divisor with generic point q, and the coefficient of cyc⁡(E)=0 at Zq is vq(g) by [F4], hence vq(g)=0; by [F11] this means that g is a unit of the discrete valuation ring Rj,q=OX,q. Applying the same argument to g−1∈K(X)×, whose valuations are vq(g−1)=−vq(g)=0, shows that g−1 is a unit of Rj,q for every height-one q as well, so both g and g−1 lie in ⋂ht⁡q=1Rj,q=Rj by the (S2) intersection [F13]; hence g∈Rj× is a unit of Rj. The restriction E∣Uj is therefore represented by a unit equation, so E∣Uj=0 by [F8]; as the finitely many Uj cover X, locality in [F8] gives E=0.

2.1F3F6F9step 1.1

The divisor of the section. By [F6] the rational section s has a Cartier divisor D:=div⁡C(s) on X together with a canonical isomorphism OX(D)→L; hence [L]=[OX(D)] in Pic⁡(X) by [F9], and the canonical homomorphism of [F3] carries [L]=[OX(D)] to the class [cyc⁡(D)]∈Cl⁡(X). Since [L] lies in the kernel of that homomorphism by hypothesis, [cyc⁡(D)]=0 in Cl⁡(X).

3.1F3F7F8F10step 2.1

Subtracting a principal divisor. By [F10] the vanishing of the class of cyc⁡(D) means that cyc⁡(D) is a principal Weil divisor: there is f∈K(X)× with cyc⁡(D)=div⁡W(f). Put E:=D−div⁡C(f)∈CaDiv⁡(X), using that div⁡C(f) is a Cartier divisor and that CaDiv⁡(X) is a group by [F7] and [F8]; then by the additivity in [F3] and the identity cyc⁡(div⁡C(f))=div⁡W(f), cyc⁡(E)=cyc⁡(D)−cyc⁡(div⁡C(f))=div⁡W(f)−div⁡W(f)=0∈Div⁡(X).

4.1F9F17step 2.1step 3.1step 1.2∎

Injectivity. Applying step 1.2 to the divisor E=D−div⁡C(f) of step 3.1 gives D=div⁡C(f), so D is a principal Cartier divisor; by [F17] its associated invertible sheaf is trivial, [OX(D)]=[OX], and hence [L]=[OX(D)]=[OX] by step 2.1. Since L was an arbitrary invertible sheaf in the kernel of the canonical homomorphism, that homomorphism is injective.

The Axiom of Choice enters exactly through [F12], [F13] and [F14], and through the implication AC⇒DC of [F2] that supplies [F3], [F4] and [F10]; the only selection performed in the proof is the single nonzero rational section of step 1.1. When X has no prime divisors, the intersections of [F13] are empty and interpreted as K=Rj, so the argument still shows that any Cartier divisor with vanishing associated Weil divisor is represented by units; when Cl⁡(X) is trivial this makes the injectivity statement vacuous. The result is the injectivity half of the classical comparison between the Picard group and the Weil divisor class group of a normal Noetherian integral scheme.

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

105 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources