Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedjudge pass (gpt-6.1-sol)
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The product of two projective lines is an integral smooth projective surface

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Choice (The Axiom of Choice). Let k be a field and let X=Pk1×Spec⁡kPk1 with projections pr1,pr2 (Relative projective space from standard charts). Then X is an integral (Integral schemes) smooth (Smoothness over a field by geometric regularity) projective (Projective morphisms before Proj) k-scheme of pure dimension two (Chain dimension and the empty-space convention); in particular X is a smooth projective surface over k (Intersection numbers of Cartier divisors on a smooth projective surface). The projections are flat (Flat morphism of schemes), proper (Proper morphisms), and of finite presentation (Locally finite presentation morphisms), and the structure morphism X→Spec⁡k is proper.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: a field k and the product X=Pk1×Spec⁡kPk1 with its projections.

[F1]

Chart data: the projective line has the two standard charts U0=Spec⁡k[t] and U1=Spec⁡k[u], glued along D(t)=D(u) by t=u−1 (Two-affine projective line and its twists, Relative projective space from standard charts). In particular Pk1 is covered by two affine schemes and the structure morphism Pk1→Spec⁡k is quasi-compact.

[F3]

Gluing fibre products: products of the open pieces glue to the fibre product, with no separatedness hypothesis (Gluing fibre products along open covers).

[F4]

Irreducibility: a nonempty topological space is irreducible exactly when every two of its nonempty open subsets meet (Irreducibility via nonempty open subsets, connectedness and open subspaces). For a domain A the spectrum Spec⁡A is irreducible with generic point the zero ideal, and irreducible closed subsets correspond to prime ideals (A Zariski-closed subset is irreducible exactly when its radical defining ideal is prime, and then it has a unique generic point); a scheme is integral when it is nonempty, reduced and irreducible (Integral schemes), and reducedness means the nilpotent ideal sheaf vanishes, equivalently all local rings are reduced (The reduction of a scheme).

[F5]

Dimension: for a Noetherian space covered by finitely many open subspaces, the chain dimension is the supremum of the dimensions of the pieces (Dimension can be computed on an open cover, Chain dimension and the empty-space convention).

[F6]

Smoothness: Pk1 is a smooth curve over k (Projective-line curve and divisor basics), Pk1→Spec⁡k is of finite type (Projective space is of finite type over its base), and for any field k and finite-type k-schemes X,Y smooth over k, the product X×kY is smooth over k in the local-standard-smooth convention; a product of finite-type k-schemes is of finite type over k (Products preserve smoothness, Finite type under base change and products over a field, Smoothness over a field by geometric regularity).

[F7]

Projectivity: for m=n=1 and S=Spec⁡k the Segre construction gives a closed immersion σ:X↪Pk3 with σ∗O(1)≅pr1∗O(1)⊗pr2∗O(1) (Segre embedding and its line bundle); composing with the projection exhibits the structure morphism X→Spec⁡k as projective in the H-projective convention, hence proper (Projective morphisms before Proj, Projective morphisms are proper).

[F8]

Projections of the product: Pk1→Spec⁡k is flat, because its two standard charts are standard smooth k-algebras and standard smooth algebras are flat (Standard smooth algebras are finitely presented and flat, Flat morphism of schemes); it is proper (Finite-dimensional projective space is proper over every base) and locally of finite presentation, its charts being finitely presented k-algebras (Standard smooth algebras are finitely presented and flat, Locally finite presentation morphisms). Each projection pri is the base change of this morphism along the structure morphism of the other factor, hence flat (Flatness is stable under arbitrary base change), proper (Properness survives arbitrary base change) and locally of finite presentation (Local finiteness conditions under base change); it is quasi-compact because the preimage of each standard chart is the union of the two affine charts lying over it (Quasi-compact and quasi-separated morphisms). Hence each projection is of finite presentation.

[F9]

The Axiom of Choice is inherited from the scheme, product and Segre suppliers above; only the two-element chart cover and the four chart products are used below.

