How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Chern–Weil Theory and Characteristic Forms
1 · Prerequisites
- Abelian Categories
- Absolute and Conditional Convergence; Rearrangement; Products
- Binary Operations, Monoids, Groups and Subgroups
- Bocksteins Steenrod Squares and Cohomology Operations
- Cardinal Arithmetic, Cofinality and the Alephs
- Categories, Functors and Natural Transformations
- Chain Complexes and Homology
- Chain Homotopy and the Homotopy Category
- Chern and Pontryagin Classes by Splitting and Complexification
- Classification of Covering Spaces
- Compactness
- Compactness in Metric Spaces
- Completeness, Completion, and Uniform Continuity
- Composition Series, the Jordan–Hölder Theorem and Solvable Groups
- Congruences, the Integers Modulo n and the Chinese Remainder Theorem
- Connectedness
- Connections Levi Civita and Parallel Transport
- Constant Rank, Submersions, Immersions and Regular Level Sets
- Construction of the Natural Numbers
- Construction of the Real Numbers via Cauchy Sequences
- Construction of the Real Numbers via Dedekind Cuts
- Continuity, IVT, EVT, and Uniform Continuity
- Cosets, Index and Lagrange's Theorem
- Countability and Uncountability
- Countability Axioms and Cardinal Functions
- Covering Spaces and Lifting
- Cup Cap Cross Products and Cohomology Rings
- Cw Complexes and Cellular Homology
- Darboux, L'Hôpital, and Taylor's Theorem
- Derived Functors
- Determinants of Matrices over a Commutative Ring
- Diagonalisation and the Minimal Polynomial
- Divisibility, Euclidean Domains, Principal Ideal Domains and Unique Factorisation
- Divisibility, Greatest Common Divisors and Bézout's Identity
- Double Complexes Exact Couples and Convergence
- Dual Spaces, Bilinear and Quadratic Forms, and Sylvester's Law of Inertia
- Eigenvalues, Eigenvectors and the Characteristic Polynomial
- Euclidean Ordinary Differential Equations with Smooth Dependence
- Exactness and the Member Calculus
- Ext and Balanced Resolutions
- Exterior Powers, Orientation and Hodge Duality
- Fibrations Fiber Bundles and Homotopy Exact Sequences
- Filters and Ultrafilters
- Finite Counting, Factorials and Binomial Coefficients
- Foundations of the Real Numbers for Analysis
- Free Groups and Presentations
- Free Modules, Exact Sequences, Projective and Injective Modules
- Free Products and Amalgamation
- Fubini and Change of Variables
- Function Space Topologies and the Exponential Law
- Gaussian Elimination, Elementary Matrices and Reduced Row Echelon Form
- Group Actions, Orbits, Stabilisers and Cayley's Theorem
- Group Homomorphisms and the Isomorphism Theorems
- Hausdorff via the Diagonal
- Hereditary and Productive Behaviour of the Separation Axioms
- Higher Homotopy Groups and Cofiber Sequences
- Homology Axioms Degree and Classical Applications
- Homotopy and Homotopy Equivalence
- Hurewicz Whitehead Freudenthal and Cw Approximation
- Ideals, Quotient Rings and the Isomorphism Theorems for Rings
- Improper and Parameter-Dependent Multiple Integrals
- Inner Product Spaces, Gram-Schmidt, Projections and Adjoints
- Integration of Forms and the General Stokes Theorem
- Kunneth Exactness and Splittings over Principal Ideal Domains
- Leray–Hirsch, the Thom Isomorphism, and Gysin Sequences
- Lie Groups, Invariant Fields, and the Exponential Map
- Limits and Colimits
- Limits of Real Functions
- limsup, liminf, and Subsequential Limits
- Linear Independence, Bases and Dimension
- Linear Transformations, Rank-Nullity and Quotient Spaces
- Local Coefficients, Twisted Homology, and Duality
- Long Exact Sequences in Homology
- Manifolds with Boundary Collars and Orientations
- Matrices, the Matrix of a Linear Map, and Change of Basis
- Metric Spaces
- Mixed Partials, Taylor Formulae, and Extrema
- Modules, Submodules, Quotient Modules and the Isomorphism Theorems
- Monotone Functions, Discontinuities, and Continuity Sets
- Monotone Sequences, Bolzano-Weierstrass, and Cauchy Completeness
- Normal Subgroups and Quotient Groups
- Obstruction Theory, Postnikov Towers, and Classifying Spaces
- Order, Zorn's Lemma, and the Axiom of Choice
- Ordinal Arithmetic and the First Uncountable Ordinal
- Ordinals, Cardinals, and Transfinite Recursion
- Orientations Poincare Lefschetz and Alexander Duality
- Partitions of Unity and Paracompactness
- Picard-Lindelöf and First-Order Ordinary Differential Equations
- Polynomial Rings, the Division Algorithm and Roots
- Power Series and Real-Analytic Functions
- Preadditive and Additive Categories and Biproducts
- Projective and Injective Resolutions
- Properties of the Integral and the Working FTC
- Rank Theorems and Embedded Submanifolds
- Reflective Subcategories and the Adjoint Functor Theorems
- Relations, Functions, and Quotients
- Relative Homology Excision and Mayer Vietoris
- Riemann Curvature and Riemannian Submanifolds
- Rings, Subrings, Integral Domains and Fields
- Rⁿ as a Normed Space; Vector-Valued Functions
- Roots, Rational Powers, and Classical Inequalities
- Sard Theorem and Transversality
- Separation Axioms: the Hierarchy
- Sequences and Limits
- Sequences and Series of Functions; Uniform Convergence
- Series: Convergence and the Nonnegative Tests
- Simple Field Extensions and the Construction of the Complex Numbers
- Simplicial Complexes and Simplicial Homology
- Simplicial Subdivision and Simplicial Approximation
- Singular Chains and Singular Homology
- Singular Cochains Mayer Vietoris and Smooth Singular Comparison
- Singular Cohomology and Coefficient Theorems
- Smooth Manifolds and Smooth Maps
- Smooth Partitions of Unity and Exhaustions
- Smooth Vector Bundles and Sections
- Spectral Sequences
- Stiefel Whitney and Euler Classes by Universal Constructions
- Subobject Lattices Generators and the Grothendieck Axioms
- Subspaces, Products, and Quotients
- Suprema and Infima
- Symmetric Groups, Cycle Decomposition and the Sign Homomorphism
- Tangent Cotangent and the Differential
- Tensor Fields Exterior Algebra and Differential Forms
- Tensor Products of Modules
- The Cantor Set, Baire Category, and Measure Zero in ℝ
- The De Rham Complex Homotopy and Mayer Vietoris
- The de Rham Theorem and Degree
- The Derivative and the Mean Value Theorems
- The Determinant of a Linear Operator, Cofactors and Cramer's Rule
- The Diagram Lemmas in an Abelian Category
- The Divergence Theorem and Classical Stokes
- The Exponential Function
- The Exterior Derivative and Cartan Calculus
- The Fundamental Group
- The Fundamental Group of the Circle
- The Fundamental Theorems of Calculus
- The Group Algebra and Representations of Finite Groups
- The Inverse and Implicit Function Theorems
- The Inverse Function Theorem Completed
- The Riemann Integral in Rᵐ and Jordan Content
- The Riemann Integral: Definition and Integrability
- The Seifert–van Kampen Theorem
- The Serre Spectral Sequence and Applications
- The Topology of Euclidean Space
- The Total Derivative in ℝᵐ → ℝⁿ
- The ZFC Axioms and the Basic Set Constructions
- Topological Spaces and Continuity
- Topological Vector Bundles and Grassmannian Classification
- Topology of ℝ
- Triangularisation, Generalised Eigenspaces and Jordan Canonical Form
- Uniform Spaces: the Three Definitions
- Universal Coefficients and Kunneth Theorems
- Universal Properties, Representables and the Yoneda Lemma
- Urysohn's Lemma and the Tietze Extension Theorem
- Vector Fields Flows and Lie Derivatives
- Vector Spaces, Linear Subspaces, Span and Direct Sums
- Volumes of Elementary Solids and Solids of Revolution
- Whitney Embedding Tubular Neighbourhoods and Approximation
2 · Summary
This page develops Chern–Weil theory from invariant polynomials on matrix Lie algebras to characteristic forms on smooth vector bundles. A homogeneous -invariant polynomial is polarized to a symmetric multilinear form, and differentiating the invariance identity along a one-parameter subgroup gives the infinitesimal vanishing identity that drives the cancellations below. The Pfaffian is admitted only on in a fixed oriented orthonormal frame. Because the published connection interface is real, the page first records smooth complex structures, complex, Hermitian and Euclidean-compatible connections, and proves that every finite-rank real or complex bundle admits a compatible metric and connection under full AC.
Curvature evaluation wedges the scalar -form coefficients of the curvature in argument order with a fixed alternating normalization; -invariance of the transition matrices makes the local expressions a global form, and matrix order is retained inside traces, determinants and Pfaffians. Infinitesimal invariance cancels the covariant-commutator terms in the graded Leibniz rule, and the second Bianchi identity then makes every invariant curvature form closed. Passing to cohomology yields the unital multiplicative Chern–Weil homomorphism, and the affine path between two compatible connections supplies an explicit transgression form, so the class is independent of the connection and natural under smooth pullback.
The page then fixes the conventions: the Chern forms as determinant coefficients of , the Pontryagin forms by complexification with , and the Pfaffian Euler form in even rank. Comparison with topology is proved on smooth bases with boundary through a CW-homotopy-type bridge, a local first-Chern normalization, the oriented real two-plane splitting lemma and the complex flag splitting lemma. The resulting theorem identifies the de Rham classes of the characteristic forms with the real coefficient images of the corresponding topological classes, and direct sums and pullbacks obey the expected formulas.
The closing remark separates real characteristic forms from integral information: every integral torsion class maps to zero in real cohomology, so the forms cannot detect it, with the flat real line bundle over the real projective plane as witness. Full AC is used only through the compatible connection suppliers and the comparison machinery; the frame, determinant and transgression computations are choice-free once the connections are supplied. See chern-weil-theory-and-characteristic-forms-examples for explicit computations and counterexamples.
3 · Logical flowchart
4 · Definitions, theorems and proofs
Invariant symmetric polynomials on a matrix Lie algebra
Definition
Let be either a real matrix Lie group with real Lie algebra , or a complex matrix Lie group with complex Lie algebra . In the real case let and use polynomials in real linear coordinates with coefficients in . In the complex case take and use polynomials in complex linear coordinates (with no conjugate-coordinate variables). A homogeneous degree- polynomial is -invariant when where the adjoint action is the one in Conjugation and the adjoint representation of a Lie group. For , its polarization is the unique symmetric multilinear map with Here multilinearity is over when is a real Lie algebra and over when it is a complex Lie algebra; thus a -valued polynomial on a real Lie algebra still has a real-multilinear polarization. A complex matrix Lie group may also be regarded as a real Lie group, in which case the underlying real Lie algebra and real-multilinear convention apply; this is also the convention for real-valued coordinate polynomials on a complex matrix Lie algebra, such as on .
The polarization can be computed by where the bracket extracts the coefficient of . A homogeneous degree- coordinate polynomial makes this coefficient symmetric and multilinear in the ; setting every gives the coefficient , and the same extraction proves uniqueness. Since has characteristic zero, division by is valid. For , the invariant polynomials are constants, viewed as symmetric -linear forms . Finite sums of these homogeneous invariant polynomials form the invariant polynomial algebra; sums and products remain invariant because the adjoint action respects addition and multiplication of scalar values.
Polarization preserves invariance: simultaneous application of to the arguments leaves every term in the coefficient formula unchanged. Conversely, if a symmetric is invariant under simultaneous adjoint action, its diagonal is a -invariant polynomial. Differentiating that multilinear invariance along gives the infinitesimal identity Indeed, for matrices, , so the chain rule gives exactly the displayed sum. For the sum is empty and equals zero.
For , every coefficient of is invariant under , since and determinant is unchanged by conjugation. Its restriction to is therefore invariant for the adjoint action of . For the Pfaffian, use only with and a fixed oriented orthonormal frame. For , define and set This is a homogeneous polynomial of degree . If , the induced action on the top exterior power multiplies the oriented volume by ; hence . It is invariant under , and a reversal of orientation changes its sign. The convention gives ; for it gives the empty-matrix Pfaffian .
Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections
Definition
Let be a smooth real vector bundle of rank , where , over a smooth manifold that may have boundary. A smooth complex structure on is a smooth bundle endomorphism with . It makes each fiber a complex vector space by . Equivalently, has local smooth complex frames with transition maps in . In one direction, multiplication by in complex bundle charts gives such a smooth because the transition maps are complex-linear. Conversely, near any point choose a complex basis in its fiber and extend its vectors to local smooth real sections; those sections together with their -images remain a real frame after shrinking the neighborhood, and give a local complex frame. Forgetting smoothness in these charts gives the associated rank- complex topological vector bundle of Real and complex topological vector bundles.
For a smooth complex bundle , write for its smooth complex sections. A complex connection is a covariant derivative that is -linear and satisfies for every smooth complex-valued function and section . This extends the real bundle-connection convention of Connection on a smooth vector bundle. A complex connection is Hermitian for a supplied Hermitian metric , taken linear in its first variable and conjugate-linear in its second, when for all smooth sections and vector fields . A real connection on a Euclidean vector bundle is Euclidean-compatible when it obeys the same identity for the real bundle metric, as in Metric compatible connection on a riemannian vector bundle.
Local frame calculation
In a local complex frame write . Applying Hermitian compatibility to the frame sections gives After smooth Gram–Schmidt, a local unitary frame has , so . In a real orthonormal frame the corresponding equation is . With the curvature convention of Curvature two-form structure equation, these identities imply and , respectively: exterior differentiation preserves the adjoint relation, and for a matrix of one-forms because transposition reverses the matrix order while one-forms anticommute. The published local structure-equation calculation is coefficientwise, so it also applies to complex frame coefficients. Thus curvature matrices of Hermitian or Euclidean-compatible connections are skew-Hermitian or skew-symmetric in the corresponding frames. For rank zero these frame identities are vacuous. In boundary charts the same identities hold up to the boundary by restriction of the smooth half-space coefficient formulas.
Existence of compatible connections
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Choice (AC). Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, with boundary allowed. Every finite-rank smooth real vector bundle over admits a smooth Euclidean bundle metric and a Euclidean-compatible smooth connection. Every finite-rank smooth complex vector bundle over admits a smooth Hermitian metric and a Hermitian complex connection. In particular, any supplied Euclidean or Hermitian metric on such a bundle admits a compatible connection. Here “complex connection,” “Hermitian,” and “Euclidean-compatible” have the meanings in Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The stated manifold and bundle; a metric is supplied for the connection-existence clause.
Full AC says every family of nonempty sets has a choice function. The Axiom of Choice.
Under countable choice, every smooth real vector bundle over a boundaryless base admits a smooth bundle metric. Every smooth vector bundle admits a smooth bundle metric.
Under countable choice, every open cover of a boundaryless smooth manifold admits a smooth subordinate partition of unity. Smooth partitions of unity exist on manifolds.
Under countable choice, every open cover of a smooth manifold with boundary admits a smooth subordinate partition of unity. Smooth partitions of unity exist on manifolds with boundary.
A smooth complex bundle has local smooth complex frames and a smooth complex structure on its underlying real bundle. Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections.
A complex connection is -linear and obeys the smooth-function Leibniz rule. Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections.
A Hermitian connection obeys the Hermitian metric-derivative identity. Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections.
A real Euclidean-compatible connection obeys the real metric-derivative identity. Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections.
The same local product convention for smooth real vector bundles is used when the base has boundary. Connection on a smooth vector bundle.
Proof
Given: Full AC, a bundle over , and, when constructing a compatible connection, a supplied smooth Hermitian or Euclidean metric.
Let be any sequence of nonempty sets. Apply [A1] to the set of distinct values and compose the resulting choice function with . This gives a choice function for the sequence; the finite and empty indexed cases are immediate. Thus the countable-choice hypotheses of [F1], [F2], and [F3] hold. This is the only use of full AC.
For a real bundle over a boundaryless base, [F1] supplies a smooth Euclidean metric. If has boundary, take its supplied local trivializing frame cover by [F7]; in each frame pull back the standard positive-definite inner product on . Apply [F3] to this cover and call the resulting partition . The locally finite sum , with each weighted term extended by zero outside its frame domain, is smooth because lies inside that domain. At each point the weights are nonnegative and sum to one, so is positive definite. The empty base has its unique metric. Hence every real bundle in the statement has a smooth Euclidean metric.
For a complex bundle, let be its smooth complex structure from [F4] and let be the real metric from step 2.1 on its underlying real bundle. Set . Then is smooth, positive definite, and -invariant; in particular . Define . The skew identity gives and ; real bilinearity therefore makes complex-linear in its first variable and conjugate-linear in its second. Symmetry of gives , while gives for . Thus is a smooth Hermitian metric in the stated convention.
Apply the local construction to a metric supplied at the start, or to the metric produced in steps 2.1 and 3.1 when proving existence for an arbitrary bundle. On each member of its local bundle-frame cover, apply Gram–Schmidt to the supplied frame to obtain an orthonormal frame in the real case or a unitary frame in the complex case, using [F4] and [F7]. All denominators are norms of nonzero vectors, so the procedure is smooth; in boundary charts the same formulas restrict from local smooth extensions. For a frame , define a local connection by . Its matrix is zero in that orthonormal or unitary frame, so it is compatible with the metric by [F5] and [F6]. It is a complex connection by [F8]. Rank zero gives the empty frame and the unique zero connection.
Choose the partition subordinate to this orthonormal/unitary frame cover using [F2] when is boundaryless and [F3] when it has boundary. Define , extending each weighted term by zero outside its frame domain. This sum is locally finite and smooth. For a smooth scalar function , each local connection obeys the relevant Leibniz rule by [F8], so , because . The same calculation gives complex-linearity in the complex case. Since every is real-valued, summing the local metric identities [F5] and [F6] gives , or its real Euclidean version. Thus is globally compatible.
Steps 2.1 and 3.1 construct the stated real and complex metrics, and step 5.1 constructs compatible connections both for those metrics and for any metric supplied at the start. At an empty base the assertions are vacuous; at rank zero the unique metric and connection satisfy the identities vacuously. At rank one Gram–Schmidt and the local connection formula remain valid. On a zero-dimensional base every local connection one-form is zero, and the averaging and compatibility identities still hold. The partition and frame formulas also restrict to the boundary by steps 2.1, 4.1, and 5.1.
Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature
Definition
Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly with boundary. Let , let be a real or complex matrix Lie group in , and let be its Lie algebra. For a smooth rank- -vector bundle , a -frame atlas is a supplied open cover with local frames whose transition matrices , defined by , take values in . This is the local-frame description of a reduction of the frame group to . If , a connection means a complex connection as in Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections; for it means an ordinary smooth bundle connection. A connection is compatible with this reduction when its connection matrix in every supplied -frame is -valued. In the convention of Curvature two-form structure equation, its curvature matrix is
It is -valued: for tangent vectors , the second term evaluates to , and both this bracket and lie in .
Let be a homogeneous degree- -invariant polynomial, with symmetric multilinear polarization as in Invariant symmetric polynomials on a matrix Lie algebra. For , define its evaluation on curvature in a supplied -frame by the alternating -form
where is any basis of and . The right side is the multilinear extension of followed by exterior multiplication, so it is independent of the chosen basis or tensor decomposition. Equivalently, for ,
For , set , the corresponding constant -valued -form. A finite sum of homogeneous invariant polynomials is evaluated degree by degree and the resulting forms are added.
These local forms agree on overlaps. Indeed, Vector-bundle curvature is an endomorphism-valued two-form makes the curvature a global -valued -form. To see its frame transformation, if a fibre vector has coordinate columns and an endomorphism has matrices , then . Applying this pointwise to curvature gives . Since , simultaneous -invariance of gives
Thus the local evaluations define a global -valued -form. For , this means a complex-valued form, obtained by complexifying the real form convention; the same local formulas are smooth up to boundary charts by The de Rham complex and pullback extend to manifolds with boundary.
Remarks
All scalar -form coefficients commute under exterior multiplication because their degree is even. Matrix factors inside polynomial expressions, including traces and determinant coefficients, retain the order prescribed by the matrix polynomial.
The reduction and compatible connection are part of the input when is invariant only under . For a polynomial invariant under the full general linear group, the construction may use the full frame group. The in-scope applications use -invariant polynomials for Chern forms, their complexified analogues for Pontryagin forms, and the Pfaffian on with an oriented orthonormal frame for Euler forms.
The local -frames and compatible connection are supplied data. The definition makes no simultaneous global choice of frames, and its construction uses no axiom of choice.
Invariant polynomials cancel connection commutators
Statement
Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly with boundary. Let be a real or complex matrix Lie group with Lie algebra , and let be the symmetric multilinear polarization of a homogeneous -invariant polynomial, where or . Work in a supplied -frame chart with a connection compatible with that reduction, so its local connection form is -valued. For each homogeneous -valued form , extend by applying it to the Lie-algebra coefficients and wedging the scalar-form coefficients in the displayed argument order. Define Then In particular, the signed sum of the graded connection-commutator terms is zero. For , the assertion is . The identity is local and hence also holds in boundary charts by restriction of the same coefficient calculation.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: A smooth -frame chart, a compatible connection, the invariant polarization , and homogeneous -valued forms with degrees .
A compatible connection has a -valued local connection form, and invariant-polynomial evaluation uses the listed-order wedge extension (Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature).
