How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Under AC, the Picard-to-class-group map is injective on normal Noetherian integral schemes
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Choice (The Axiom of Choice). Let be a normal Noetherian integral scheme (Weil divisor normal noetherian scheme, Integral schemes). Then the canonical homomorphism of The Cartier-to-Weil map respects addition and principal divisors, which sends the class of a Cartier divisor to the class of its associated Weil divisor (Cartier divisors on a normal Noetherian scheme give Weil divisors), is injective. Moreover, the Cartier-to-Weil cycle homomorphism itself is injective: if a Cartier divisor satisfies , then .
The Axiom of Choice is used exactly through the normality and inputs normal domain implies s two, r one s two intersection of height one localisations and A domain is integrally closed if and only if its prime localisations are, equivalently if and only if its maximal localisations are, which assume it, and through the implication (AC implies DC implies countable choice) that makes the Dependent-Choice suppliers available.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: a normal Noetherian integral scheme and an invertible -module whose class in lies in the kernel of the canonical homomorphism .
The Axiom of Choice is the statement that every family of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Choice).
, and DC includes a prescribed initial point (AC implies DC implies countable choice).
Assume DC. For a normal Noetherian integral scheme , the associated Weil divisor satisfies , and for Cartier divisors , while for ; there is a canonical homomorphism carrying to the class of (The Cartier-to-Weil map respects addition and principal divisors).
Assume DC. Let be a normal Noetherian scheme and let be a Cartier divisor represented by local equations . For every prime divisor with generic point and every index with , the coefficient of at is , the value of the normalized valuation of the discrete valuation ring , and this is independent of and of the local-equation datum (Cartier divisors on a normal Noetherian scheme give Weil divisors).
Let be an integral scheme with generic point and invertible. Then is the constant sheaf with value the stalk , a one-dimensional -vector space, so it is nonzero; a rational section of is by definition a nonzero element of this vector space (Rational section line bundle).
Let be integral, invertible and a rational section of . Then is a well-defined Cartier divisor on , there is a canonical isomorphism carrying to , and for every Cartier divisor the canonical section satisfies (Rational sections of line bundles are Cartier divisors).
For the principal Cartier divisor is represented by the single global equation , and principal Cartier divisors form a subgroup of (Principal cartier divisor).
Cartier divisors on form an abelian group and are represented on open covers by meromorphic units with unit ratios; a divisor represented by unit equations is the zero divisor, and a divisor whose restriction to every member of an open cover is zero is zero (Cartier divisor).
The Picard group is the group of isomorphism classes of invertible -modules, with identity (Picard group of a scheme).
Assume DC. On a normal Noetherian integral scheme one has , the map is a group homomorphism with image the subgroup of principal Weil divisors, and ; consequently a Weil divisor has zero class exactly when it is of the form for some (Principal weil divisor and class group).
For a prime divisor with generic point the order of vanishing is , and in the case of an integral normal locally Noetherian scheme for if and only if is a unit of (Order codimension one rational function).
Assume AC. Every commutative Noetherian integrally closed domain satisfies (normal domain implies s two).
Assume AC. If is a commutative Noetherian domain satisfying , then inside its fraction field one has ; for a field the empty intersection is interpreted as (r one s two intersection of height one localisations).
Assume AC. A domain is integrally closed if and only if every localisation at a prime ideal is integrally closed (A domain is integrally closed if and only if its prime localisations are, equivalently if and only if its maximal localisations are).
An integral scheme is nonempty, reduced and irreducible; equivalently every nonempty affine open subscheme is the spectrum of a domain (Integral schemes).
A Noetherian normal scheme has a finite affine open cover by spectra of Noetherian rings; normal means every local ring is an integrally closed domain, and the local ring at the generic point of a prime divisor is a one-dimensional local ring (Locally Noetherian and Noetherian schemes, Weil divisor normal noetherian scheme).
On an integral scheme, is a homomorphism with kernel exactly the principal Cartier divisors; hence every principal Cartier divisor has trivial associated invertible sheaf (On an integral scheme, Cartier divisors modulo principal divisors compute the Picard group).