Proof

technique · direct: compute on the four standard product charts, use their common generic point for irreducibility, then product-stability and the Segre embedding for smoothness, projectivity and properness
1.1F1F2F3

Charts and their coordinate rings. By [F1] the standard charts U0,U1 cover Pk1 and meet in Spec⁡k[t,t−1]=Spec⁡k[u,u−1] with t=u−1. For i,j∈{0,1} put Cij:=Ui×kUj; by [F3] these four products exist and form an open cover of X=Pk1×kPk1. Each Cij is affine: by [F2] it is Spec⁡(k[t]⊗kk[u])≅Spec⁡k[t,u], the isomorphism with the iterated polynomial ring being the one fixed in [F2], and Cij∩Ckl corresponds to a localization of k[t,u].

2.1F1F2F4step 1.1

Irreducibility and nonemptiness. Each chart Cij is the spectrum of the domain k[t,u] [F2], hence irreducible with generic point the zero ideal, and nonempty. On each nonempty overlap Cij∩Ckl, which is a localization of the domain k[t,u] and therefore again a domain, the generic points of the two charts restrict to the generic point of the overlap: passing to the localization of the zero ideal gives the zero ideal, and the gluing identifies the overlap with a localization compatibly with the chart isomorphisms. Consequently the four chart generic points are compatible and define a single point ξ∈X lying in every chart. Every nonempty open subset U⊆X meets some chart Cij in a nonempty open subset, which is a nonempty open subset of the irreducible chart Cij and hence contains its generic point ξ. Therefore any two nonempty open subsets of X meet, and X≠∅; by [F4] the space X is irreducible.

3.1F2F4step 1.1step 2.1

Reducedness. Every local ring OX,x is a local ring of one of the charts Cij, which are spectra of the domain k[t,u]; localizations of a domain are domains, hence reduced. So the nilpotent ideal sheaf of X vanishes and X is reduced [F4]. Together with step 2.1 this makes X an integral scheme [F4], and by [F2] the charts are Noetherian, so X is a Noetherian space.

4.1F2F5step 1.1step 2.1step 3.1

Dimension. Each chart Cij is Spec⁡k[t,u], whose chain dimension is the Krull dimension of k[t,u], namely two [F2], and whose coordinate ring is Noetherian [F2]; the finite cover by the four charts exhibits X as a Noetherian space, so [F5] gives dim⁡X=sup⁡ijdim⁡Cij=2. Since X is irreducible by step 2.1, it has pure dimension two.

5.1F6step 1.1step 4.1

Smoothness. By [F6] the projective line is smooth over k and of finite type, so X is of finite type over k [F6] and smooth over k by the second clause of the product-stability theorem [F6]; in particular every local ring of X is regular [F6]. In particular X is a smooth projective surface once projectivity is established.

6.1F1F7F8step 5.1

Projectivity, properness and the projections. By [F7] with m=n=1, S=Spec⁡k there is a closed immersion σ:X↪Pk3 with σ∗O(1)≅pr1∗O(1)⊗pr2∗O(1); composing σ with the projection Pk3→Spec⁡k, which is projective by the identity closed immersion, exhibits X→Spec⁡k as H-projective, hence proper [F7]. For the projections: pri is the base change of the flat, proper, locally finitely presented morphism Pk1→Spec⁡k along the structure morphism of the other factor [F8], so it is flat, proper and locally of finite presentation, and it is quasi-compact because the preimage of each standard chart is a union of two of the four affine charts [F8], [F1]; hence each projection is of finite presentation.

7.1F9step 4.1step 5.1step 6.1∎

Conclusion and choice accounting. Steps 1.1–3.1 exhibit X as an integral k-scheme of pure dimension two with Noetherian affine charts, step 5.1 shows it is smooth over k, and step 6.1 shows the structure morphism is projective hence proper and that the projections are flat, proper and of finite presentation. The Axiom of Choice is inherited from the suppliers recorded in [F9]; the chart cover has two members and the chart products four, so no infinite selection is made.

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

185 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources