How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Ample divisors meet nonzero effective divisors positively
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Choice (The Axiom of Choice). Let be a field, let be an integral smooth projective surface over (Intersection numbers of Cartier divisors on a smooth projective surface) and let be an ample invertible -module (Absolute ampleness by affine section opens).
- If is a nonzero effective Cartier divisor (Effective cartier divisor), then .
- Consequently .
- If is an invertible -module (Invertible sheaves) and is a nonzero global section with zero scheme (Zero scheme of a line-bundle section), then , and unless and . In particular, if and is not numerically trivial, then .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: a field , an integral smooth projective surface over , an ample invertible -module , a nonzero effective Cartier divisor , and (for part 3) an invertible sheaf with a nonzero global section .
is projective over in the H-projective convention, hence proper over (Projective morphisms are proper) and of finite type, so it is Noetherian and locally Noetherian; coherent -modules have finite-dimensional cohomology and a well-defined Euler characteristic (Euler characteristic of a coherent sheaf, Intersection numbers of Cartier divisors on a smooth projective surface). The intersection product on invertible sheaves and Cartier divisors is symmetric and -bilinear, vanishes against , and depends only on the isomorphism classes of the entries (Intersection numbers of Cartier divisors on a smooth projective surface, The surface intersection product is symmetric and bilinear).
For an effective Cartier divisor on and any Cartier divisor one has , the degree being of Degree of an invertible sheaf on a proper one-dimensional scheme on the proper curve (Intersection with a curve is the degree of the restriction).
A nonzero effective Cartier divisor on the surface is nonempty and has pure dimension one. Nonemptiness: the vanishing subscheme is empty exactly for the zero divisor (Effective cartier divisor). Dimension: on an affine chart meeting , the coordinate ring is a finite-type -domain of dimension two, and at a closed point with maximal ideal one has (Maximal ideals of an affine domain have full height); the local equation of at is a nonzerodivisor and a nonunit, so every prime minimal over has height one (A minimal prime over a principal nonzerodivisor has height one) and (Height plus quotient dimension equals ambient dimension in an affine domain); hence has dimension one, and it has dimension at most one everywhere by the same height computation on the remaining charts (Chain dimension and the empty-space convention, A Zariski-closed subset is irreducible exactly when its radical defining ideal is prime, and then it has a unique generic point). Thus is a proper -scheme of pure dimension one (Projective morphisms are proper), and for the very ample embedding used below the coherent sheaf is nonzero with (Integral schemes).
Very ample powers: since is Noetherian, is proper of finite type and is ample, there is an integer such that is closed H-very ample relative to (High powers of an ample line bundle embed a proper scheme); by definition this means that for some there is a closed immersion with (Relative very ampleness in the finite projective-space convention). Fix such and write for the embedding .
Hilbert polynomial: for a coherent -module and the twist the function is a polynomial of degree , with exact degree and nonzero leading coefficient when , and for (Hilbert function and Euler characteristic on a projective scheme, Euler characteristic is a Hilbert polynomial, Degree of the coherent Hilbert polynomial). Moreover for all higher cohomology of vanishes (Serre vanishing for coherent sheaves and ample twists).
For a closed immersion and an invertible sheaf on , the projection formula gives and for every integer (Projection formula for a closed immersion and an invertible sheaf).
A nonzero global section of an invertible sheaf on the integral scheme is a regular section, its zero scheme is an effective Cartier divisor with and exactly when is nowhere vanishing, in which case (A regular global section of an invertible sheaf glues to an effective Cartier divisor, Zero scheme of a line-bundle section).
The Axiom of Choice is inherited from the cohomology, Hilbert-polynomial and ample-embedding suppliers of [F4]–[F6]; the divisor , the section and the embedding are given data, and only finitely many sheaves and Hilbert-polynomial values are used below.
Proof
Reduction to a very ample power. Fix , and the closed immersion with supplied by [F4], and put . Since the intersection product is -bilinear, for every Cartier divisor ; hence , and for part 1 it suffices to prove for every nonzero effective Cartier divisor .
The Hilbert polynomial of the curve. Let be the nonzero effective Cartier divisor and put , a nonzero coherent sheaf on with support of dimension one by [F3]. For the fixed embedding with , [F5] and [F6] give for every integer . This polynomial has exact degree one, so with . For large it equals , so .
The intersection number is the leading coefficient. Since is linear, . By step 1.2, and ; by the degree formula of [F2] applied to the effective Cartier divisor , This proves part 1 for and hence, by step 1.1, for the given ample : .
Positive self-intersection. Apply [F5] to with the same embedding and . Its support is the surface , so its Hilbert polynomial has exact degree two, say with . Since for large , one has . The defining intersection expression gives Bilinearity then gives . This proves part 2 over every field without choosing a rational point or a hyperplane through one.
The section criterion. Let be invertible with a nonzero global section . By [F7] the zero scheme is an effective Cartier divisor with . If , then is a nonzero effective Cartier divisor and part 1 gives by symmetry. If , then is nowhere vanishing, so trivialises , , and ; in this case is numerically trivial. Hence always, with equality only in the stated case, and if for a numerically nontrivial then any nonzero section has nonempty zero scheme and .
Choice accounting and conclusion. Steps 1.1 and 2.1 prove part 1, step 2.2 proves part 2, and step 3.1 proves part 3. The Axiom of Choice is used through the cohomology, Serre-vanishing and Hilbert-polynomial suppliers recorded in [F8], which underlie the very ample embedding and the finiteness of cohomology; the divisors and the section are single given objects, and no family is selected.
Depends on
- Maximal ideals of an affine domain have full height
- Height plus quotient dimension equals ambient dimension in an affine domain
- A minimal prime over a principal nonzerodivisor has height one
- Absolute ampleness by affine section opens
- The Axiom of Choice
- Degree of an invertible sheaf on a proper one-dimensional scheme
- Chain dimension and the empty-space convention
- Intersection numbers of Cartier divisors on a smooth projective surface
- Effective cartier divisor
- Euler characteristic of a coherent sheaf
- Hilbert function and Euler characteristic on a projective scheme
- Integral schemes
- Invertible sheaves
- Zero scheme of a line-bundle section
- Relative very ampleness in the finite projective-space convention
- Projection formula for a closed immersion and an invertible sheaf
- A regular global section of an invertible sheaf glues to an effective Cartier divisor
- Relative very ampleness implies relative ampleness
- High powers of an ample line bundle embed a proper scheme
- Euler characteristic is a Hilbert polynomial
- Degree of the coherent Hilbert polynomial
- Intersection with a curve is the degree of the restriction
- A Zariski-closed subset is irreducible exactly when its radical defining ideal is prime, and then it has a unique generic point
- Projective morphisms are proper
- Serre vanishing for coherent sheaves and ample twists
- The surface intersection product is symmetric and bilinear
Used by
- The intersection form is not negative definite on all divisor classes Counterexample
- The Hodge index theorem on a blowup of the projective plane Example
- Vanishing of top cohomology past the canonical threshold Lemma
- Conventions and hypothesis bookkeeping for surface Riemann-Roch and Hodge index Remark
- The Hodge index theorem for an ample class Theorem
- The Hodge index theorem for smooth projective surfaces Theorem
Dependency tree · two levels
155 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- Ravi Vakil, The Rising Sea: Foundations of Algebraic Geometry, pre-publication version 2025-10-21 (standard reference, not scraped)
- The Stacks Project, Varieties, Section 33.45 (Numerical intersections) (standard reference, not scraped)