The polarization is symmetric and satisfies (Invariant symmetric polynomials on a matrix Lie algebra).
The covariant exterior derivative of an -valued form is defined by alternating the induced covariant derivative (Second Bianchi identity for a bundle connection).
The induced Hom connection satisfies (Product connection on tensor and hom bundles).
Exterior differentiation obeys the degree-one graded Leibniz rule (The exterior derivative is a graded derivation).
On boundary charts, the exterior derivative is defined by locally extendible half-space coefficients, independently of the extension, and the graded Leibniz rule restricts to the boundary (The de Rham complex and pullback extend to manifolds with boundary).
Proof
Proof technique: expand the scalar-form extension of in one local frame and use infinitesimal invariance coefficient by coefficient.
In a fixed basis write and extend by ; this finite tensor contraction is basis independent. Put . The graded Leibniz rule [F5] gives .
The covariant exterior derivative is the alternation of the induced End connection by [F3]. From [F4], in this frame , so alternation yields , where . Since and are -valued and is closed under brackets, is -valued. Substituting into step 1.1 reduces the claim to .
Write as a sum of scalar 1-forms times Lie-algebra elements and each as a sum of scalar -forms times Lie-algebra elements; locally each scalar form is a sum of coefficient functions times coordinate wedges. Fix one resulting coefficient monomial. In the th graded commutator, reordering the scalar -form to contributes , canceling its commutator factor and leaving . Moving past the earlier scalar forms contributes , canceling the prefactor in . The common ordered coefficient is therefore by [F2], so every coefficient of vanishes. The same calculation holds in boundary charts by [F6]. For the form is the constant and its derivative is zero; no simultaneous choice is made.
Closedness of invariant curvature forms
Statement
Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly with boundary. Let be a smooth finite-rank real or complex vector bundle with a supplied -frame atlas and a connection compatible with that reduction, and let be a homogeneous degree- -invariant polynomial as in Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature. If is the curvature matrix in a supplied -frame, then its global evaluation is closed. This includes , where the evaluation is the constant -form. The assertion applies to , , , and within their stated invariant-polynomial scopes. Finite sums are closed degree by degree.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The manifold, bundle, compatible connection, curvature, and invariant polynomial in the Statement.
For the curvature of a bundle connection, the covariant exterior derivative satisfies (Second Bianchi identity for a bundle connection).
For homogeneous -valued forms, the differential of the invariant-polynomial extension is the signed sum obtained by applying in each slot; the identity also holds in boundary charts (Invariant polynomials cancel connection commutators).
The compatible connection and invariant polynomial define the global curvature evaluation used in the Statement (Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature).
Proof
Proof technique: apply the covariant Leibniz identity to repeated copies of the curvature and use the second Bianchi identity.
If , the evaluation is a constant -form and its exterior derivative is zero. Suppose . On each supplied -frame chart use [F2] with . Since every has degree , each prefix sign is , and [F2] gives . By [F3] this local expression is the differential of the global form in the Statement.
In the supplied frame, from [F2] is the local expression for the covariant exterior derivative in [F1]. Hence , so every summand in step 1.1 vanishes. Thus the differential is zero on every chart and therefore is zero globally. The calculation is coefficientwise and also restricts to boundary charts as specified in [F2]. The conclusion for a finite sum follows by linearity.
Chern–Weil map for a chosen connection
Statement
Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly with boundary. Let be a smooth rank- real or complex vector bundle with a supplied -frame atlas, where is a real or complex matrix Lie group, and let be a fixed connection compatible with that reduction. For the algebra of finite sums of -invariant polynomials with values in . For each , write for its normalized symmetric polarization (with ), and define where a degree- polynomial maps to cohomological degree . The map is a graded unital -algebra homomorphism, with polynomial multiplication on the source and wedge product on the target, and . The coefficient convention for on boundary manifolds is specified below. This definition depends on the fixed connection; independence of its cohomology value is a later theorem.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: , , the supplied -frame atlas, its compatible connection, and a finite sum of -invariant polynomials with coefficients in .
Degree zero evaluates as the corresponding constant -form (Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature).
A compatible connection and invariant polynomial give a global -valued curvature form (Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature).
The global evaluation of each homogeneous invariant polynomial on the curvature is closed, including degree zero (Closedness of invariant curvature forms).
Each homogeneous invariant polynomial has a unique normalized symmetric polarization whose diagonal is the polynomial (Invariant symmetric polynomials on a matrix Lie algebra).
Finite sums of homogeneous invariant polynomials form an algebra under addition and multiplication (Invariant symmetric polynomials on a matrix Lie algebra).
On a manifold with boundary the real forms form a cochain complex and the exterior derivative obeys the graded Leibniz rule; its cohomology is formed as cycles modulo boundaries (The de Rham complex and pullback extend to manifolds with boundary).
On a boundaryless manifold the published real de Rham cohomology is a unital graded-commutative real algebra with unit (De rham cohomology ring).
The real de Rham cohomology of the empty manifold is the zero algebra with (De rham cohomology ring).
Definition
For the real coefficient target, use the ordinary real de Rham complex when and the locally extendible boundary-chart complex from [F5] when has boundary; write its cohomology ring as . Its product is induced by wedge: the graded Leibniz rule in [F5] makes exact changes of a closed representative exact. For , set . For , set This is the complex-valued smooth-form complex, with boundary coefficients locally extendible componentwise. Real and imaginary parts split its cycles and exact forms, so its cohomology is ; wedge and the unit extend -linearly. On the empty manifold the target is the zero algebra with , as in [F7].
For a polynomial homogeneous of degree , use its polarization in the global form from [F2]. Define the map by taking its cohomology class and summing over the homogeneous components. No connection-independence assertion is included in the definition.
Proof
Well-definedness and algebra law.
The target complex for is the complexification of the real complex: every complex-valued form is uniquely with real forms , and exactly when ; it is exact exactly when both real and imaginary parts are exact. Hence cohomology splits as the stated complexification, wedge induces its -algebra product by the graded Leibniz rule in [F5], and for boundaryless the real target agrees with the unital ring [F6]. If it is the zero algebra [F7].
For every homogeneous component , the global form supplied by [F2] is closed by [F3], so it determines a class in the target cohomology from step 1.1; degree zero is the constant -form [F1], also closed. The finite sum therefore defines the displayed map.
Let be homogeneous with normalized symmetric polarizations and . The normalized polarization from [F4] of their product, which is an invariant polynomial by [F8], is where list and list its complement. This is symmetric and multilinear with diagonal . On setting every equal to the curvature -form, every summand evaluates to : scalar coefficient forms have even degree and commute. Thus evaluation preserves products, including or , and passing to cohomology gives the algebra law.
Multilinearity of polarization [F4], exterior multiplication, and the cohomology quotient makes the map -linear and degree doubling. By [F1], the constant polynomial evaluates to the constant -form , hence to the target unit; if is empty both are the zero-algebra unit by [F7]. This proves the unital graded algebra claim. The connection is fixed throughout, and no step asserts that changing it leaves the class unchanged. The atlas and connection are supplied data, so no axiom of choice is used.
Explicit Chern–Simons transgression between two connections
Statement
Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly with boundary. Let be a finite-rank real or complex smooth vector bundle with a fixed -frame reduction, and let be connections compatible with that same reduction. Put , , and let be the curvature of . For a homogeneous degree- -invariant polynomial with symmetric polarization, , define
This is a global -form and
For , the two constant curvature evaluations agree, so their difference is zero. The result applies to the , , , and reductions with their respective invariant polynomials.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The smooth base, fixed -reduction, compatible endpoint connections, and invariant polynomial in the Statement.
In a supplied -frame, curvature is ; its invariant-polynomial evaluation patches to a global form (Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature).
The symmetric polarization is invariant under simultaneous adjoint action by (Invariant symmetric polynomials on a matrix Lie algebra).
The difference of two connections is a global endomorphism-valued one-form, whose frame matrix is (The difference of two connections is an endomorphism valued one form).
A complex connection is -linear, so a difference of complex connections is complex-linear on the underlying real bundle (Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections).
For homogeneous -valued forms, differentiating the invariant-polynomial extension is the signed sum obtained by applying in each slot (Invariant polynomials cancel connection commutators).
For each connection with curvature , the covariant exterior derivative satisfies (Second Bianchi identity for a bundle connection).
On a manifold with boundary, the exterior derivative is defined by locally extendible coefficients and obeys the graded Leibniz rule (The de Rham complex and pullback extend to manifolds with boundary).
Proof
Proof technique: differentiate the invariant curvature form along the affine path and integrate its exact derivative.
By [F3], is a global endomorphism-valued one-form; for a complex bundle [F7] ensures that the difference remains complex-linear. In every supplied -frame its matrix is -valued. If is a transition matrix, then and ; hence is a compatible connection for every . The curvature transforms by conjugation, so [F2] makes agree in all frames. Its coefficients are smooth in , hence integrating on the compact interval defines a global smooth form of degree .
In a fixed -frame, [F1] gives . Differentiating this expression in yields , since for a one-form the local covariant derivative is .
Set . Symmetry of and the even degree of every curvature factor give . Applying [F4] to leaves : every other term contains by [F5]. Here the local in [F4] is the covariant exterior derivative in [F5]. Therefore .
Integrating the identity from step 3.1 gives . To justify the last equality, write in a chart; each is smooth, and each coordinate derivative commutes with its integral over compact , so the equality holds coefficient by coefficient. On boundary charts the same calculation restricts from local extensions by [F6]. For both endpoint forms are the same constant and their difference is zero. No axiom of choice is used.
Connection independence and naturality of Chern–Weil classes
Statement
Let and be finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifolds, with boundary allowed. Let be a finite-rank real or complex bundle with a supplied -frame reduction, where the applicable group is , , , or . For a finite sum of -invariant polynomials, let be the map defined in Chern–Weil map for a chosen connection using a connection compatible with this same reduction.
For any two compatible connections on , For every smooth map , equip with its pulled-back -reduction and use the pullback connection . Then where for boundary manifolds smoothness and pullback of forms use the library's local-extension convention. For each supplied compatible connection, is a unital graded algebra homomorphism in .
Assume full Axiom of Choice (AC) for the existence assertion: every such real or complex bundle with a fixed , , or reduction admits a compatible connection. The connection-independence and pullback assertions for supplied compatible connections do not use AC.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The manifolds and bundle; a supplied -frame atlas; a finite sum of -invariant polynomials; and, for the first two assertions, the compatible connection or pair of compatible connections explicitly named. A smooth map is included when proving naturality.
Full AC says every family of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Choice).
For a fixed compatible connection, the Chern–Weil construction is a unital graded algebra map (Chern–Weil map for a chosen connection).
For every homogeneous degree , the difference of endpoint curvature evaluations is the exterior derivative of the explicit transgression form; degree zero has equal endpoint evaluations (Explicit Chern–Simons transgression between two connections).
Under AC, every real or complex bundle admits a compatible metric and connection, and any supplied Euclidean or Hermitian metric admits a compatible connection (Existence of compatible connections).
