Alphabeta Math
Pipeline-generated
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Gauge/diffeomorphism matter identity and field exchange

1 · Prerequisites

2 · Summary

Scope

This page develops the compact-variation Einstein equation, the gauge and diffeomorphism Noether identity for matter, and the classical charged-scalar current and stress tensor. It then derives the electromagnetic stress exchange identity under the sourced Maxwell equations. Each result is conditional on its stated smoothness, bundle, field-equation and compact-support hypotheses.

The mathematical items do not adopt Einstein, Maxwell or matter equations as physical laws, claim existence of a coupled solution, or use experimental data. The current M02 and M03 supplier carriers are drafts, and their inspected interfaces are used conditionally. The seven typed M01 replacement carriers referenced by this batch are authored drafts on emg-mg02; their review and independent acceptance remain pending. The historical research-only GR-G3 token is reconciled at its actual contracted-Bianchi use to the published The second Bianchi identity and the vanishing divergence of the Einstein tensor; no broader GR-G3 result is asserted.

3 · Logical flowchart

4 · Definitions, postulates, theorems and proofs

LemmaStatement: AI-adaptedProof: AI-adaptedOpen item page →

Gauge/diffeomorphism matter identity and field exchange

Statement

Let (M,g,N,o) be an oriented, time-oriented smooth Lorentzian four-manifold of signature (−,+,+,+) with metric-selected connection ∇, as in Oriented Lorentzian fields, observers and coordinate conventions. Let π:P→M be a smooth principal U(1) bundle with a smooth connection and global curvature two-form F, using the local-potential and fixed-sector conventions of Local potentials and smooth circle-bundle connection data and Circle gluing, curvature and connection variations. Specify the matter fields by a smooth fiber bundle pE:E→M: its local trivializations are smooth diffeomorphisms pE−1(U)≅U×Q commuting with projection, for a fixed finite-dimensional smooth manifold Q. A matter configuration is a smooth section Ψ:M→E, so pE∘Ψ=idM; write C=Γ∞(E). No linear structure on Q is required. A compact matter variation is a jointly smooth family Ψs∈C, ∣s∣<ε, with Ψ0=Ψ and Ψs=Ψ off a common compact subset of M. Its derivative η(x)=∂sΨs(x)∣0 lies in VΨ(x)E:=ker⁡(dpE)Ψ(x), the vertical tangent space. Thus η is a smooth compactly supported section of the vector bundle Ψ∗VE→M.

Let Sm:D→R, where D is a declared subset of triples (g~,A~,Ψ~) consisting of smooth Lorentzian metrics of the fixed signature, smooth connections on P, and sections in C; A denotes the connection, not necessarily a global one-form. Admissible variations are jointly smooth curves in D equal to the fixed triple off a common compact set. Require that freezing any two components of an admissible curve still gives an admissible curve near zero, and that every compact metric and fixed-sector connection direction is admitted. Here differentiable means that along each admissible curve the derivative at zero exists, depends real-linearly only on (q,α,η), and is the sum δgSm[q]+δASm[α]+δΨSm[η] of its three partial derivatives. The connection direction α is the physical one: δAi=α∣Ui, equivalently δω=κ0−1π∗α for the normalized connection ω of Circle gluing, curvature and connection variations.

Matter transport is additional supplied data, not a canonical construction for an arbitrary E. For every compact real gauge parameter χ, use the principal-bundle path Hs(p)=p⋅eisχ(π(p))/κ0 covering fs=idM. For each compact smooth vector field ξ use its flow fs and the flow Hs of its horizontal lift ξH, uniquely specified by dπ(ξH)=ξ∘π and ω(ξH)=0. For each of these paths supply a jointly smooth family of bundle diffeomorphisms HsE:E→E covering fs, with H0E=idE, equal to the identity over the complement of the compact support of the generating parameter or vector field. The maps and their inverses are required on a common interval about zero. Define the transported section by Ψs=(HsE)−1∘Ψ∘fs, and require (fs∗g,Hs∗ω,Ψs) to be admissible. This pathwise specification also allows models whose gauge action is defined using real phase paths; it asserts no action of every finite circle transformation on E.

Fix a configuration at which the matter Euler–Lagrange variation vanishes, meaning δΨSm=0 for every smooth compactly supported matter-field variation. Suppose that for all compactly supported metric variations qab=δgab and all compactly supported connection variations α∈Ω1(M) in the fixed bundle sector, the remaining first variation is

δSm=−12c∫MTabmqab volg+1c∫Mjaαa volg,

where c>0, Tm is a smooth symmetric covariant two-tensor, and j is a smooth vector field. Assume Sm(fs∗g,Hs∗ω,Ψs)=Sm(g,ω,Ψ) for both types of supplied transport above. Only derivatives at s=0 are used; no global flow for all times is required. Then

∇aja=0,∇aTmab=Fbcjc,

where jc:=gcaja. These are conditional variational identities; no Maxwell or Einstein field equation, existence theorem, or empirical premise is assumed.

For SI bookkeeping in length coordinates, take [c]=m s−1, [Aa]=Wb m−1, and [Fab]=Wb m−2. If Sm is assigned action units J s, the displayed variation convention assigns [Tm]=J m−3 and [ja]=A m−2. These are formal dimensional assignments only; the lemma adopts no matter model or empirical law.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: The manifold, Lorentzian metric, orientation, principal circle bundle, connection, curvature, matter configuration, and functional in the Statement; the matter equations hold at the fixed configuration; the stated first-variation formula and both invariances hold for compactly supported variations.

[F1]

The EMG geometric setup is a smooth oriented/time-oriented Lorentzian four-manifold of signature (−,+,+,+); a local potential may be used without assuming a global potential. (Oriented Lorentzian fields, observers and coordinate conventions)

[F2]

On the fixed principal circle bundle, local connection forms patch to a global connection and curvature; differences of fixed-sector connections are global base one-forms, so α in the Statement is globally defined. (Local potentials and smooth circle-bundle connection data, Circle gluing, curvature and connection variations)

[F3]

The Hilbert tensor convention for inverse-metric variation is δgSm=−12c∫Tabmqab volg. (The Hilbert stress-energy tensor of a metric-dependent action)

[F4]

Every smooth vector field has a unique maximal local flow on an open domain containing time zero. (A smooth vector field is a smooth section of the tangent bundle, Local and global flows generated by a vector field, The fundamental theorem on flows)

[F5]

In a chart, (Lξg)ab=ξc∂cgab+gcb∂aξc+gac∂bξc; metric compatibility and torsion freedom identify this with ∇aξb+∇bξa, and differentiating the inverse metric gives δgab=−(∇aξb+∇bξa). (The Lie derivative of a tensor field, The coordinate formula for the Lie derivative of a covariant tensor, Oriented Lorentzian fields, observers and coordinate conventions)

[F6]

For a smooth vector field W compactly supported inside one positively oriented coordinate ball, ∫M∇aWa volg=0. Indeed Divergence, Stokes flux balance and the non-null face formula for a Lorentzian current(a) gives d(ιWvolg)=(∇aWa)volg. In the chart, volg=w dx0∧⋯∧dx3 and ιWvolg=∑a(−1)awWa dx0∧⋯dxa^⋯∧dx3; differentiating gives w∇aWa=∑a∂a(wWa). Each coefficient wWa has compact support inside the chart image, so its zero extension to R4 is smooth and vanishes near the faces of a containing rectangle. FTC in coordinate a and iterated integration over the other coordinates give ∫R4∂a(wWa)=0, exactly the chart argument in First variation of the Einstein-Hilbert density under compactly supported metric variations, and of the timelike length functional, Facts & Assumptions [L8]. The chart integral is the full integral of this chart-supported density. This uses neither a finite singular chain enclosing arbitrary support nor a claim of boundary-free flux on a subdomain. Nonnegative smooth bumps exist in any coordinate ball (A smooth bump between concentric Euclidean balls); if a smooth covector pairs to zero with every vector test compactly supported inside each such ball, a componentwise fixed-sign bump test makes it zero at every point (A continuous symmetric coefficient orthogonal to every compactly supported variation vanishes uses the same local bump principle).

[A1]

Matter stationarity means that the partial derivative vanishes on every admissible compact section variation defined in the Statement. In particular each transported section is such a variation: it is jointly smooth, is a section because its bundle map covers the base flow, and is fixed off the generating compact support. The freezing and differentiability hypotheses therefore make its partial contribution zero, leaving exactly the displayed metric and connection terms.

Proof

technique · use compact gauge variations to obtain current continuity, then use the horizontal lift of a compactly supported vector field to convert diffeomorphism invariance into the stress-exchange identity
1.1givenA1F6algebra

Fix any positively oriented coordinate ball and let χ be a smooth real gauge parameter compactly supported inside it. Pullback by the supplied gauge path changes ω by sκ0−1π∗dχ, so the physical variation is α=dχ; its compact matter-section variation has zero partial contribution by [A1]. Gauge invariance and the stated first variation give 0=δχSm=1c∫Mja∇aχ volg. The product rule writes the integrand as ∇a(χja)−χ∇aja; the first term integrates to zero by [F6], because supp⁡(χj)⊆supp⁡χ is compact inside the chosen chart. If ∇aja were nonzero at a point, continuity and a nonnegative compact bump supported where it has fixed sign, whose existence is part of [F6], would contradict the resulting integral identity for all χ. Since the ball and its tests are arbitrary, ∇aja=0 at every point of M.

