Alphabeta Math
TheoremStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generated
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Finite generation of invariants and the affine categorical quotient

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Choice inherited from the named suppliers. Let G be a complex reductive affine algebraic group and let X be an affine algebraic set with an algebraic G-action (Classical complex affine algebraic actions and rational modules). Then: (i) C[X]G is a finitely generated C-algebra; (ii) for any finite generating set f1,…,fn of C[X]G the image of the morphism X→Cn, x↦(f1(x),…,fn(x)), is closed and is canonically isomorphic to the affine variety with coordinate ring C[X]G, so the quotient is independent of generators up to this canonical isomorphism; (iii) the resulting surjective G-invariant morphism π:X→X/ ⁣/G:=Spec⁡C[X]G is a categorical quotient (Categorical and geometric quotients of classical varieties); (iv) for every closed G-stable subset Y⊆X the induced morphism Y/ ⁣/G→X/ ⁣/G is a closed immersion, and for closed G-stable Y,Y′⊆X one has π(Y∩Y′)=π(Y)∩π(Y′); (v) every fibre of π contains exactly one closed G-orbit; (vi) if X is irreducible then so is X/ ⁣/G, and if in addition X is normal then so is X/ ⁣/G.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: AC; a complex reductive affine algebraic group G; an affine algebraic set X with algebraic G-action; A=C[X] and its invariant subalgebra AG; a finite generating set f1,…,fn of AG when mentioned; the Reynolds operator RX:A→AG.

[F1]

Invariants of a finite-dimensional module. If V is a finite-dimensional rational G-module, then C[V]G is a finitely generated C-algebra (Invariants of a finite-dimensional module are finitely generated).

[F2]

Reynolds ideal theory. For every ideal I⊆AG one has RX(IA)=I, the extension I↦IA is injective on ideals of AG, and if φ:A→B is a surjective G-equivariant homomorphism of rational G-algebras then φ(AG)=BG (The Reynolds operator and the ideal theory of the invariant subring). The Reynolds operator is natural under equivariant maps and linear over invariant elements (Complete reducibility and the Reynolds operator for a complex reductive group).

[F3]

Equivariant linear embedding. There is a finite-dimensional rational submodule W⊆A generating A such that evaluation is an equivariant isomorphism of X onto a closed invariant subset of W∗, so that the coordinate map C[W∗]→A is a surjective G-algebra map (Every complex affine algebraic action has a finite-dimensional equivariant closed embedding).

[F4]

Nullstellensatz correspondence. Radical ideals of a coordinate ring correspond to closed subsets of the affine algebraic set, points to maximal ideals, and a point lies in a closed set exactly when its maximal ideal contains the radical ideal of the set (Classical affine algebraic sets correspond to radical ideals, and irreducible sets to prime ideals).

[F5]

Morphisms and coordinate rings. Pullback is a natural bijection between morphisms of affine algebraic sets and unital k-algebra maps of coordinate rings, reversing composition (Classical affine morphisms are contravariantly equivalent to coordinate-ring homomorphisms).

[F6]

Maximal ideals. In a nonzero commutative ring every proper ideal is contained in a maximal ideal (In a nonzero commutative ring, every proper ideal is contained in a maximal ideal, AC).

[F7]

Closed orbits exist in closures. Every orbit of minimal dimension in X is closed, and every orbit closure contains a closed orbit (Orbit dimension and closed orbits for complex group actions, (c)).

[F8]

Categorical quotients. A G-invariant morphism π:X→Y is a categorical quotient if every G-invariant morphism f:X→Z of classical varieties factors uniquely as f=φ∘π with φ:Y→Z a morphism (Categorical and geometric quotients of classical varieties).

[F9]

Normality is integral closedness. For a domain A, being integrally closed is equivalent to every prime localisation being integrally closed (A domain is integrally closed if and only if its prime localisations are, equivalently if and only if its maximal localisations are), and normality of an irreducible affine variety means that its coordinate domain is integrally closed in its fraction field (Normal points and normal varieties, Integral closure in an extension ring and integrally closed domains).

[F10]

Principal opens and their functions. For an affine algebraic set T with coordinate ring B, the principal open DT(g) is affine: the map t↦(t,1/g(t)) identifies it with the closed set g(t)u=1 in T×A1, with inverse the first projection. Its regular-function algebra is Bg (Regular functions on a principal open are the principal localization). Principal opens form a basis, since a point outside a polynomial zero locus has some defining polynomial nonzero there.

Proof

technique · direct
1.1F1F2F3

Part (i): by [F3] there is a finite-dimensional rational module W and a surjective G-algebra map C[W∗]→A; by [F1] the invariant algebra C[W∗]G is finitely generated over C; by the surjectivity statement of [F2] the induced map C[W∗]G→AG is surjective. Hence AG is a finitely generated C-algebra.

2.1F2step 1.1

The localisation identity: for f∈AG, the algebra Af is rational, since each fraction a/fm lies in the image of a finite-dimensional rational submodule containing a, divided by the invariant fm. Thus the Reynolds operator exists on Af. Naturality under A→Af and linearity over the invariant invertible element f give RAf(a/fm)=RA(a)/fm. If a/fm is invariant, it is fixed by RAf and hence has an invariant numerator. Conversely every fraction with invariant numerator is invariant. The natural map (AG)f→Af is injective: if a∈AG is killed by a power of f in A, the same equation holds in the subring AG. Hence (Af)G=(AG)f, without asserting injectivity of the unlocalized map AG→Af.

2.2F2F4F5F6step 1.1

Parts (ii) and (iii), core: let I⊆AG be a maximal ideal and put J=IA. Then J∩AG=RX(J)=I≠AG by [F2], so J is a proper ideal of A; by [F6] it lies in a maximal ideal m of A. The contraction m∩AG is proper and contains I, so maximality of I gives m∩AG=I. By the correspondence [F4] the maximal ideal m is a point x∈X with π(x)=I. Thus π:X→Spec⁡AG is surjective. For a finite generating set f1,…,fn of AG, let P=C[t1,…,tn] and map ti↦fi; this is surjective onto AG. The subring AG of the reduced ring A is reduced, so this kernel is radical; [F4] identifies its zero locus with the coordinate-ring model, giving a closed embedding Spec⁡AG↪Cn. The morphism in (ii) is the composite of the surjective π with this closed embedding, so its image is exactly that closed affine subvariety. If a different generating set is chosen, both closed images represent Spec⁡AG via their coordinate-ring maps, and [F5] gives the canonical isomorphism between them.

2.3F4F9step 1.1

Part (vi): if X is irreducible then A is a domain by [F4], and AG is a subring of a domain, hence a domain, so X/ ⁣/G=Spec⁡AG is irreducible. If in addition X is normal, then A is integrally closed in F(A); let u∈Frac⁡(AG) be integral over AG. Since Frac⁡(AG)⊆Frac⁡(A)G, the element u lies in Frac⁡(A) and is integral over A, so u∈A; being fixed by G, it lies in AG. Hence AG is integrally closed in its fraction field, and by [F9] the variety X/ ⁣/G is normal.

3.1F2F4F5F6step 2.2

Part (iv): let Y⊆X be closed and G-stable with radical ideal IY⊆A. The quotient map A→A/IY is surjective and G-equivariant, so by [F2] the induced map AG→(A/IY)G is surjective with kernel IY∩AG; by [F5] the corresponding morphism Y/ ⁣/G=Spec⁡(A/IY)G→Spec⁡AG=X/ ⁣/G is a closed immersion. For closed G-stable Y,Y′ and a point q∈X/ ⁣/G with maximal ideal m⊆AG, one has q∈π(Y)∩π(Y′) exactly when both IY+mA and IY′+mA are proper. If they are, then IY+IY′+mA is proper: otherwise 1=a+b+c with a∈IY, b∈IY′, c∈mA, and applying RX, which maps IY into IY∩AG⊆m, IY′ into m and mA onto m, would give 1∈m. A maximal ideal containing this proper ideal is a point of Y∩Y′ mapping to q, so q∈π(Y∩Y′); the reverse inclusion is immediate.

4.1F7step 2.2step 3.1

Part (v): each fibre π−1(q) is nonempty by surjectivity of step 2.2, closed and G-stable; it contains a closed orbit by [F7]. If it contained two distinct closed orbits Gx,Gx′, then applying part (iv) of step 3.1 to the closed G-stable sets Gx and Gx′ gives π(Gx)∩π(Gx′)=π(Gx∩Gx′)=∅, contradicting that both contain q. Hence each fibre contains exactly one closed orbit.

5.1F4F5F8F10step 2.1step 3.1step 4.1

Part (iii), full universality: let h:X→Z be a G-invariant morphism to a separated classical variety Z. First, h is constant on every fibre of π: for y in a fibre, h is constant on the closure of the orbit Gy, because the preimage of the value h(y) is closed in X and contains Gy; that closure lies in the fibre, which is closed and G-stable, and contains the unique closed orbit of the fibre by step 4.1, so h(y) equals the value on that orbit, the same value on every point of the fibre. Write hˉ for the induced map on X/ ⁣/G. For q∈X/ ⁣/G choose an affine chart V⊆Z containing hˉ(q); the closed G-stable set C=h−1(Z∖V) has closed image π(C) by step 3.1, and q∉π(C) because the whole fibre of q maps into V. A regular function g∈AG vanishes on π(C) and is nonzero at q by the correspondence [F4]; then h maps the principal open Xg=π−1(D(g)) into V, each coordinate of h∣Xg is an invariant regular function on the affine open Xg, hence lies in (Ag)G=(AG)g by [F10] and step 2.1, and the dictionary [F5] produces a morphism D(g)→V inducing hˉ. These local morphisms agree on overlaps, since π is surjective, so they glue to a morphism hˉ:X/ ⁣/G→Z with hˉ∘π=h; uniqueness is surjectivity of π. Thus π is a categorical quotient, and (ii) follows from the same dictionary because any two finite generating sets present Spec⁡AG canonically.

6.1F1F2F4F9step 1.1step 2.2step 3.1step 4.1step 5.1step 2.3∎

Assembly and conventions: (i) is step 1.1, (ii) and (iii) are steps 2.2 and 5.1, (iv) is step 3.1, (v) is step 4.1 and (vi) is step 2.3. In the classical register, Spec⁡ of a finitely generated reduced complex algebra denotes the affine variety of its complex closed points with the classical regular-function sheaf, and no identification with the space of all scheme primes is used. If X=∅ then A=0, the invariant algebra is zero, finite generation is immediate, X/ ⁣/G=∅, and the fibre assertions are vacuous; the maximal-ideal argument above concerns nonempty X. The Axiom of Choice is inherited from the embedding, Reynolds, Nullstellensatz and normality suppliers named above. This proves all six clauses.

Remarks

  • This is Brion's proof of Theorem 1.24 (printed pp. 8-9) with the two reductions isolated above: finite generation passes through an equivariant linear embedding and the finite-dimensional case, while surjectivity, closedness and the fibre statements pass through the maximal-ideal extension I↦IA and the radical-safe intersection argument.
  • The full classical universality in (iii) replaces Brion's affine-target formulation by the descent argument of step 5.1; this is the strengthened statement used by the projective GIT consumers downstream.
  • AC enters only through the named suppliers; the ideal-theoretic computations themselves are choice-free.

Depends on

Used by

Cited to discharge well-definedness by Categorical and geometric quotients of classical varieties.

Dependency tree · two levels

97 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources