Alphabeta Math
Pipeline-generated
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Selected classical field topology and optional circle normalization

1 · Prerequisites

2 · Summary

This page separates a smooth classical real electromagnetic two-form from an optional circle-bundle connection with a chosen normalization κ0. By Selected classical field topology and optional circle normalization, a field is closed when dF=0 and has a global potential when F=dA for a smooth one-form A on M. A closed field has local potentials on star-shaped coordinate domains. A global potential forces ∫cF=0 for every finite smooth singular 2-chain c with ∂c=0, by Stokes theorem for smooth singular chains; the punctured-space example below supplies such a cycle with nonzero flux. A fixed U(1) sector restricts the explicit sphere-patch construction; that restriction is geometric model data and does not quantize every classical electromagnetic flux.

For the sphere example, fix x0 and r>0 and write Sr2 for the oriented spatial sphere. Let N and S denote its north and south poles, UN=Sr2∖{S}, US=Sr2∖{N}, and O=UN∩US. The arrows below are subset inclusions; the composites from O through either UN or US to Sr2 are the same inclusion. This cover diagram records the domains only. The local potential formulas, transition law, and proofs are given in the items and do not follow from the diagram.

\begin{tikzcd}
& S^2_r & \\
U_N \arrow[ur,hook] & O \arrow[l,hook'] \arrow[r,hook] & U_S \arrow[ul,hook']
\end{tikzcd}

The companion emg-g02-examples gives exact flux and flat-holonomy calculations. The displayed mathematics concerns smooth fields on the stated domains; it reports no physical magnetic monopole and asserts no quantum charge or phase rule.

3 · Logical flowchart

4 · Definitions, postulates, theorems and proofs

DefinitionDefinition: AI-adaptedProof: Not applicableOpen item page →

Selected classical field topology and optional circle normalization

Physical scope

A choice between a smooth classical real two-form field and an additionally selected, fixed-normalization U(1) connection sector on the stated Einstein–Maxwell spacetime; no assertion that every closed field admits that sector and no quantum electric-charge quantization.

Definition

Let (M,g,N,o) be the smooth, Hausdorff, second-countable, oriented and time-oriented Lorentzian four-manifold of Einstein–Maxwell primitive quantities and SI conventions, with signature (−,+,+,+) and no boundary. Write Ωk(M) for the smooth real sections of ΛkT∗M. The classical electromagnetic field type is a smooth real two-form F∈Ω2(M). In length-coordinate charts its components have SI unit tesla; its integral over an oriented smooth two-surface has unit weber. The exterior derivative is denoted d. A field is closed when dF=0. Closedness is a field condition, not the same condition as having a global potential.

For an open set U⊆M, a local potential for F on U is a smooth real one-form AU∈Ω1(U) satisfying dAU=F∣U. It is a global potential when U=M. In a length-coordinate chart the components of AU have unit tesla metre. This classical real-field description chooses F itself and requires no bundle or global A.

An optional circle-normalized connection sector adds the mathematical data of a smooth right principal U(1) bundle π:P→M and a connection, using the local-potential and circle-data conventions of Local potentials and smooth circle-bundle connection data. Here U(1)={z∈C:∣z∣=1} with multiplication. Concretely, supply a countable open cover {Ui} and smooth transition maps gij:Ui∩Uj→U(1) satisfying gii=1 and gijgjk=gik. On overlap pieces with smooth real lifts gij=eifij, the normalized local connection one-forms ai satisfy aj=ai+dfij; in local fibre angles the convention is θj=θi−fij, so dθi+ai patches. The local curvature forms dai agree. Fix an independent constant κ0>0 with unit weber, and set Ai=κ0ai and F∣Ui=κ0dai. Thus ai has component unit m−1 in length coordinates, while Ai has component unit tesla metre. Choosing P and κ0 is extra model data; no claim is made that every smooth closed real F is the curvature of such a fixed-normalization connection.

The selected topological sector is the fixed pair consisting of the bundle P and the normalization κ0; its connection is data on that fixed bundle. Changing P or κ0 selects a different sector.

In a trivialization, a gauge transformation is a single-valued smooth map h:U→U(1); its local real lifts may differ by integer multiples of 2π. A connection on a trivial bundle is gauge trivial when one such global map takes its normalized connection form to zero. For a closed piecewise-C1 loop γ lying in a trivialization, horizontal transport is defined by θ˙=−a(γ˙); the endpoint fibre rotation is its holonomy. When a is one global one-form along the loop this is exp⁡(−i∫γa). These definitions introduce no quantum state or quantum phase. The constant κ0 is not identified with Planck's constant or a unit of electric charge.

Physics theoremStatement: AI-adaptedProof: AI-adaptedprecheck passjudge pass (gpt-6-luna)Open item page →

Local potentials and explicit global obstruction in the model

Physical scope

The smooth classical field branch uses only the adopted homogeneous Maxwell law dF=0: local potentials exist on star-shaped coordinate charts; on the punctured spatial domain a nonzero sphere flux obstructs a global potential; a fixed U(1) normalization restricts the explicit north/south connection patching, while a separate flat example distinguishes zero curvature from gauge triviality. No coupled Einstein solution, physical magnetic monopole, or quantum charge quantization is asserted.

Statement

Let (M,g,N,o) be a smooth, oriented and time-oriented Lorentzian four-manifold with signature (−,+,+,+), and let F∈Ω2(M) be a smooth real field with the SI conventions of Selected classical field topology and optional circle normalization. Assume the smooth branch of the adopted curved Maxwell postulate Smooth curved vacuum Maxwell constitutive adoption applies on M, with no singular source in its domain. Only its homogeneous clause dF=0 is used below; no Einstein equation or coupled solution is asserted.

If U⊆M is a nonempty star-shaped coordinate domain with chart image V⊆R4 star-shaped about a point p (that is, p+t(x−p)∈V for every x∈V and 0≤t≤1), then F∣U has a smooth local potential. Use a length-coordinate chart for the following formula; its coordinates have unit metre. The components can be taken to be

Aν(x)=∫01t(x−p)μFμν(p+t(x−p)) dt.

For an explicit global example, take M∗=Rx0×(R3∖{0}) with Minkowski metric −(dx0)2+dx2+dy2+dz2, orientation dx0∧dx∧dy∧dz, and x0,x,y,z measured in metres. Let r>0 be spatial radius, let θ,ϕ be dimensionless spherical angles, and for b∈R with unit weber set

Fb=bsin⁡θ dθ∧dϕ.

For each fixed (x0,r), let Sr2 have its outward orientation, let N,S be its north and south poles, and set UN=Sr2∖{S}, US=Sr2∖{N}, and O=UN∩US. The corresponding open patches in M∗ are U~N={r+z>0} and U~S={r−z>0}, whose restrictions to each Sr2 are UN and US. The angular coordinate ϕ is defined modulo 2π on O, while dϕ is a global one-form there. The form Fb is smooth and closed on M∗, with outward sphere flux ∫Sr2Fb=4πb. For b≠0 it has no global smooth one-form potential on M∗. It has local north/south potentials

AN=b(1−cos⁡θ) dϕ,AS=−b(1+cos⁡θ) dϕ.

For the fixed circle normalization κ0>0 of Selected classical field topology and optional circle normalization, these patch as the stated normalized U(1) connection exactly when 2b/κ0∈Z: on the overlap, AS−AN=−2b dϕ and the transition is gNS(ϕ)=exp⁡(−2ibϕ/κ0). This integrality is a restriction of the selected connection sector; the classical real-field description permits every real b.

There is also a flat-connection example on the smooth base M0=Rx0×S1×R2. Write w∈S1⊂C for the circle coordinate and ν=−iw−1dw for its global angular one-form, normalized by ∫S1ν=2π. For dimensionless a∈R, the global one-form A=κ0a ν has F=dA=0, while its normalized connection has holonomy e−2πia around the positive circle. It is gauge trivial for integer a and is not gauge trivial for noninteger a. On an angle chart w=eiϕ, ν=dϕ. This is a classical connection statement on a smooth base, not a claim about a quantum phase or an Einstein solution. The punctured point in the sphere example is outside the field domain; no physical magnetic monopole or quantum electric-charge quantization is asserted.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: The smooth Lorentzian field model above, a smooth real two-form, and the positive fixed normalization κ0 only when the optional circle sector is selected.

[A1]

The current draft Smooth curved vacuum Maxwell constitutive adoption adopts the smooth SI field law on an open subset U of a smooth oriented, time-oriented Lorentzian four-manifold: for smooth real F∈Ω2(U) and smooth four-current j, dF=0 and ∇agFab=−μ0jb. It excludes magnetic sources, material excitation laws, singular point or sheet sources, distributional products, and global-potential assumptions. This is a physical postulate, not a theorem; only dF=0 is used here. Its batch-1 contract contains author formulation, scope, sources and non-derivation review; this is not independent acceptance, and current external prerequisite closure remains an owner obligation.

[A2]

The current draft Radial primitives for closed one- and two-forms states that for an open star-shaped D⊆R4 and smooth closed real two-form F=12Fab dxa∧dxb, the displayed radial integral defines a smooth A=Ab dxb with dA=F. Its complete local proof differentiates the integral and checks every coefficient. The typed foundational dependencies are now authored earlier on emg-mg02; this is local proof completion, not independent acceptance. Independent acceptance and current run readiness remain separate owner duties.

[A3]

For the punctured-Minkowski specialization equip M∗ with the future time orientation selected by N∗:=∂x0; its displayed metric gives g(N∗,N∗)=−1, and its orientation is the displayed product orientation. This is the canonical Lorentzian tuple of the supplier. The current draft Sphere winding, nonexact curvature and flat holonomy states the smooth Cartesian punctured-space form, its unit-sphere flux and Stokes obstruction, the smooth north/south potentials and fixed-κ0 transition criterion, and the flat example A=κ0a ν with ν=−iw−1dw and holonomy e−2πia. On an angle chart w=eiϕ, its global angular one-form is ν=dϕ. Its complete local proof gives an ordered tetrahedral finite-cycle Stokes argument and gauge-period calculation. The gluing supplier now uses the actual local set-size definition and constructs the normalized bundle and curvature. The exact interfaces match; no independent acceptance is asserted.

[F1]

Selected classical field topology and optional circle normalization defines a closed classical field by dF=0, a local potential by dAU=F∣U, and the optional normalized connection by Ai=κ0ai, F∣Ui=κ0dai, and aj=ai+dfij when gij=eifij. It assigns F flux unit Wb and κ0 unit Wb; the choice is not a quantum charge postulate.

[F2]

Stokes theorem for smooth singular chains states that for a smooth manifold X, integer k≥1, finite smooth real singular k-chain c, and smooth (k−1)-form ω, ∫cdω=∫∂cω.

Proof

1.1A2construct

Fix a nonempty star-shaped chart U and its center p. Define Aν by the displayed radial integral. The integrand is smooth in (x,t) on V×[0,1]; on every relatively compact subdomain its x-derivatives are continuous and uniformly bounded on the compact integration interval, so differentiation under the integral gives a smooth one-form.

1.2A3algebra

Equip the explicit M∗ witness with N∗:=∂x0 as in [A3]. This vector field is smooth, globally defined and timelike since g(N∗,N∗)=−1; select its future cone. The displayed metric and orientation, this time orientation, and the standard product smooth structure give exactly the tuple required by [A3]. On M∗ the Cartesian expression Fb=b(x dy∧dz+y dz∧dx+z dx∧dy)/r3 is smooth because r>0. Direct differentiation gives dFb=b(∂x(x/r3)+∂y(y/r3)+∂z(z/r3)) dx∧dy∧dz=b(3/r3−3r2/r5) dx∧dy∧dz=0. In spherical coordinates, the outward-oriented sphere integral is ∫Sr2Fb=b∫0πsin⁡θ dθ∫02πdϕ=4πb.

1.3A3F1algebra

The north and south potentials in [A3] are smooth on U~N and U~S respectively, differentiate to Fb, and differ by AS−AN=−2b dϕ on their overlap. Dividing by κ0 gives the normalized connection transition lift fNS=−2bϕ/κ0, so gNS=eifNS returns to its initial value after ϕ↦ϕ+2π exactly when e−4πib/κ0=1. The map x↦eix has kernel 2πZ, hence this is equivalent to 2b/κ0∈Z. If n=2b/κ0∈Z, then gNS=e−inϕ is smooth and single-valued on the overlap and aS=aN+d(−nϕ) is the declared gluing rule; conversely any fixed-sector transition must be single-valued.

2.1A1A2step 1.1algebra

By antisymmetry of F and dF=0 from [A1], differentiation of the radial formula in step 1.1 gives ∂ρAν−∂νAρ=∫01(2tFρν+t2(x−p)μ∂μFρν)(p+t(x−p)) dt=∫01∂t[t2Fρν(p+t(x−p))] dt=Fρν(x). Hence dAU=F∣U.

2.2A3F2step 1.2algebra

For b≠0, step 1.2 identifies the explicit field and its canonical Lorentzian tuple with [A3]. That supplier proves that Fb has no global smooth one-form potential, using its ordered tetrahedral smooth singular two-cycle c with ∂c=0 and ∫cFb=4πb. Its proof establishes the radial projection as an orientation-preserving one-sheeted parametrization and justifies this integral by its finite-parametrization integration supplier. If a global A satisfied dA=Fb, finite-chain Stokes [F2] would give 4πb=∫cdA=∫∂cA=0, a contradiction. Thus the stated obstruction follows with the exact supplier hypotheses and integration bridge.

3.1A3F1algebraconstruct∎

On M0, write w=eiϕ on an angle chart. The supplier form ν=−iw−1dw then equals the global angular form dϕ, since dw=ieiϕdϕ; its integral around the positive circle is 2π. Thus A=κ0a ν is global and dA=0. The horizontal-lift equation over one positive turn is θ˙=−aϕ˙, so the endpoint fibre rotation is e−2πia. A single-valued gauge map along the circle has a real lift on [0,2π] whose endpoint difference is in 2πZ, so it preserves this rotation. Therefore noninteger a is not gauge trivial. If a∈Z, h(w)=w−a is a well-defined U(1) map and its local lift has derivative −a dϕ, which removes the connection.

Remarks

The source texts motivate the local/global distinction and exhibit patch potentials, but the proof uses the current conditional local radial and sphere-flux supplier interfaces above. The classical sphere field is smooth only on the punctured domain; no source at the removed point is included. The finite radial integral, explicit two-patch transition, flux integral, and circle holonomy calculation make no arbitrary-family choice. The typed sequence criterion states exactly its countable-choice hypothesis; the finite calculations here do not spend it. Independent supplier acceptance and source status remain owner review duties; the audited imported boundaryless-convention remark is not a missing prerequisite.

5 · Examples, experiments and counterexamples

None yet.

Sources