1.2givenA1F1F2F4F5algebra

Let ξ be a smooth vector field compactly supported inside an arbitrary positively oriented coordinate ball in a bundle trivialization, and use the flows and matter transport specified in the Statement. In a local circle angle θ, ω=dθ+κ0−1Aadxa, so ξH=ξa∂a−κ0−1(ξaAa)∂θ. Differentiating Hs∗ω gives κ0−1(LξA−d(ξaAa))=κ0−1ιξF on the base: explicitly (LξA)a=ξb∂bAa+Ab∂aξb=ξbFba+∂a(ξbAb). Consequently the physical connection variation is αa=ξbFba. Since F is global by [F2], this formula agrees on overlaps. The supplied matter transport has compact vertical derivative as in [A1]. Such coordinate balls cover M, so restricting to their tests loses no pointwise conclusion.

2.1A1F3F5step 1.2algebra

By [F5], the metric derivative along the same local flow has inverse-metric variation qab=−(∇aξb+∇bξa). Simultaneous diffeomorphism invariance, the on-shell matter condition [A1], and the first-variation formula therefore give 0=1c∫M(Tabm∇aξb+jaξbFba)volg, where symmetry of Tm combines its two metric-variation terms.

3.1F6step 2.1algebra∎

The product rule gives Tabm∇aξb=∇a(Tabmξb)−(∇aTabm)ξb. The vector field Wa=(Tm)abξb is compactly supported inside the chosen chart, so its divergence integrates to zero by [F6], so step 2.1 becomes ∫M(−∇aTabm+Fbaja)ξb volg=0 for every vector test ξ compactly supported inside that ball. The ball was arbitrary; [F6] therefore makes the smooth covector coefficient vanish pointwise throughout M. Relabeling the contracted index and raising b yields ∇aTmab=Fbcjc, completing the proof.

Remarks

  • The formula is global even when no global potential A exists: the horizontal connection variation is ιξF, and F is global.
  • Matter stress is not separately divergence-free in the charged subsystem: its divergence is the Lorentz-force density, with the sign derived from the stated first-variation and flow conventions. Under the matching sourced-Maxwell convention, Curved electromagnetic stress divergence gives the opposite electromagnetic stress divergence, so the two cancel where both hypotheses hold.
  • Sourced Maxwell sign and current conservation is a formulation prerequisite: it fixes the downstream source convention ∇aFab=−μ0jb (equivalently d(⋆gF)=μ0ιjvolg for μ0>0), specifying the sign with which this lemma's variational current is matched to the Maxwell source in a coupled formulation. This lemma's Statement and proof assume neither Maxwell equation; ja is fixed by the displayed matter first variation, and the stress-exchange sign is derived from the stated diffeomorphism and gauge conventions.
  • The M02 and M03 supplier carriers are present as drafts and are used only at their inspected statements; the Maxwell-current dependency preserves the planned notation but no Maxwell equation is assumed; their proofs are not treated as accepted. The seven typed foundational replacements are now authored on emg-mg02; no independent acceptance is asserted: Finite-real supremum and infimum domain, Real metric and pseudometric convention, Metric nonnegativity from the three axioms, Explicit rational and real power regimes, Sequence-limit criterion with explicit choice use, Boundaryless domain for geometric completeness, and Set-sized objects and definable-class schemas. The inherited geometry chain states ACω; after the smooth data and local flows are given, the displayed calculation makes no further choice. The direct Countable Choice metadata dependency is inherited from that geometry chain.
LemmaStatement: AI-adaptedProof: AI-adaptedOpen item page →

Compact Einstein–Hilbert variation and SI coupling

Statement

Let (M,g,N,o) be as in Oriented Lorentzian fields, observers and coordinate conventions. Write R:=S=gabRic⁡ab:M→R for the smooth scalar curvature of The Riemann curvature operator and the derived Ricci, scalar and Einstein tensors, with Ric⁡bd=Rabad and Gab=Ric⁡ab−12Rgab in that supplier's curvature convention. For a compactly supported metric variation, write qab=δgab, hab=δgab=−gacgbdqcd, w=∣det⁡(gab)∣, and Va=gbdδΓadb−gabδΓddb, where δΓabc=12gad(∇bhcd+∇chbd−∇dhbc); curvature and Einstein tensors are as in The Riemann curvature operator and the derived Ricci, scalar and Einstein tensors. The local density identity is

δ((R−2Λ)w)=w(Gab+Λgab)qab+∂a(wVa).