Every point of an open subset of an affine spectrum has a distinguished-open neighbourhood contained in that subset; localizations of Noetherian rings are Noetherian. (Every point of a Zariski-open set has a distinguished-open neighbourhood inside it, Every quotient and every localisation of a Noetherian ring is Noetherian)
Proof
Setup and a rational section. Assume AC; by [F2] DC holds, so the DC-based statements [F3], [F4] and [F10] apply. Since is integral and nonempty by [F15], and is invertible, [F5] makes the constant sheaf with value the one-dimensional nonzero -vector space ; choose a nonzero element of , viewed as a rational section of (a single selection from a nonempty set).
A Cartier divisor with zero associated Weil divisor is zero. Let be any Cartier divisor with . By [F8] it has an open cover on which it is represented by single meromorphic equations. Intersect this cover with a cover by Noetherian affine charts from [F16]. Within each such chart, [F18] refines the intersections by distinguished opens, whose coordinate rings are Noetherian localizations. Since is quasi-compact by [F16], a finite subcover suffices. Write , with Noetherian, and retain on the equation restricted from its containing Cartier-trivializing open; each is a domain by [F15], and each is integrally closed: every localisation is integrally closed by the normality in [F16], so is integrally closed by [F14]; in particular each satisfies by [F12]. Fix and restrict to ; by the chosen refinement and [F8], this restriction is represented by a local equation , the equality holding because is integral by [F15]. For every height-one prime of the closure of in is a prime divisor with generic point , and the coefficient of at is by [F4], hence ; by [F11] this means that is a unit of the discrete valuation ring . Applying the same argument to , whose valuations are , shows that is a unit of for every height-one as well, so both and lie in by the intersection [F13]; hence is a unit of . The restriction is therefore represented by a unit equation, so by [F8]; as the finitely many cover , locality in [F8] gives .
The divisor of the section. By [F6] the rational section has a Cartier divisor on together with a canonical isomorphism ; hence in by [F9], and the canonical homomorphism of [F3] carries to the class . Since lies in the kernel of that homomorphism by hypothesis, in .
Subtracting a principal divisor. By [F10] the vanishing of the class of means that is a principal Weil divisor: there is with . Put , using that is a Cartier divisor and that is a group by [F7] and [F8]; then by the additivity in [F3] and the identity ,
Injectivity. Applying step 1.2 to the divisor of step 3.1 gives , so is a principal Cartier divisor; by [F17] its associated invertible sheaf is trivial, , and hence by step 2.1. Since was an arbitrary invertible sheaf in the kernel of the canonical homomorphism, that homomorphism is injective.
The Axiom of Choice enters exactly through [F12], [F13] and [F14], and through the implication of [F2] that supplies [F3], [F4] and [F10]; the only selection performed in the proof is the single nonzero rational section of step 1.1. When has no prime divisors, the intersections of [F13] are empty and interpreted as , so the argument still shows that any Cartier divisor with vanishing associated Weil divisor is represented by units; when is trivial this makes the injectivity statement vacuous. The result is the injectivity half of the classical comparison between the Picard group and the Weil divisor class group of a normal Noetherian integral scheme.
Depends on
- The Axiom of Choice
- AC implies DC implies countable choice
- The Cartier-to-Weil map respects addition and principal divisors
- Cartier divisors on a normal Noetherian scheme give Weil divisors
- Rational section line bundle
- Rational sections of line bundles are Cartier divisors
- Principal cartier divisor
- Cartier divisor
- Picard group of a scheme
- Principal weil divisor and class group
- Order codimension one rational function
- normal domain implies s two
- r one s two intersection of height one localisations
- A domain is integrally closed if and only if its prime localisations are, equivalently if and only if its maximal localisations are
- Integral schemes
- Weil divisor normal noetherian scheme
- Locally Noetherian and Noetherian schemes
- On an integral scheme, Cartier divisors modulo principal divisors compute the Picard group
- Every point of a Zariski-open set has a distinguished-open neighbourhood inside it
- Every quotient and every localisation of a Noetherian ring is Noetherian
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
105 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- The Stacks Project, Divisors, Lemma 31.28.6 (Tag 0BE8: for normal X the map Pic(X) to Cl(X) is injective) and Definition 31.28.4 (Tag 0BE6) (standard reference, not scraped)
- J. S. Milne, Algebraic Geometry, Ch. 12 §§12.1-12.9 (divisors, the class group and the Picard group) (standard reference, not scraped)