In a pulled-back frame the pullback connection matrix is the entrywise pullback of the original matrix (Pullback connection).
The pullback prescription defines a unique connection independent of frames (Pullback connection is well defined and functorial).
In a local frame the curvature matrix satisfies (Curvature two-form structure equation).
A smooth map between manifolds with boundary has coordinate representatives smooth in the local-extension sense (Smooth maps between manifolds with boundary).
On the boundary-capable form complex, pullback commutes with , preserves wedges, and induces maps on de Rham cohomology (The de Rham complex and pullback extend to manifolds with boundary).
Curvature evaluation is the multilinear extension of the invariant polarization followed by exterior multiplication (Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature).
Hermitian-compatible and Euclidean-compatible connections obey their respective metric-derivative identities (Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections).
In frames related by , connection matrices satisfy (Connection one form transformation law).
Local connection matrices satisfying that transition identity define a unique connection (Local connection forms glue exactly when they obey the transformation law).
Proof
Write as its finite homogeneous decomposition. For , apply [F2] to on the same supplied -reduction: the representative difference is exact. For , both representatives are the same constant form. Taking classes and adding the finitely many homogeneous components proves the displayed connection-independence equality, including for complex coefficients and boundary bases.
Let be smooth. Pull back each supplied frame to on ; its transition matrix is , still valued in . The definition [F4] gives local connection matrix , with values in the Lie algebra of . On boundary charts use local smooth extensions as in [F7]. On boundaryless charts [F5] supplies frame-independent gluing; for boundary charts, differentiating the frame relation gives [F11], whose product-rule derivation applies to the locally extendible coefficients at boundary points. Pulling the matrix identity back and using [F8] yields This is precisely the gluing identity [F12]. Explicitly, if , the product rule gives ; the local expressions therefore define one connection, including at boundary points. This establishes the boundary case directly without presuming [F5] covers it. Finally, the structure equation [F6] and [F8] give, entry by entry, . Thus the pulled-back connection preserves the pulled-back reduction.
Assume [A1]. The compatible-connection existence result [F3] supplies a metric and a compatible connection for every real or complex bundle in the stated scope, and supplies compatible connections for any given Euclidean or Hermitian metric. A general linear reduction is preserved by any such real or complex connection. For a reduction the supplied Hermitian metric makes [F3] Hermitian-compatible; applying its metric-derivative identity [F10] in a unitary frame gives a skew-Hermitian connection matrix. For an reduction the supplied oriented Euclidean metric makes [F3] Euclidean-compatible. Applying its metric-derivative identity to an oriented orthonormal frame gives a skew-symmetric connection matrix, hence a -valued matrix in each such frame. This proves existence. AC is used only here, through [F3]; all other claims use supplied connections and no choice axiom.
By [F1], for the fixed supplied connection the map preserves multiplication and the unit in the invariant-polynomial algebra. This proves the stated multiplicativity without using connection independence as a premise.
For each , [F9] expresses the curvature evaluation as a multilinear combination of wedge products of scalar coefficient forms. Pullback preserves those products by [F8], so step 1.2 gives . For both sides are the pullback of the same constant -form. Summing over gives equality of representative forms. Since [F8] induces the pullback map on the de Rham quotients, their classes satisfy the stated naturality equation. For complex coefficients the same cochain equality holds componentwise on real and imaginary parts. If another compatible connection is chosen on , step 1.1 gives the same class.
If is empty, its de Rham target is the zero algebra and every class equality is the unique equality there; a map to the empty manifold can exist only when is empty. For rank zero, the connection is unique and only the degree-zero polynomial evaluation can be nonzero. At rank one the matrix and pullback computations above remain scalar and use no rank lower bound. Any form degree above the base dimension is zero, so the equalities remain valid in those degrees. The path in [F2] is integrated from to , giving exactly the two endpoint forms in the order used in step 1.1. The theorem contains no iff assertion.
Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler characteristic forms
Statement
Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly with boundary. If is a rank- complex vector bundle with complex connection and curvature , define the total Chern form where has degree . For a Hermitian connection these forms are real-valued; a general complex connection need not give real-valued forms.
For a rank- real vector bundle with real connection , let carry the complexified connection and set Then , when , and every is real-valued, even if is not metric-compatible. If is compatible with a Euclidean metric, each odd Chern form vanishes pointwise. Assume full Axiom of Choice (AC); for every real connection each is then exact, with AC used through existence of a metric-compatible connection and the transgression lemma.
If is an oriented Euclidean bundle of even rank and is metric-compatible, define where the Pfaffian uses the ordered oriented orthonormal frame and . These curvature evaluations are closed forms. In rank zero, . The Euler form is defined here only for oriented even-rank Euclidean bundles with a metric-compatible connection.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The manifold and bundle; the complex or real connection in the relevant clause; and, for the Hermitian or Euler clause, the supplied compatible metric and orientation.
Full AC says every family of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Choice).
The coefficients of are invariant polynomials on , and polarization preserves invariance (Invariant symmetric polynomials on a matrix Lie algebra).
Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature gives a global form of the prescribed degree (Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature).
A Hermitian connection obeys the Hermitian metric derivative identity (Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections).
Under AC, each smooth real bundle has a Euclidean metric and a compatible connection (Existence of compatible connections).
For the same -reduction, two connections' invariant curvature evaluations differ by the exterior derivative of the supplied transgression form, including on manifolds with boundary (Explicit Chern–Simons transgression between two connections).
The Pfaffian is invariant under , with the fixed orientation sign (Invariant symmetric polynomials on a matrix Lie algebra).
The global evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature is closed (Closedness of invariant curvature forms).
In a local frame, the curvature matrix is (Curvature two-form structure equation).
A Euclidean-compatible connection obeys the real metric derivative identity (Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections).
Proof
For , let be the coefficient of in . The determinant expansion makes homogeneous of degree , with and for . Conjugation leaves the determinant unchanged, so is invariant by [F1]. Applying [F2] and [F7] gives a global closed form of degree ; define and sum these forms to obtain the stated total determinant. This is the published determinant normalization; the global form-level construction here follows from the curvature-evaluation suppliers.
For a real bundle define and extend complex-linearly; in a real frame its curvature is the same real matrix over . Let be the coefficient of in . Since , we have . Each is real, so is a real closed form; the rank cutoff gives for , and the constant coefficient gives . This sign agrees with the published Pontryagin convention; real-valuedness for arbitrary real connections follows here from the real coefficients .
If is Hermitian, applying [F3] in a unitary frame gives . The structure equation [F8] and the identity give , so satisfies . Its even-degree entries commute, and coefficientwise conjugation and transpose yield ; therefore every is real-valued. Haller states the equivalent self-adjoint normalized-curvature and real-trace fact; the determinant calculation proves form-level reality of every coefficient here.
If preserves a Euclidean metric, choose a local orthonormal frame; applying [F9] to the frame vectors gives . The structure equation [F8] and anticommutation of one-form coefficients give , hence . Since scalar coefficients of even-degree forms commute, , so every odd coefficient is zero and step 1.2 gives pointwise. The total Pontryagin form is because all odd determinant coefficients vanish.
On the trivial complex line over with coordinates , take . Its curvature is , and step 1.1 gives , which is not real-valued. This witness shows that no general reality assertion holds for arbitrary complex connections.
For any real connection assume [A1]; [F4] supplies a Euclidean metric and a metric-compatible connection on . The complexified connections are both compatible with the same reduction of . For each odd , step 2.1 gives , while [F5] gives ; hence is exact. This is the only AC use: it supplies the comparison connection through [F4]; the determinant calculation and transgression are choice-free once the connections are given.
For an oriented Euclidean bundle of rank , step 2.1 gives curvature in ; by [F6] the Pfaffian is -invariant with the stated normalization. Its evaluation on is therefore a global closed real form by [F2] and [F7]. In oriented orthonormal frames a transition obeys , so the local forms patch; for an orientation-reversing orthogonal frame change the factor is . Milnor–Stasheff Appendix C, Lemma C.12, gives the same covariance and rank-two normalization.
If the base is empty, every form space has its unique section, so each total form is the unique inhomogeneous form there. If the rank is zero, the empty determinant and Pfaffian are both and every positive Pontryagin index vanishes by step 1.2. For rank one, and a real rank-one bundle has . Forms whose degree exceeds are zero, including a top Pfaffian when . The same frame calculations hold in boundary charts, and [F2] and [F5] include the boundary-capable form complex. Supplied-data calculations use no choice; only step 3.1 assumes AC, and this statement contains no iff assertion.
Smooth manifolds have CW homotopy type
Statement
Assume AC. Every finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, including a manifold with boundary and the empty manifold, is paracompact Hausdorff, compactly generated weak Hausdorff, and has the homotopy type of a CW complex. Every smooth finite-rank vector bundle on it is numerable.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC and a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold , possibly with boundary or empty.
The Axiom of Choice says every family of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Choice).
The Axiom of Countable Choice says every at-most-countable family of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Countable Choice ()).
Under , every smooth -manifold admits a proper smooth embedding into (The weak Whitney proper embedding theorem).
Under , every embedded smooth submanifold of Euclidean space has a tubular neighbourhood diffeomorphic to an open neighbourhood of that submanifold (The Euclidean tubular neighbourhood theorem).
Under , every smooth manifold with boundary has a smooth collar (Collar neighborhood theorem).
Under , every open cover of a smooth manifold with boundary has a smooth partition of unity subordinate to it (Smooth partitions of unity exist on manifolds with boundary).
Under , every open cover of a smooth manifold has a smooth partition of unity subordinate to it (Smooth partitions of unity exist on manifolds).
In a locally compact Hausdorff space every neighbourhood of a point contains a compact neighbourhood (In a locally compact Hausdorff space every point has a neighbourhood base of compact sets, every open subspace and every closed subspace is locally compact, every open set around a point contains an open set with compact closure inside it, and every compact set sits inside an open set with compact closure).
In a locally compact Hausdorff space, an open neighbourhood of a point contains an open neighbourhood whose compact closure stays inside it (In a locally compact Hausdorff space every point has a neighbourhood base of compact sets, every open subspace and every closed subspace is locally compact, every open set around a point contains an open set with compact closure inside it, and every compact set sits inside an open set with compact closure).
Under , every second-countable space is Lindelöf (Assuming countable choice, every second countable space is Lindelöf).
A space is regular exactly when each open neighbourhood of contains an open with (A space is regular if and only if every point has a neighbourhood base of closed neighbourhoods, if and only if open gives an open with ).
Under , every regular Lindelöf space is paracompact (Under countable choice, every regular Lindelöf space is paracompact).
Weak Hausdorffness tests closed images of maps from compact Hausdorff spaces, and compact generation tests closed subsets by their preimages under all such maps (Compactly generated conventions for based homotopy).
A topological manifold without boundary is Hausdorff and second-countable, and every point has a neighbourhood homeomorphic to an open subset of Euclidean space (Topological manifolds without boundary: Hausdorff, second-countable, and locally Euclidean spaces).
A topological manifold with boundary is Hausdorff and second-countable, and every point has a chart to a relatively open subset of the closed half-space (Topological manifolds with and without boundary).
A smooth manifold without boundary has a smooth atlas whose chart domains are open subsets of the manifold (Smooth manifolds and their smooth charts).
For a smooth manifold with boundary, boundary charts are homeomorphisms onto relatively open subsets of a closed half-space and their compatible atlases define its smooth structure (Smooth charts, atlases, and structures with boundary).
A smooth finite-rank vector bundle has an open cover by local trivializations that are linear on every fiber (Smooth vector bundles, rank, fibres, and trivial bundles).
A smooth complex rank- bundle is a smooth real rank- bundle with a smooth fiberwise endomorphism satisfying ; equivalently, it has local smooth complex frames (Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections).
A vector bundle is numerable when it has a linear trivializing cover with a locally finite subordinate partition of unity (Real and complex topological vector bundles).
An abstract simplicial complex is a set of finite vertex subsets closed under taking subsets (An abstract simplicial complex).
Its geometric realization consists of finitely supported barycentric coordinates on simplices and has the weak topology with respect to its closed simplex inclusions (The geometric realization of an abstract simplicial complex).
A CW complex is Hausdorff, has closure-finite cells, and has the weak topology with respect to the closed cells (CW complex with closure finiteness and weak topology).
The boundary of a smooth manifold with boundary is closed, and it is empty in dimension zero (The boundary of a positive-dimensional manifold is a closed embedded smooth (n-1)-manifold).
In positive-dimensional Euclidean space every closed bounded subset is compact (Heine-Borel in : with the Euclidean metric a subset of is compact if and only if it is closed and bounded, and the proof by bisection uses no choice principle; the same holds on the real line).
Proof
Given any sequence of nonempty sets, apply [A1] to its range and compose the resulting choice function with . Thus the assumed AC implies [F1], which is the exact choice strength required by the published suppliers below.
Each point of has a chart into an open subset of or a relatively open subset of the closed half-space by [F14] or [F15]. If , around its coordinate image choose a small open ball (intersected with the half-space when needed) whose closed ball lies in the chart image; this closed, bounded subset is compact by [F25]. Its chart preimage is compact because the chart is a homeomorphism (pull back any open cover), and it contains an open neighbourhood of the original point. Hence is locally compact; it is Hausdorff by the given hypothesis. If , the local model is a point, which is itself a compact neighbourhood.
If is continuous with compact Hausdorff, then is compact: pull any open cover of back to a cover of and take a finite subcover. Since is Hausdorff, [F12] makes closed. By [F13], is weak Hausdorff.
For any second-countable locally compact Hausdorff space , [F8] gives the closure-shrinking property, so [F10] makes regular; [F9] makes it Lindelöf under [F1], and [F11] then makes it paracompact. Applying this implication to proves its paracompactness.
Let be k-closed in the sense of [F13], and fix . By [F7], choose a compact neighbourhood of and an open with . The inclusion is a compact Hausdorff test, so is closed in . There is therefore an open with . Then is an open neighbourhood of disjoint from . Thus every k-closed subset of is closed; the reverse implication follows by continuity of every test map, so . Hence is compactly generated and, with step 1.3, CGWH.
First suppose has no boundary. By [F2] and step 1.1 it admits a proper smooth embedding , where .
Now suppose . By [F4] take a collar with open image. By [F24], is open. Apply [F5] to the cover and let be the partition function assigned to . Its support lies in , and on because the other cover member misses the boundary. Put for and for , and define . Then near and for . On the collar set and set outside . The new collar coordinate stays below ; because has support contained in , this formula glues continuously to the identity. For every boundary point moves into the interior, and every interior point stays there. Thus maps to , while gives both and, on the interior, for the inclusion .
Let be a finite-rank real or complex smooth vector bundle. In the real case [F18] gives a linear trivializing cover. For a complex bundle presented as a real smooth bundle with smooth fiberwise , fix any point and a complex basis in ; extend its vectors to smooth local sections in a real trivialization. Those sections and their -images remain real-linearly independent after shrinking, since their coordinate determinant is nonzero at and varies continuously. They form local complex frames; on overlaps the transition maps commute with and have smooth real matrix entries, so are smooth complex-linear trivializations. The pointwise construction selects no global family. If has boundary, [F5] supplies a locally finite smooth partition subordinate to either cover; otherwise [F6] does. Forgetting smoothness gives a topological linear trivializing cover, and [F20] makes the cover with its partition a numeration. This includes rank zero and the empty manifold, where the empty cover and empty partition satisfy the definition.
In the boundaryless branch of step 2.3, the image is closed. Indeed, for take an open Euclidean ball about contained in a compact closed ball , compact by [F25]. Properness means compact sets have compact preimages, so is compact; its image is compact and closed by [F12]. The open set contains and misses , proving closedness. Now [F3] gives an open tubular neighbourhood of , diffeomorphic to a disk neighbourhood in its normal bundle. The homotopy , , is defined inside that disk neighbourhood and retracts onto . Thus in this branch .
In the boundaryless branch, the open set from step 3.1 is second-countable, locally compact, and Hausdorff, so the implication proved in step 2.1 makes it paracompact. Let be the set of all Euclidean open balls whose closed balls lie in . This is an open cover; each nonempty finite intersection is convex and hence contractible by straight-line contraction to any point in that intersection. Since is itself a smooth manifold, [F6] supplies a subordinate partition of unity. Hatcher, Algebraic Topology, §4G, Proposition 4G.2 and Corollary 4G.3, then give : the proposition uses the subordinate partition, and the corollary uses the paracompactness and contractible finite intersections just verified.
In the boundaryless branch, the nerve is the abstract simplicial complex whose vertices are the balls and whose finite simplices are the subfamilies with nonempty intersection. In its realization, distinct points differ at some vertex coordinate; that coordinate is continuous by the weak topology, so disjoint intervals separate the points. The open simplices are cells, each closed simplex meets only its finitely many faces, and the weak topology in [F22] is exactly the closed-cell topology in [F23]. Attaching the simplices in increasing dimension therefore gives a CW structure on . From steps 3.1 and 4.1, the boundaryless has the homotopy type of this CW complex.
The interior is a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold without boundary by [F14] and restriction of the charts and smooth structure in [F16] and [F17]. Applying the boundaryless argument of steps 2.3, 3.1, 4.1, and 5.1 to gives it CW homotopy type; step 2.4 makes its inclusion into a homotopy equivalence. Therefore also has CW homotopy type.
Step 2.1 establishes paracompactness; steps 1.3 and 2.2 establish weak Hausdorffness and compact generation, while Hausdorffness is assumed. Steps 5.1 and 6.1 establish CW homotopy type in the boundaryless and boundary cases, and step 2.5 establishes numerability. Together with step 1.1, all AC-dependent supplier hypotheses are met, proving the statement.
Remarks
The statement assumes full AC, but the proof uses only its countable-choice consequence: step 1.1 derives . It is spent in the cited embedding, tube, collar, Lindelöf-to-paracompact, and smooth partition suppliers. Hatcher's open-cover-to-nerve argument needs a subordinate partition, supplied here by [F6]. The Euclidean cover consists of all eligible balls, the contraction of each nonempty convex intersection is pointwise, and the collar displacement uses the displayed fixed cutoff; none requires an uncountable selection.
First Chern form agrees with the topological line class
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Choice. Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly with boundary or empty, and let be a smooth complex line bundle with a supplied Hermitian metric and Hermitian connection . Write for its curvature and for the published integral line class, using the complex orientation on the underlying real plane. Let be induced by . Under the natural de Rham isomorphism , For a disconnected base the same line-class convention is understood on each component; the global class is the Euler class displayed above.
If is any complex connection on , not necessarily metric compatible, then where is induced by including real-valued forms into complex-valued forms. Thus the arbitrary-connection class is identified with the same real class by the degree-one transgression.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: Full AC, the stated manifold and line bundle, and a supplied Hermitian metric and Hermitian connection for the first assertion.
Full AC is the choice-function principle of The Axiom of Choice. It supplies compatible-connection existence [F2], manifold numerability [F3], the Thom/Euler and projective Chern-class inputs [F5, F6, F10], and the field UCT [F7]. It implies the hypotheses of the de Rham comparison [F4], smooth partitions [F9], and smooth-chain homology comparison [F16].
The total Chern form is ; its degree-two term for a line is , and Hermitian connections give real-valued Chern forms (Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler characteristic forms).
Chern–Weil classes are natural under smooth pullback and independent of the supplied compatible connection; full AC is needed for the connection existence clause (Connection independence and naturality of Chern–Weil classes).
A manifold in this statement is paracompact Hausdorff, has CW homotopy type, and its smooth bundles are numerable (Smooth manifolds have CW homotopy type).
Under , the natural de Rham isomorphism is natural for smooth maps (The de Rham theorem).
The Thom-defined Euler class is natural under orientation-preserving pullback, and the published first Chern class of a complex line is the Euler class of its complex-oriented real plane (Naturality, orientation sign, and Whitney product for Euler classes, Chern classes from the projective-bundle relation).
For , has one Schubert cell in each dimension ; the standard is its two-skeleton when . For , cellular homology and the field-coefficient UCT therefore give , , and restriction is an isomorphism. For , is a point, so , , and all vanish. The integral tautological Euler class is natural under projective inclusions (Schubert cells in real and complex Grassmannians, Schubert cells give the stable Grassmannian CW structure, Cellular homology computes singular homology).
For a free chain complex over a PID the UCT evaluation map fits into . Over the field the Ext term vanishes, so evaluation is an isomorphism (The universal coefficient theorem for cohomology over a PID).
Stokes holds on compact oriented manifolds with boundary with the outward-normal-first convention (The general Stokes theorem).
Under , every open cover of a smooth manifold, including one with boundary, has a smooth subordinate partition of unity (Smooth partitions of unity exist on manifolds, Smooth partitions of unity exist on manifolds with boundary).
The Euler class is the zero-section pullback of the Thom class, whose restriction to each oriented fiber disk is the positive generator. Excision identifies the local class at an isolated zero with the fiber class, and the Kronecker pairing evaluates it against the local fundamental class (Euler class by zero-section pullback of the Thom class, Thom class by fiberwise normalization, Excision for singular cohomology, Homotopic maps induce equal maps in singular cohomology, Kronecker evaluation pairing).
A smooth vector bundle has local smooth trivializations, and a complex bundle has local complex frames (Smooth vector bundles, rank, fibres, and trivial bundles, Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections).
Smooth singular chains are finite real linear combinations of smooth singular simplices. Their standard domains are compact, and continuous images of compact sets are compact (Smooth singular chain and cochain complexes, Smooth singular simplex, The standard topological simplex and its affine face maps, Heine-Borel in : with the Euclidean metric a subset of is compact if and only if it is closed and bounded, and the proof by bisection uses no choice principle; the same holds on the real line, A continuous image of a compact space is compact; a continuous real-valued map on a nonempty compact space attains a maximum and a minimum; and a continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space is a homeomorphism).
Ordinary singular homology uses finite formal chains, and the singular cochain complex is their Hom; integer-to-real coefficient inclusion is postcomposition and commutes with the differential (The singular chain complex and singular homology, Singular cochain complex with coefficients).
For a compactly supported top form, a finite family of orientation-preserving parametrizations whose open images are disjoint and whose closures cover the support computes its integral by summing the parameter-domain integrals (Computing form integrals by finite parametrizations).
The degree-one Chern–Simons transgression for two complex line connections is the differential of the normalized connection difference (Explicit Chern–Simons transgression between two connections).
Inclusion of smooth real singular chains into continuous real singular chains induces a natural homology isomorphism under (Smooth singular chains compute singular homology).
A compact oriented manifold's fundamental class is determined by its local orientation restrictions (Fundamental class of a compact oriented manifold).
The de Rham integration cochain evaluates a form on a smooth simplex by integrating its pullback over the standard simplex (De Rham integration cochain, Integral of a form over a smooth singular simplex, Smooth singular chain and cochain complexes).
Complex de Rham cohomology is the cohomology of the complexification of the real form complex, and real cohomology is closed forms modulo exact forms. The inclusion of real forms into complex forms induces an injective cohomology map, since the real part of a complex primitive of a real form is a real primitive (Chern–Weil map for a chosen connection, De rham cohomology).
Proof
Let be tautological and choose a Hermitian connection on it using the compatible-connection supplier. [F2, A1] First take , with affine coordinates and . The standard frames and satisfy on the overlap. If and , the connection Leibniz rule gives In their displayed charts, the closed unit disks cover and induce opposite orientations on their common boundary. The equator parametrization preserves orientation. The coordinate maps from the open unit disks in and preserve orientation, have disjoint images, and their closed images cover , so [F14] gives the integral as the sum of the two disk integrals. Using , , and [F8], Thus the degree-two Chern form has period . This calculation is for any chosen connection; in particular it applies to the Hermitian connection above.
The de Rham evaluation on the fundamental class is determined by integration [A1, F4, F18]. Identify with the unit sphere with its complex orientation. Take a tetrahedron containing the origin in its interior and radially project its oriented boundary to the sphere, orienting the faces by the boundary orientation. The four face maps form a smooth singular cycle: each face map extends smoothly near its standard simplex because its affine plane misses the origin, and the shared edge chains cancel. The radial map carries the oriented tetrahedral triangulation to the sphere, so the resulting cycle has the local orientation restrictions of the fundamental class by [F17]. By [F16], it also represents the corresponding class in smooth singular homology. Each face interior maps orientation-preservingly and diffeomorphically onto one of four disjoint spherical triangles; their closures cover the sphere. Thus the finite-parametrization formula in [F14] identifies the sum of the face integrals with . The restriction from continuous to smooth cohomology sends to the class of the integration cochain [F18], so evaluation on this smooth cycle is exactly the integral just computed, namely . The independent Thom-class calculation is local. On the tautological line , orthogonally project the fixed vector onto each complex line. This gives a smooth section with its only zero at . In the chart centered at , use the frame ; the section has fiber coordinate . Its derivative at zero is complex conjugation, with real determinant . Homotopy through scalar multiples of the section identifies its absolute Thom pullback with the zero-section Euler class. In a small disk about , excision and fiberwise Thom normalization [F10] identify the relative pullback with the local orientation class multiplied by that determinant sign. The fundamental class restricts to the positive local orientation by [F17]. Hence . Its coefficient image has the same real evaluation by [F13]. Evaluation is an isomorphism in degree two by [F7] and [F6], so the two real singular classes agree on .
The Schubert cell structure and field UCT control the degree-two comparison [A1, F6, F7]. For , the Schubert cell structure in [F6] has one cell in each even dimension and none in odd dimensions. Its cellular chain complex over therefore has , , and zero boundary into or out of degree two. The inclusion includes the unique two-cell, so it induces an isomorphism on . Cellular homology and [F7] make restriction on an isomorphism. By naturality of and of the Euler class, step 1.2 then gives For , both degree-two groups vanish, so the same equality holds. The sign here comes from the computed periods, not merely from the fact that the tautological class is a generator.
Every real homology class has a smooth cycle representative by [A1, F16]. Fix a smooth real singular two-cycle in . [F16] Let be the union of the images of its finitely many singular simplices. Each standard simplex is compact, so [F12] makes compact. If , then and this cycle pairs to zero; henceforth assume . By [F3], is numerable, so its Thom-defined Euler class lies in the stated scope. Let the index set consist of all local nonvanishing smooth sections of , with domain ; the domains cover by [F11]. Use [F9] to take a smooth partition subordinate to this indexed cover. The open sets cover . Compactness gives finitely many indices whose cover , so . Define on and zero outside. This extension is smooth because . On the open neighborhood of , at least one is nonzero at every point.
The local complex bundle frames give the fiberwise evaluation map [F11]. The evaluation map is smooth and complex-linear on each fiber. Since some is nonzero for every , its fiber map is injective. Its image is a smooth line subbundle: on the open set where the th coordinate is nonzero, the projective coordinate ratios are smooth. Hence it defines a smooth map and an isomorphism . The isomorphism is complex-linear and therefore preserves the complex orientation. This construction uses a finite subcover of ; no global finite-dimensional classifying map on is asserted.
Euler naturality applies to the orientation-preserving line-bundle isomorphism. [F5] By [F5] and the orientation-preserving isomorphism of step 1.5, Choose a Hermitian connection on over , and transport its pullback to . It may use a different Hermitian metric from the supplied one on , but both are complex-linear connections on the same complex line bundle; their Hermitian metrics need not agree. By [F2], their first Chern forms have the same complex de Rham class, and naturality identifies the pulled-back form class with . By step 1.3 this is the complexification of under the de Rham comparison. The inclusion is injective on cohomology: a complex primitive of a real exact form has a real part that is a real primitive by [F19]. Therefore the two real classes agree on . Naturality of gives
The UCT evaluation map detects the difference class. [F7] Put If , its evaluation is zero. Otherwise step 1.4 gives a neighborhood containing its image, and step 1.6 makes . Naturality in [F4] then makes the UCT evaluation of on zero. Every class of is represented by a smooth cycle by [F16, A1], so evaluates to zero on all of . Since is a field, [F7] makes the evaluation map an isomorphism, hence . This proves the Hermitian assertion globally, including disconnected ; the argument only fixes one cycle at a time.
The degree-one transgression applies to any two complex line connections. [F15] Let be any complex connection and set . The degree-one case of [F15], for , gives Thus their complex de Rham classes differ by the displayed exact form. Step 1.7 identifies the real class of , and [F19] shows that including real forms into complex forms carries it to the stated complex class. This proves the second assertion and fixes the transgression endpoints in the order to . If , its singular and de Rham groups are zero by [F13, F19]. A zero curvature form is included in the same transgression equation; the zero cycle was handled in step 1.4. The statement is for a line bundle, and in step 1.5 gives the trivial target , covered by step 1.3. Degenerate singular simplices remain among the finite chains and have compact standard domains by [F12]. Boundary points use the half-space conventions in [F2, F4, F9, F16]. Full AC is used exactly through the compatible-connection, manifold numerability, Thom/Euler, projective Chern and UCT suppliers; its consequence is used by the partition, smooth-chain and de Rham comparison suppliers. The local cycle argument uses only a finite subcover of , with no global classifying map. There is no if-and-only-if assertion. [A1, F1, F2, F3, F4, F5, F6, F7, F9, F10, F12, F13, F15, F16, F19, cases, step 1.4, step 1.5, step 1.7]
Source notes
Haller, The Atiyah–Singer Index Theorem, §II.4.5, Example II.4.5, gives the two tautological frames, their connection-form difference, and the Stokes calculation . Its passage asserts the Chern–Weil class and period for the tautological line; the proof above separately identifies the integral Euler-class sign using the local Thom-class computation in step 1.2. The finite projective factorization and the passage from compact cycles to the arbitrary possibly noncompact base are proved here; neither is inferred from Haller's compact model calculation.
Oriented real two-plane splitting with real-cohomology injection
Statement
Assume AC. Let be an oriented smooth Euclidean vector bundle of rank over a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold , possibly with boundary or empty. There is a smooth proper flag-bundle projection (proper means inverse images of compact sets are compact) such that is injective and is an ordered orthogonal sum of oriented real two-plane bundles, with one oriented trivial line appended when is odd. The cases are included.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, , and the oriented Euclidean bundle . Write for singular cohomology with real coefficients.
AC supplies a choice function for every family of nonempty sets. Its restriction to countable families gives AC (The Axiom of Choice, The Axiom of Countable Choice ()). We use AC for the tubular-neighbourhood, bundle-metric, smooth-partition and countable-cover suppliers; full AC is also inherited by the CW-type, characteristic-class, Leray–Hirsch and UCT suppliers. At the end, full AC is used once more to identify cohomology of a disjoint union with the product of its component cohomologies.
A smooth bundle has local smooth linear frames; a supplied smooth bundle metric makes orthogonal complements smooth subbundles, and the supplied orientation can be represented by positive frames (Smooth vector bundles, rank, fibres, and trivial bundles, Smooth bundle metrics, Oriented real bundles and oriented frame bundles).
The oriented Grassmannian is the quotient of the orthonormal two-frame space by ; it has the tautological oriented plane bundle. The ordinary Grassmannian has graph charts, and these charts lift to its two orientation sheets (Stiefel spaces, Grassmannians, and tautological bundles, Oriented Grassmannians and the tautological oriented bundle, The quotient topology of a surjection, quotient maps, saturated sets, and the quotient of a space by an equivalence relation with its canonical projection).
Smooth manifolds with or without boundary have the indicated Euclidean or half-space charts. Under AC, their open covers admit smooth partitions of unity; a locally trivial fiber bundle is numerable when such a subordinate partition is supplied. Under AC, second-countable spaces are Lindelöf and a countable union of countable sets is countable (Assuming countable choice, every second countable space is Lindelöf, Countable unions of at most countable sets, assuming , Smooth manifolds and their smooth charts, Locally trivial fiber bundle, Smooth partitions of unity exist on manifolds, Smooth partitions of unity exist on manifolds with boundary).
Under AC every finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, with boundary or empty, is paracompact Hausdorff, CGWH, and of CW homotopy type, and every smooth finite-rank vector bundle on it is numerable (Smooth manifolds have CW homotopy type). A CW complex is a Hausdorff space with closure-finite cells and weak topology (CW complex with closure finiteness and weak topology). Every CW complex is paracompact and Hausdorff (Hatcher, Vector Bundles & K-Theory, Appendix to §1.2, Proposition 1.20, printed pp. 36–37; its inductive partition-of-unity proof is the paracompactness input below).
For a rank- oriented Euclidean bundle, the oriented two-plane Grassmann bundle is locally the product with , and its tautological plane plus oriented orthogonal complement is the pullback of the original bundle. A smooth map's local coordinate expressions are smooth in boundary charts ([F1], [F2], Smooth charts, atlases, and structures with boundary, Smooth functions on relatively open half-space sets, Smooth maps between manifolds with boundary, Chain rule for smooth half-space maps).
The cohomology ring of is for the Euler class of its complex tautological line; its integral homology is in even degrees and zero otherwise. The Schubert CW structure has one cell in each even dimension and none in odd dimensions, so its cellular boundaries vanish. The integral homology of is in degree zero, in odd degrees strictly below the top, and an additional in top degree exactly when is odd; all other groups vanish (Integral cohomology ring of complex projective space, Schubert cells in real and complex Grassmannians, Schubert cells give the stable Grassmannian CW structure, Cellular homology computes singular homology, Real projective space cellular homology and the pinch map).
The standard inclusion is a smooth embedding: in affine projective charts it is the inclusion of real coordinates into complex coordinates. Both projective spaces are compact, and the ambient one is Hausdorff, so the image is closed. Explicitly, the unit real and complex spheres surject onto the respective projective spaces; their quotient topologies make these spaces compact by [F13]. The map identifies with a subset of the Hausdorff space of Hermitian matrices: it is continuous and injective, and compact-to-Hausdorff implies it is a homeomorphism onto its image. The affine charts have transition maps given by ratios of coordinates, and the real chart is the zero set of the imaginary coordinate functions in the complex chart. This proves the stated smooth embedded inclusion directly (The quotient topology of a surjection, quotient maps, saturated sets, and the quotient of a space by an equivalence relation with its canonical projection, A continuous image of a compact space is compact; a continuous real-valued map on a nonempty compact space attains a maximum and a minimum; and a continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space is a homeomorphism, In a Hausdorff space a point and a disjoint compact set, and two disjoint compact sets, have disjoint open neighbourhoods; hence every compact subset is closed, and in a compact Hausdorff space the compact subsets are exactly the closed ones). A closed embedded submanifold has a tubular neighborhood that deformation retracts onto it (The tubular neighbourhood theorem in a smooth ambient manifold). Compactly supported cohomology is the filtered colimit of relative cohomology groups over compact supports ; excision, the pair long exact sequence and the five lemma apply naturally to singular cohomology (Compactly supported singular cohomology, Excision for singular cohomology, Long exact sequence of a pair in singular cohomology, The Five Lemma for modules).
On an oriented boundaryless -manifold, cap product gives natural Poincaré duality ; on a CW complex, the UCT sequence is natural, and homotopic maps induce equal singular cohomology maps (Poincaré duality for oriented topological manifolds, The universal coefficient theorem for cohomology over a PID, Homotopic maps induce equal maps in singular cohomology).
Euler classes are natural for oriented pullbacks and multiply over ordered oriented sums. A positive-rank bundle with a nowhere-zero section has zero Euler class (Euler class by zero-section pullback of the Thom class, Naturality, orientation sign, and Whitney product for Euler classes, A nowhere-zero section forces the Euler class to vanish). Singular cohomology pullback preserves cup products and the unit (Singular cohomology ring, Cup product is natural, unital and associative).
For an oriented rank- bundle on a path-connected CW base, its top Pontryagin class equals the square of its Euler class. Over a coefficient ring where is invertible, total Pontryagin classes multiply under ordered Whitney sums, and adding a trivial bundle leaves them unchanged (Pontryagin classes by complexification, Top Pontryagin class is the square of the Euler class, Pontryagin Whitney product away from two, Naturality, stability, and mod-two reduction of Pontryagin classes). These characteristic classes are first defined integrally, then mapped through the coefficient-ring map; step 1.6 uses their images in real cohomology.
A numerable fiber bundle is a Hurewicz fibration; a Hurewicz fibration has the disk homotopy lifting property of a Serre fibration. Serre fibrations have natural long exact homotopy sequences. Weak homotopy equivalences induce integral homology isomorphisms; the natural UCT sequence and the module five lemma then compare singular cohomology with real coefficients (Numerable fiber bundles are hurewicz fibrations, Hurewicz and serre fibrations, Long exact sequence of homotopy groups of a fibration, Fibration sequence is natural, Weak homotopy equivalences induce integral homology isomorphisms without choice, The Five Lemma for modules). Singular chains are free on singular simplices, cochains are their Hom complexes, and continuous maps induce contravariantly functorial cohomology maps (The singular chain complex and singular homology, Singular cochain complex with coefficients, Singular cohomology with coefficients, Singular cohomology is contravariantly functorial).
Leray–Hirsch applies to a Serre fibration over a path-connected CW complex when finitely many total-space classes restrict to a homogeneous cohomology basis on every fiber. Its module isomorphism sends the unit basis class to pullback on the base (Leray–Hirsch module isomorphism).
A finite-dimensional Euclidean Stiefel space is compact by Heine–Borel; continuous images of compact spaces are compact; closed subsets of compact spaces and finite products of compact spaces are compact; compact subsets of a Hausdorff space are closed (Heine-Borel in : with the Euclidean metric a subset of is compact if and only if it is closed and bounded, and the proof by bisection uses no choice principle; the same holds on the real line, A continuous image of a compact space is compact; a continuous real-valued map on a nonempty compact space attains a maximum and a minimum; and a continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space is a homeomorphism, A closed subspace of a compact space is compact, and a finite union of compact subspaces is compact, A product of finitely many compact spaces is compact in the product topology, In a Hausdorff space a point and a disjoint compact set, and two disjoint compact sets, have disjoint open neighbourhoods; hence every compact subset is closed, and in a compact Hausdorff space the compact subsets are exactly the closed ones).
Under AC, every smooth vector bundle admits a smooth bundle metric (Every smooth vector bundle admits a smooth bundle metric).
Proof
Proof technique: construct one oriented Grassmann tower, calculate its fiber basis, and prove injectivity at each stage.
Fix and write , with [F2, F13] tautological oriented plane and oriented orthogonal complement . The quotient definition gives a continuous bijection from the compact Stiefel quotient to the set of unit simple bivectors in ; the bivector records both the plane and its orientation. A continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space is a homeomorphism here: a closed subset of the compact source is compact, and its image is closed in the Hausdorff target by [F13]. The graph charts make a smooth manifold of dimension ; the finite coordinate-plane chart cover makes it second-countable. The group acts transitively on oriented two-planes, and is path-connected: successive plane rotations reduce any special orthogonal matrix to the identity. Hence is path-connected.
Let . Write a point as [F2] with linearly independent. The ordered pair orients its real span; multiplying by a nonzero complex scalar changes by a positive-determinant similarity, so this defines a map . Conversely, in a local oriented orthonormal frame of a plane, the point of is an invertible real matrix modulo positive similarities. Polar decomposition writes it uniquely as a positive scalar, an element of , and a positive symmetric determinant-one matrix. Thus is the associated bundle over with fiber the positive symmetric determinant-one matrices. The homotopy contracts that fiber to the identity; it is equivariant under orthogonal conjugation, so it descends through the frame changes and gives a deformation retraction . The real-part map on each complex tautological line sends and to the positively oriented basis , identifying the pulled-back oriented plane with the underlying real complex tautological line.
Put , , and . [F6, F7, F14] The quotient maps from to and from to show that both are compact. By [F7], is a closed smooth embedded submanifold. The tubular-neighborhood theorem [F7] gives a tubular diffeomorphism from an open neighborhood of the zero section of the normal bundle onto a neighborhood of . By [F14], give the normal bundle a smooth metric. Around each point of the compact zero section, a bundle chart contains a product neighborhood lying inside the tubular domain; finitely many such base patches cover , and the minimum of their positive fiber radii gives a uniform disk neighborhood. Every smaller-radius disk neighborhood deformation retracts radially to . Their images are nested tubular neighborhoods. Their complements are compact subsets of and are cofinal among compact subsets of : for compact , the open set contains the compact zero section, so compactness gives a sufficiently small uniform disk neighborhood lying in . By [F7] and excision, . The inclusion is a homotopy equivalence; the natural pair long exact sequences and five lemma identify every with . Consequently , and the map forgetting support is the relative-to-absolute map .
Apply the natural UCT to the integral homology in [F6]. For , [F6, F7] and . For both terms vanish: the Hom group is zero because has no 2-torsion, and the free resolution computes . Thus in even degrees and zero otherwise. For , it is in degree zero, and also in degree when is even; all its other positive-degree groups vanish. The pair long exact sequence now gives ; for positive even it gives except that when is even; all odd groups and groups outside vanish.
The complex orientation of restricts to an orientation of the open [F6, F8, F9] manifold . Poincaré duality and the deformation retraction in step 1.2 therefore compute : it is in degrees , zero in odd degrees, and has dimension two in degree when is even. Let be the generator from [F6], let , and let , with integral classes mapped to real coefficients as needed. By [F6] and [F8], the image of each is a nonzero generator of . For positive even except when is even, the pair sequence shows of step 1.3 is an isomorphism. PD identifies it with . By the natural UCT pairing, the dual restriction is therefore an isomorphism. Step 1.2 identifies the pullback of with ; since generates , it follows that for every except possibly when is even. In that exceptional case follows below from the nonzero square .
Suppose . The ordered sum is the trivial oriented [F9, F10] rank- bundle. By [F9], , since the trivial positive-rank bundle has a nowhere-zero section. To calculate the square, take a homotopy equivalence from a path-connected CW complex. Since is a finite-dimensional second-countable smooth manifold, [F4] makes numerable; pulling its numeration back makes numerable on . Hatcher's CW paracompactness proof, recorded in [F4], gives that is paracompact and Hausdorff, so the Pontryagin suppliers apply. Set and . Euler naturality identifies their Euler classes with pullbacks of those on . The top Pontryagin theorem gives , and the rank cutoff gives . Pontryagin multiplicativity over and stability under a trivial summand yield . Comparing successive homogeneous degrees in this equation gives for . The top Pontryagin theorem for then gives . Since is an isomorphism and Euler classes are natural, this descends to on . Step 1.5 established ; hence and are linearly independent: multiplying a relation by and using gives , while step 1.5 gives ; then , and forces . These two classes therefore form a basis of the two-dimensional middle cohomology. For odd , the nonzero powers in step 1.5 already form a basis by their distinct degrees. Thus the full fiber basis is when is odd, and when is even.
For each oriented smooth Euclidean bundle of rank , [F1, F2, F3, F5] form its oriented Grassmann bundle . Local positive orthonormal frames and the graph charts of [F2] give smooth local product charts with fiber . Transition maps act smoothly by ; their formulas remain smooth on half-space charts by [F5] when has boundary. Thus the total is a finite-dimensional smooth manifold, with boundary exactly over the boundary of . It is Hausdorff: points over different base points separate by inverse images of base neighborhoods, and points in one fiber separate in a bundle chart. It is second-countable: the trivializing cover has a countable subcover by Lindelöfness; each product chart has a countable basis, and their countable union is a basis. The pulled-back bundle splits orthogonally as , with both summands oriented as in [F2].
