How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Iterated derivative ideals preserve support in the safe characteristic range
Statement
Assume AC (The Axiom of Choice) for the completed-local and smooth-coordinate arguments.
Let be a marked ideal on a smooth -scheme with (Marked ideals and their support, Smooth morphism of schemes), and let (Derivative ideals of an ideal sheaf and of a marked ideal). In every characteristic, and, when is perfect, is closed. If has characteristic zero, or is perfect of characteristic with (Field), then the inclusion is an equality. In these same characteristics, for the condition for every is equivalent to .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: A marked ideal on a smooth -scheme and an integer .
Derivative ideals of an ideal sheaf and of a marked ideal: , is generated locally by generators of and their coordinate partial derivatives of order at most ; the recursive identity holds in every characteristic.
Order of an ideal sheaf at a point: , with order at least equivalent to vanishing in .
The regular-local associated-graded and completion theorems identify with and its completion with when is perfect. A coefficient field containing is obtained by lifting a separating transcendence basis of , then its finite separable algebraic generators by the coefficient-field adjunction lemmas. The parameter map is surjective by the Cohen presentation and injective by the associated-graded isomorphism. These are associated graded ring of a regular local ring, Completion of a Noetherian local ring is local with the same residue field, completion preserves regular local rings, A complete equicharacteristic Noetherian local ring is a power-series quotient, Transcendental residue elements adjoin across a maximal subfield, and Separable residue elements adjoin across a maximal subfield. Formal parameter derivatives restrict to derivations ; since is finite free locally, universality identifies them with -linear combinations of the algebraic derivations (Differentials of a smooth morphism, Derivations are maps out of Ω). Iterated Leibniz therefore puts their order- derivatives of in .
On an étale chart to affine -space, the infinitesimal Taylor map with coordinate increments exists uniquely by Etale morphisms are the formally etale morphisms locally of finite presentation, modulo . Its finitely many coefficients for a function are the Hasse derivatives of orders , regular functions on the chart. Over a perfect field, their residues all vanish at exactly when . Indeed the completed chart can be expressed using a separating residue-field coordinate system and the normal parameters in [F4]; Taylor substitution in the normal parameters detects every nonzero initial form of degree . An invertible change of smooth coordinates gives invertible changes of these truncated Taylor coefficients. This reasoning concerns Hasse derivatives, and uses no factorial division.
Proof
If , Leibniz shows for every derivation and : differentiate each product of elements of . Iterating gives . This proves the forward inclusion over any field, independently of perfection or factorials.
Assume perfect. For finitely many local generators of , take the finitely many Taylor coefficients in [F5] of orders . Their simultaneous vanishing locus is exactly , so this set is closed on each chart and hence on . This proves closedness in the stated perfect-field range, in every characteristic.
Reverse inclusion in the safe-order range. Assume or perfect with . If but , choose of order and let be its nonzero initial form in [F4]. If , choose a monomial of with and differentiate by ; its initial constant term is , since in positive characteristic. This puts a unit in , contradicting its order being at least . If , choose a monomial of and a multiindex with . Then is nonzero: its selected coefficient is a product of falling factorials of integers at most , so is nonzero in . Hence has order exactly , contradicting the same support assumption. Thus the reverse inclusion holds in the stated range.
The maximal-order criterion in the same range. Suppose first that for every . For a point with , choose of order and a monomial in its initial form; , and the coefficient of is in characteristic zero or when . Thus ; the case is immediate since . Conversely, if , at least one of its local generators is a unit, with and . Since differentiation lowers order by at most , . This proves the equivalence stalkwise.
Remarks
Perfection is essential to the positive-characteristic converse: for , on has order one at the closed point , but every ordinary -derivative of vanishes. Thus and the marking-one maximal-order criterion fails even though . The all-characteristic forward inclusion above remains valid. Closedness over imperfect fields is not established by this proof or used by the characteristic-zero development.
Depends on
- embedding dimension and regular local ring
- Field
- Derivative ideals of an ideal sheaf and of a marked ideal
- Marked ideals and their support
- Order of an ideal sheaf at a point
- Smooth morphism of schemes
- The Axiom of Choice
- associated graded ring of a regular local ring
- Completion of a Noetherian local ring is local with the same residue field
- completion preserves regular local rings
- A complete equicharacteristic Noetherian local ring is a power-series quotient
- Transcendental residue elements adjoin across a maximal subfield
- Separable residue elements adjoin across a maximal subfield
- Differentials of a smooth morphism
- Derivations are maps out of Ω
- Etale morphisms are the formally etale morphisms locally of finite presentation
Used by
- The maximal-contact mechanism fails in positive characteristic Counterexample
- Marked ideals of maximal order, tangent directions and transversality to the exceptional divisors Definition
- Canonical resolutions over non-algebraically-closed ground fields Lemma
- Controlled derivative transforms are contained in derivatives of the controlled transform Lemma
- Controlled transforms preserve maximal order on nonempty transformed schemes Lemma
- Derivative ideals under a multiple test blow-up Lemma
- Giraud's tangent-direction lemma Lemma
- Order functions and normal-crossings strata are upper semicontinuous Lemma
- The coefficient ideal controls the support after restriction Lemma
- The coefficient ideal is equivalent to the marked ideal Lemma
- The homogenized ideal is equivalent to the marked ideal Lemma
- The supports of a multiple test blow-up stay inside the strict transforms of a hypersurface of maximal contact Lemma
- Canonical resolution of marked ideals Proposition
Dependency tree · two levels
68 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.