Fix constants c>0, GN>0, μ0>0, and Λ∈R. Regard these as formal coefficients; their physical interpretation and units are not assumptions of this mathematical lemma. For smooth metric variations with compact support in the interior, at fixed bundle connection and fixed matter fields, consider the action difference

Stot=c316πGN∫M(R−2Λ) volg−14μ0c∫MFabFab volg+Sm,

where noncompact action values are used only through compactly supported differences, F is the curvature of a fixed smooth bundle connection, and Sm has Hilbert tensor Tm in the convention of The Hilbert stress-energy tensor of a metric-dependent action. Let TEM be the electromagnetic Hilbert tensor supplied by the compact Maxwell variation of Compact potential and metric variation of the Maxwell action, and set κE:=8πGN/c4. Then for every compactly supported inverse-metric variation qab=δgab,

δStot=c316πGN∫M(Gab+Λgab−κE(TabEM+Tabm))qab volg.

Consequently, stationarity under all such metric variations is equivalent to

Gab+Λgab=κE(TabEM+Tabm).

Any tensor fields satisfying this equation necessarily have ∇a(TabEM+Tabm)=0 because Λ is constant. This is a compatibility condition, not a claim that the coupled field equations have a solution or that matter and Maxwell equations follow from metric stationarity.

For dimensional bookkeeping in length coordinates one may assign [R]=[Λ]=m−2, [c]=m s−1, [GN]=m3 kg−1 s−2, [μ0]=H m−1, [Fab]=Wb m−2, and [Tm]=[TEM]=J m−3. Then every action term has units J s and κET has units m−2. These are formal assignments only; the lemma assumes no measured parameter value or physical field law.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: A smooth oriented time-oriented Lorentzian four-manifold with fixed signature, constants c,GN,μ0>0, constant Λ, a fixed smooth connection sector and matter configuration, and compactly supported inverse-metric variations.

[F1]

With R=S as defined in the Statement, for a smooth fixed-signature Lorentzian metric family, the local Einstein–Hilbert density satisfies ∂s(w(s)R(s))∣s=0=wGabqab+∂a(wVa), with the inverse variation and tensor δΓ given in clauses (a)–(d) of First variation of the Einstein-Hilbert density under compactly supported metric variations, and of the timelike length functional. Its clause (e) proves the compact action formula when the support is inside one chart. The extension to arbitrary compact support is proved below, rather than attributed to that chart-only clause. [F2] also supplies the global compact divergence and finite-chart differentiation arguments proved in the preliminary localization argument of Compact potential and metric variation of the Maxwell action.

[F2]

The planned M03 Maxwell metric variation is δgSEM=−12c∫MTabEMqabvolg, with TabEM=μ0−1(FacFbc−14gabFcdFcd), for fixed lower F and compact inverse-metric variations. (Compact potential and metric variation of the Maxwell action)

[F3]

The matter Hilbert tensor satisfies δgSm=−12c∫MTabmqabvolg. (The Hilbert stress-energy tensor of a metric-dependent action)

[F4]

If a continuous symmetric coefficient pairs to zero with every smooth compactly supported symmetric test tensor, then it vanishes pointwise. (A continuous symmetric coefficient orthogonal to every compactly supported variation vanishes)

[F5]

The contracted Bianchi identity is ∇aGab=0, and the metric is covariantly constant: ∇g=0. (The second Bianchi identity and the vanishing divergence of the Einstein tensor)

[A1]

The compact variations are smooth families fixed off a common compact set K for all sufficiently small parameters, within the fixed Lorentzian signature and fixed bundle sector; Λ,c,GN,μ0 are held constant. For any compactly supported direction q, such a family is realized by g(s)=g+sh, h=−gqg, on a sufficiently small uniform parameter interval as proved in the Maxwell supplier.

[A2]

The supporting smooth Lorentzian geometry is under the published ACω tangent-bundle convention; no use of full AC is needed in these variational calculations. (The Axiom of Countable Choice (ACω))

[F6]

Compactly supported top forms have the finite-chart integral of Integral of a compactly supported top form, independent of partition by Independence of atlas, partition and refinement. Under ACω a subordinate smooth partition exists by Smooth partitions of unity exist on manifolds.

Proof

technique · add the three independent first variations, normalize the common coefficient, and use compactly supported test tensors for the pointwise Euler–Lagrange equation
1.1givenA1A2F1F2F6algebra

For a family in [A1], the top form ωs=(R(g(s))−2Λ)volg(s)−(R(g)−2Λ)volg is supported in the common compact K. Define its relative action by [F6], even if the separate background integrals diverge. Fix a subordinate partition independently of s; only finitely many terms meet K, and each has compact support inside its chart. The uniform difference-quotient argument in the Maxwell supplier [F2] differentiates this finite sum. Clause (d) of [F1] gives its derivative density locally, and δ(−2Λvolg)=Λgabqabvolg. The field V is global because δΓ is a tensor, and is supported in K. The compact divergence argument in [F2] now gives ∫M∇aVavolg=0: apply chart FTC to each ρiV and sum, with ∑idρi=0 near K. Thus no single chart or enclosing finite singular chain is presumed. Multiplication by c3/(16πGN) yields c316πGN∫M(Gab+Λgab)qabvolg, as claimed.

2.1F2F3step 1.1algebra

Add [F2] and [F3]. Since 12c=c316πGN8πGNc4, the total variation is exactly the expression in the Statement with κE=8πGN/c4.

3.1A1F4step 2.1algebra

If the action is stationary for every compactly supported qab, step 2.1 implies that the continuous symmetric coefficient Gab+Λgab−κE(TabEM+Tabm) pairs to zero with every such q. Because c,GN>0, its prefactor is nonzero; [F4] therefore gives the displayed field equation pointwise.

4.1step 2.1step 3.1algebra

Conversely, if the displayed field equation holds pointwise, the coefficient in step 2.1 is zero everywhere, so its integral vanishes for every compactly supported q. This proves stationarity and the equivalence.

5.1A2F5step 3.1algebra∎

Take the covariant divergence of the field equation in step 3.1. By [F5], ∇aGab=0 and ∇a(Λgab)=Λ∇agab=0 because Λ is constant. Since κE>0, division gives ∇a(TabEM+Tabm)=0. No PDE existence follows from this necessary compatibility identity.

Remarks

DefinitionDefinition: AI-adaptedProof: AI-adaptedOpen item page →

Classical complex-scalar connection derivative and action

Definition

Let (M,g,N,o) be an oriented time-oriented smooth Lorentzian four-manifold of signature (−,+,+,+) as in Oriented Lorentzian fields, observers and coordinate conventions. Set U(1):={z∈C:∣z∣=1} with multiplication. A smooth right principal U(1) bundle is a smooth manifold P with a smooth surjective submersion π:P→M, a smooth right U(1) action, and smooth local equivariant product charts π−1(Ui)≅Ui×U(1); the action is free and transitive on each fibre. This is the smooth version of the right-action convention in Principal g bundle and associated fiber bundle. A principal connection on P is a smooth distribution H⊆TP with TpP=ker⁡(dπp)⊕Hp and dRz(Hp)=Hpz. Equivalently, it is a smooth real one-form ω on P that is right-invariant and satisfies ω(ζP)=1, where ζP(p):=ddt∣0p⋅eit; then H=ker⁡ω. Choose a fixed smooth right principal U(1) bundle with a principal connection ω. In a smooth trivialization τi:P∣Ui→Ui×U(1), set σi(x):=τi−1(x,1) and ai:=σi∗ω. Choose the normalized local data (Ui,gij,ai;κ0) as in Local potentials and smooth circle-bundle connection data; the potentials used below are their rescalings Ai:=κ0ai. On any overlap neighborhood admitting a smooth real phase lift fij, write gij=eifij. Use the dual representation ρk(z):=z−k and define charged scalar representatives by the global transition rule φj=gijkφi, equivalently eikfijφi on each phase-lift neighborhood; the connection rule there is

Aj=Ai+κ0 dfij.

Here κ0>0 is the chosen circle normalization with [κ0]=Wb, k∈Z is the representation weight, and λ:=k/κ0 has units Wb−1. Because gijgjk=gik and k is an integer, the maps gijk satisfy the scalar transition cocycle. A charged scalar is a family of smooth local functions φi satisfying this rule; all phase-lift calculations below are local, and no global phase lift is assumed. The constant c>0 is the length-to-time conversion parameter of Oriented Lorentzian fields, observers and coordinate conventions, with units m s−1. Define F∣Ui:=dAi; the transition law gives dAj=dAi, so F is a global curvature two-form. In a global real-potential model on a trivial bundle, one may instead take a global A and any real λ; no charge quantization is imposed there.

In a local trivialization define the gauge-covariant derivative and its lower-index one-form by

Pa:=(Dφ)a:=∂aφi−iλAi,aφi.

The transition laws give Pj,a=eikfijPi,a, since λκ0=k. For any charged covector Qb with the same phase transition, define the gauge- and metric-covariant derivative by DaQb:=∇aQb−iλAaQb in a local trivialization; for a charged scalar η, set Daη:=∂aη−iλAaη. Conjugate fields use the opposite gauge sign. Thus DaPb is a well-defined charged covariant two-tensor, and DaPa:=gabDaPb. Consequently ∣φ∣2 and gabPa‾Pb are global scalar fields. Let V:U→R be smooth on an open set U⊆R containing the range of ∣φ∣2, write V′ for its ordinary real derivative, and choose a positive normalization constant Kφ>0.

The kinetic scalar gabPa‾Pb is real because its complex conjugate equals itself by symmetry of gab. Put

Lφ:=gabPa‾Pb+V(∣φ∣2),Sφ:=−Kφ2c∫MLφ volg.

For SI dimensional bookkeeping in length coordinates, take [φ]=1, [Aa]=Wb m−1, [Pa]=m−1, [V]=m−2, and [Kφ]=J m−1; then Sφ has units J s. These are formal dimensional assignments, not measured values or physical postulates. On noncompact M, the integral is used when finite; otherwise only differences between configurations agreeing outside a compact set are defined, so every variation below is a compactly supported integral.

Allowed first variations are compactly supported smooth complex-section variations δφ, compactly supported real global one-form variations α=δA added to every local Ai (so the same bundle transition functions are retained), and compactly supported symmetric inverse-metric variations qab=δgab. The formula defines a classical mathematical functional; it asserts no quantum interpretation, value of ℏ, or material-response model.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: The smooth Lorentzian manifold, a fixed principal circle bundle and connection, local potentials and transition functions, a smooth scalar section, constants, and a smooth potential function as specified in the Definition.

[F1]

A right principal bundle has local equivariant charts and the chosen transition data obey Aj=Ai+κ0dfij on phase-lift neighborhoods and the circle cocycle. (Principal g bundle and associated fiber bundle, Local potentials and smooth circle-bundle connection data)

[F2]

The exterior derivative satisfies d2=0 on smooth forms. (Lorentzian exterior calculus and Hodge star)

[F3]

Compactly supported smooth top forms on an oriented smooth manifold have a well-defined integral; in particular the action's compactly supported differences are defined. (Finite chart localization gives choice-free integration and compact Stokes)

[A1]

In the circle-bundle branch, k∈Z and λκ0=k. In the separate trivial global-potential branch, λ may be any real number.

Proof

technique · verify that the scalar transition maps form a line bundle, that the covariant derivative and action density patch globally, and that the stated dimensions agree
1.1F1F2A1algebra

On every triple overlap, gijgjk=gik and integer k give gijkgjkk=gikk, so the scalar transition data satisfy the cocycle. On any local phase-lift neighborhood, changing fij by 2πn leaves eikfij unchanged. Also dAj=dAi+κ0d2fij=dAi by [F2]; these local equalities patch because they hold near every point of each overlap, so F is global.

1.2F1A1algebra

Expanding the derivative gives Pj,a=eikfij[∂aφi+ik(∂afij)φi−iλAi,aφi−iλκ0(∂afij)φi]. The phase-derivative terms cancel because λκ0=k, so Pj,a=eikfijPi,a. Hence ∣φ∣2 and gabPa‾Pb are independent of the local trivialization.

1.3givenF3algebra

Complex conjugation and exchange of dummy indices show gabPa‾Pb‾=gabPa‾Pb. Since V is real-valued, Lφ is a global real scalar. Its product with the oriented metric volume form is a real four-form, so compactly supported action differences have the well-defined integral supplied by [F3].

1.4F1givenalgebra

Adding the same real global one-form α to every Ai leaves Aj−Ai=κ0dfij unchanged. Therefore the prescribed connection variations retain the local transition data and remain in the same bundle sector.

2.1givenalgebra∎

In length-coordinate components, [Lφ]=m−2 and [volg]=m4, while [Kφ/c]=(J m−1)/(m s−1)=J s m−2. Therefore Sφ has units J s.

Remarks

LemmaStatement: AI-adaptedProof: AI-adaptedOpen item page →

Classical charged-scalar action, current and stress variation

Statement

Use the scalar functional of Classical complex-scalar connection derivative and action on a fixed smooth bundle sector, with Kφ>0, real λ, real smooth V, and smooth φ,A,g. Write Pa:=Daφ and define the gauge- and metric-covariant derivative of its one-form by

DaPb:=∇aPb−iλAaPb,

with the conjugate derivative using +iλAa. For compactly supported variations, define

Eφ:=DaPa−V′(∣φ∣2)φ,ja:=Kφλ Im⁡(φ‾Pa),

Tabφ:=KφRe⁡(Pa‾Pb)−Kφ2gabLφ.

Then the scalar-field variation is δφSφ=KφcRe⁡∫Mδφ‾ Eφ volg; stationarity in every compactly supported complex scalar direction is equivalent to Eφ=0. The connection and inverse-metric variations are

δASφ=1c∫Mjaαa volg,δgSφ=−12c∫MTabφqab volg.

The following off-shell identities also hold:

∇aja=KφλIm⁡(φ‾Eφ),∇a(Tφ)ab=KφRe⁡(Eφ‾Pb)+Fbaja.

In particular, the matter equation Eφ=0 implies current conservation and the exact Lorentz-force exchange identity ∇a(Tφ)ab=Fbcjc. No coupled Einstein–Maxwell solution or empirical matter model is asserted.

Under the formal SI assignments of Classical complex-scalar connection derivative and action, ja has units A m−2 and Tφ has units J m−3; this dimensional check is not an empirical claim.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: The smooth metric, bundle connection and scalar section of Classical complex-scalar connection derivative and action, its fixed-sector compact variations, and the definitions of Pa,Lφ,V,Kφ,λ there.

[F1]

The scalar functional has Pa=∂aφ−iλAaφ, its induced charged-covector derivative, and Lφ=gabPa‾Pb+V(∣φ∣2); a fixed-sector connection variation is a global real one-form. (Classical complex-scalar connection derivative and action, Circle gluing, curvature and connection variations)

[F2]

The metric volume varies as δvolg=−12gabqabvolg for compact inverse-metric variation qab. (First variation of the Einstein-Hilbert density under compactly supported metric variations, and of the timelike length functional)

[F3]

Compactly supported divergences integrate to zero. (Finite chart localization gives choice-free integration and compact Stokes)

[F4]

For a real-valued differentiable functional on a declared metric/connection/section domain, with the compact-variation splitting and supplied smooth gauge/horizontal-flow section transports specified in its Statement, invariance and the stated Hilbert/current first variation give the on-shell identity ∇aTab=Fbcjc. (Gauge/diffeomorphism matter identity and field exchange)

[F5]

In an oriented chart, a continuous covector whose integral pairing with every compactly supported smooth vector field vanishes is zero pointwise. (A continuous symmetric coefficient orthogonal to every compactly supported variation vanishes)

[F6]

The Levi-Civita derivative obeys the product rule, preserves g and g−1, and is torsion-free. (Existence and uniqueness of the metric-selected connection of a nondegenerate metric, and its extension to tensor fields)

[A1]

V is real-valued and smooth on a neighborhood of the attained ∣φ∣2 values, so V′ exists and is real there. All fields and variations are smooth, and each variation has compact support in the fixed bundle sector.

[A2]

The geometric supplier convention includes ACω for the canonical tangent-bundle setup; no arbitrary-choice argument is used in the scalar variation. (The Axiom of Countable Choice (ACω))

Proof

technique · compute the three compact first variations, then differentiate the current and stress expressions using the gauge-covariant product rule
1.1A1A2F1F3F5algebra

Let η=δφ be a compactly supported complex section. Direct differentiation gives δφLφ=2Re⁡(gabDaη‾Pb+V′η‾φ). The gauge-covariant product rule gives ∇a(η‾Pa)=Daη‾Pa+η‾DaPa, so [F3] removes the compact divergence and ∫Daη‾Pa volg=−∫η‾DaPa volg. Multiplying by −Kφ/(2c) yields the displayed scalar variation. If stationarity holds, then Re⁡∫η‾Eφ volg=0 for all compactly supported η. In a positively oriented chart, for every compactly supported real vector field q=qa∂a, its component q0 is a real test function; choosing η=q0 in the local scalar frame gives zero pairing of the covector Wa=(Re⁡Eφ)δa0 with q. [F5] implies Re⁡Eφ=0. Choosing instead η=iq0 gives zero pairing for Wa=(Im⁡Eφ)δa0, so [F5] implies Im⁡Eφ=0. Thus Eφ=0 pointwise. Conversely, Eφ=0 makes the variation zero for every test section; hence stationarity is equivalent to Eφ=0.

1.2F1givenalgebra

At fixed g,φ, a real connection variation αa gives δAPa=−iλφαa and δAPa‾=+iλφ‾αa. Their contraction is δALφ=−2λIm⁡(φ‾Pa)αa, so δASφ=1c∫MKφλIm⁡(φ‾Pa)αa volg. This is the stated current.

1.3F1F2algebra

At fixed lower A and fixed φ, the inverse-metric variation gives δgLφ=Re⁡(Pa‾Pb)qab. Combining this with [F2] in Sφ=−Kφ(2c)−1∫Lφvolg yields δgSφ=−12c∫M[KφRe⁡(Pa‾Pb)−Kφ2gabLφ]qab volg, the displayed Hilbert tensor.

2.1A1F6step 1.2algebra

The covariant derivative of ja=KφλIm⁡(φ‾Pa) is KφλIm⁡(Pa‾Pa+φ‾DaPa). The first term is real; adding V′∣φ∣2 inside the imaginary part changes nothing because V′ is real. Therefore ∇aja=KφλIm⁡(φ‾(DaPa−V′φ))=KφλIm⁡(φ‾Eφ).

2.2A1F1F6step 1.3algebra

Raise the first index of Tφ and differentiate. Using [F6] to differentiate contractions and ∇bLφ=2Re⁡(Pa‾DbPa)+2V′Re⁡(φ‾Pb), the product rule gives ∇a(Tφ)ab=KφRe⁡(Eφ‾Pb+Pa‾(DaPb−DbPa)). In a local trivialization, symmetry of the Levi-Civita symbols and commutation of scalar partial derivatives give DaPb−DbPa=−iλFabφ. Hence the second term is −KφλIm⁡(φ‾Pa)Fab=Fbaja, proving the stated off-shell stress identity.

3.1F1F4step 2.1step 2.2algebra∎

If Eφ=0, steps 2.1–2.2 give ∇aja=0 and ∇a(Tφ)ab=Fbaja. For the auxiliary Noether route, restrict to configurations for which the scalar density is absolutely integrable. Take E to be the supplied associated complex line bundle (the trivial complex line in the global-potential branch), and let the functional domain consist of these finite-action triples. Compact smooth variations remain in this domain near zero; their density differences have common compact support, so differentiation of their coordinate integrals gives the real-linear partial splitting established in steps 1.1–1.3. The induced line-bundle gauge maps and horizontal connection-flow maps supply the smooth section transports of [F4], equal to the identity off the generating support. The covariant derivative transforms by the same phase as the section under gauge transport and as a covector under base transport; thus the scalar density is gauge invariant and pulls back under the base flow. Change of variables for its absolutely integrable density makes this real-valued functional invariant, so [F4] gives the same raised-index exchange equation. When only relative compact action differences are defined, steps 2.1–2.2 already prove both identities and the same sign directly, without invoking a real-valued global functional.

Remarks

LemmaStatement: AI-adaptedProof: AI-adaptedOpen item page →

Curved electromagnetic stress divergence

Statement

Let U be an oriented open subset of a smooth time-oriented Lorentzian four-manifold of signature (−,+,+,+), with metric-selected connection ∇. Let F∈Ω2(U) and j∈Γ(TU) be smooth, and let μ0>0. Assume

dF=0,∇aFab=−μ0jb,

with the sign convention of Sourced Maxwell sign and current conservation. Define the Maxwell Hilbert tensor by the compact metric variation of Compact potential and metric variation of the Maxwell action,

TabEM:=1μ0(FacFbc−14gabFcdFcd).

Then

∇aTEMab=−Fbcjc.

All fields and derivatives are smooth on U. In length-coordinate SI bookkeeping, assign [Fab]=Wb m−2, [μ0]=H m−1, [ja]=A m−2, and [TEM]=J m−3; these are formal units and not observed values. No quadratic stress is assigned to singular point self-fields or distributional sources.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: The Lorentzian metric, its metric-compatible torsion-free connection, a smooth real two-form F, a smooth vector current j, μ0>0, and the two Maxwell equations in the Statement.

[F1]

In the selected sourced convention, ∇aFab=−μ0jb and dF=0; equivalently the first equation is d⋆F=μ0ιjvolg. (Sourced Maxwell sign and current conservation)

[F2]

The Maxwell stress tensor obtained by compact variation at fixed lower F is TabEM=μ0−1(FacFbc−14gabFcdFcd). (Compact potential and metric variation of the Maxwell action)

[F3]

The induced connection on tensor fields satisfies the product rule and commutes with contractions; it is torsion-free and metric-compatible, so ∇agbc=0. (Existence and uniqueness of the metric-selected connection of a nondegenerate metric, and its extension to tensor fields)

[A1]

The geometric interface carries the ACω convention through its canonical smooth tangent-bundle supplier. This proof uses no choice after the smooth manifold, metric and fields are given. (Oriented Lorentzian fields, observers and coordinate conventions, The Axiom of Countable Choice (ACω))

Proof

technique · differentiate the variational Maxwell tensor, contract the homogeneous Maxwell identity with $F$, and cancel the derivative terms
1.1A1F1F3givenalgebra

Write F2:=FcdFcd. Because ∇ is torsion-free, dF=0 is equivalent to ∇aFdc+∇dFca+∇cFad=0. Metric compatibility and the product rule in [F3] give the raised-index derivatives used below.

2.1step 1.1F3algebra

Multiply the cyclic identity in step 1.1 by Fac. The first term is Xd:=Fac∇aFdc. In the third term, swapping the dummy indices a,c and using Fca=−Fac and Fad=−Fda gives another Xd. The middle term is Fac∇dFca=−12∇d(FacFac)=−12∇dF2. Thus 2Xd−12∇dF2=0, so Fac∇aFdc=14∇dF2.

3.1F1F2F3step 2.1algebra

Raise d in step 2.1 and differentiate the tensor in [F2]. The product rule yields μ0∇aTEMab=(∇aFac)Fbc+Fac∇aFbc−14∇bF2=−μ0jcFbc+14∇bF2−14∇bF2, where the sourced equation in [F1] gives the first term and step 2.1 gives the second.

4.1step 3.1algebra∎

The last two terms in step 3.1 cancel. Dividing by μ0>0 gives ∇aTEMab=−Fbcjc, as claimed. The calculation uses no regularity beyond the stated smoothness and no physical or empirical premise.

Remarks

5 · Examples, experiments and counterexamples

None yet.

Sources