Each is proper. Let be compact. [F13] Around each point of , choose a relatively open coordinate ball or half-ball whose compact closure lies inside a bundle-trivializing chart. Heine–Borel makes each closure compact. Finitely many such cover . Each is a closed subset of compact , hence compact; in the trivialization, is homeomorphic to , compact by [F13]. Their finite union is , so it is compact.
Every stage projection is numerable. On its smooth base, apply the [F3, F4] boundaryless or boundary partition theorem in [F3] to its bundle-trivializing cover; the supplied partition satisfies the support and local-finiteness conditions in the definition of numerable fiber bundle. Its total is again a second-countable smooth manifold, so [F4] makes every stage paracompact Hausdorff and of CW homotopy type and makes its smooth finite-rank vector bundles numerable.
We prove real-cohomology injectivity for componentwise. [F4, F11] The fiber is path-connected. Since a smooth manifold is locally path connected, its connected components are path components; the local bundle charts and path lifting show that the total-space components are exactly the preimages of base components. Fix one such component and a path-connected CW complex with a homotopy equivalence , available by [F4]. Pull back to . The pulled-back bundle is numerable because its partition is the pullback of the partition in step 1.9. By [F11] both projections are Hurewicz, hence Serre, fibrations.
The global classes , [F9, F12] together with when is even, restrict to the full fiber basis of step 1.6 by naturality of Euler classes and cup products. Pull these classes back to ; on each fiber their restrictions are the same basis. Applying Leray–Hirsch [F12] to shows that is injective: in the module isomorphism, pullback is exactly the coefficient of the basis element .
The pullback map induces a [F11] weak homotopy equivalence. On fibers it is the identity, and on bases it is the homotopy equivalence . The natural long exact sequences [F11] give isomorphisms on all higher homotopy groups. For , the terms in the five-term segment around are abelian, so the module five lemma applies. In degree two, if maps to zero, its base class is zero because is injective; hence comes from . Its fiber class is a boundary from , which lifts through the surjection , so exactness makes . Conversely, for , its base class lifts to ; naturality and the identity fiber map make the lifted class have zero boundary in , so exactness lifts it to . The difference from lies in the image of and can be corrected there. For use the group sequence : injectivity lifts a boundary witness through , and surjectivity first lifts the base loop through and then corrects by a loop in the common fiber. Since the fiber and both bases are path-connected, the total spaces are path-connected too, so is also a bijection on components.
By [F11], induces an isomorphism on integral homology. [F8, F11] Apply the natural UCT sequence to the free singular chain complexes with coefficient group . The induced maps on the Hom and Ext terms are isomorphisms because the integral homology maps are; the five lemma therefore makes an isomorphism. Also is an isomorphism by [F8]. The square commutes by functoriality. If , then ; step 1.11 gives , hence . Thus is injective on every component. Singular cochains on a disjoint union are the product of component cochains; full AC makes the product of component coboundary preimages surjective, so cohomology is the product of component cohomologies. Therefore is injective globally.
Start with and . Whenever the current oriented complement [F1] has rank , set , pull back, and replace it by its oriented orthogonal complement . Step 1.7 keeps each stage smooth, Hausdorff and second-countable; steps 1.8–1.9 make every projection proper and numerable; step 1.13 proves every cohomology pullback injective. The rank drops by two at each stage, so the process stops after finitely many stages with rank zero, one, or two. A rank-one oriented Euclidean bundle has the unique positive unit section and is the oriented trivial line; a rank-two terminal complement is itself the final oriented two-plane. The composite is proper by finite composition of proper maps; its cohomology pullback is the composition of the stagewise injections. The tautological planes and terminal rank-two plane, or final line when rank one, give the required ordered orthogonal decomposition.
If , its tower is empty and all cohomology groups are [A1, F1, F3] zero. If , take and the empty sum. If , take the identity and the unique positive unit section. If , no Grassmann stage is needed: take the identity and the single oriented plane . These identity maps are proper and induce identity maps in cohomology. At every positive-rank stage the complement is oriented by the rule that has the pulled-back orientation, so no orientation choice is hidden. The boundary case is included by the half-space chart and partition arguments of steps 1.7–1.9; the fiber calculation uses only closed boundaryless manifolds. The item is a one-way existence statement, so neither direction of an iff is applicable. AC is used only in the supplier and component-product uses recorded in [A1]. Full AC lets us choose cocycle representatives for any family of component cohomology classes and choose coboundary preimages for any family of component boundaries; hence the canonical map from cohomology of the disjoint union to the product of component cohomologies is an isomorphism.
Source notes
Kaiwen, Talk 13: Cohomology of Projective Bundles, §4, Proposition 4.6 and Lemma 4.7 identify the oriented Grassmannian with the homotopy type of the projective complement by polar decomposition; Lemma 4.8 and Proposition 4.9 give the compact-support/relative-cohomology and Poincaré-duality route to the additive groups; Proposition 4.12 records the Euler and Pontryagin relations; Propositions 4.13 and Theorem 4.14 apply Leray–Hirsch and iterate the tower. The notes mark the polar-decomposition and cohomology arguments as sketches. They also state integral Pontryagin multiplicativity without treating the two-torsion obstruction; this proof instead uses the library's real-coefficient product theorem and supplies the missing middle-degree basis argument. The source locators above refer to printed pages 7–11 (PDF pages 6–10).
Hatcher, Vector Bundles & K-Theory, Appendix to §1.2, Proposition 1.20, printed pp. 36–37, proves that every CW complex is paracompact by extending locally finite partitions over successive skeleta. This is the precise paracompactness input for the CW model used in step 1.6.
Complex flag splitting with injective real pullback on smooth bases
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Choice (AC). Let be a smooth complex vector bundle of finite rank over a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly with boundary or empty. There is a smooth complete flag-bundle projection such that is a direct sum of smooth complex line bundles, is proper, and is injective. Here proper means that inverse images of compact subsets are compact; is given the smooth structure of the finite projective tower constructed below, whose fibers are the complete flags of . In ranks zero and one take to be the identity. The assertion is componentwise for disconnected .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the stated smooth complex bundle, and its finite rank .
AC says every family of nonempty sets has a choice function. In particular it implies countable choice by applying a choice function to the set of distinct values of a countable family and composing with the indexing map (The Axiom of Choice, The Axiom of Countable Choice ()).
Every finite-rank smooth complex vector bundle over the stated manifold admits a smooth Hermitian metric, and a supplied Hermitian metric admits a compatible complex connection (Existence of compatible connections).
A smooth complex bundle has local smooth complex frames; a smooth vector bundle has smooth local trivializations linear on fibers (Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections, Smooth vector bundles, rank, fibres, and trivial bundles).
Boundary charts have relatively open half-space images; smoothness of maps is checked in such charts, smooth functions admit local Euclidean extensions, and smooth half-space maps compose (Smooth manifolds and their smooth charts, Smooth charts, atlases, and structures with boundary, Smooth functions on relatively open half-space sets, Smooth maps between manifolds with boundary, Chain rule for smooth half-space maps).
Every finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, including one with boundary, is paracompact Hausdorff and CGWH, has CW homotopy type, and every smooth finite-rank bundle on it is numerable (Smooth manifolds have CW homotopy type).
Under AC, every second-countable space is Lindelöf, and a countable union of countable sets is countable (Assuming countable choice, every second countable space is Lindelöf, Countable unions of at most countable sets, assuming ).
Over a paracompact Hausdorff CGWH base of CW homotopy type, the complex projectivization, tautological line, and its complex-oriented integral Euler class use the same quotient and local chart formulas as over a CW base (Integral complex projective bundle theorem). The projective fiber is compact Hausdorff and has one cell in each dimension (Complex projective bundle and tautological complex line).
On , the powers of the tautological real Euler class form an integral cohomology basis for (The complex tautological Euler class restricts to the projective-fiber generator). Euler classes commute with orientation-preserving pullback (Naturality, orientation sign, and Whitney product for Euler classes).
Cellular homology computes singular homology for CW complexes (Cellular homology computes singular homology). The cohomological universal-coefficient sequence for a free integral chain complex is natural and has the form (The universal coefficient theorem for cohomology over a PID).
Singular cochains are Hom groups with coboundary given by precomposition with the boundary, cohomology is cocycles modulo coboundaries, and the cup product is induced by the front/back face formula (Singular cochain complex with coefficients, Singular cohomology with coefficients, Singular cohomology ring). Pullbacks compose and coefficient homomorphisms commute with pullbacks (Singular cohomology is contravariantly functorial).
Homotopic maps induce equal singular-cohomology maps (Homotopic maps induce equal maps in singular cohomology).
If a Serre fibration over a path-connected CW complex has finitely many homogeneous cohomology classes restricting to a basis on each fiber, the Leray–Hirsch cup-product map is an isomorphism over any commutative unital coefficient ring (Leray–Hirsch module isomorphism). A numerable fiber bundle with its support-subordinate partition is a Hurewicz, hence Serre, fibration under AC (Numerable fiber bundles are hurewicz fibrations). Numerability means that the local product charts carry a locally finite partition whose supports lie in their chart domains (Real and complex topological vector bundles, Locally trivial fiber bundle).
Closed bounded subsets of Euclidean space are compact; continuous images of compact spaces are compact; closed subsets of compact spaces are compact; finite products and finite unions of compact spaces are compact; compact subsets of Hausdorff spaces are closed (Heine-Borel in : with the Euclidean metric a subset of is compact if and only if it is closed and bounded, and the proof by bisection uses no choice principle; the same holds on the real line, A continuous image of a compact space is compact; a continuous real-valued map on a nonempty compact space attains a maximum and a minimum; and a continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space is a homeomorphism, A closed subspace of a compact space is compact, and a finite union of compact subspaces is compact, A product of finitely many compact spaces is compact in the product topology, In a Hausdorff space a point and a disjoint compact set, and two disjoint compact sets, have disjoint open neighbourhoods; hence every compact subset is closed, and in a compact Hausdorff space the compact subsets are exactly the closed ones).
Proof
Assume AC as in [A1]. It discharges the full-AC hypotheses of [F1], [F4], [F6]–[F8], and [F11], and implies AC for [F5]. In the disconnected cohomology argument below, AC is also used to choose componentwise cocycle representatives and primitives.
Let be any smooth complex bundle of rank over a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold with boundary allowed. By [F4], is paracompact Hausdorff CGWH of CW type and is numerable, so [F6] supplies the topological projective bundle and its tautological line. Locally, projectivizing a smooth frame chart gives ; on overlaps a smooth matrix map acts by . In affine projective charts , coordinates are ; the overlap formulas are ratios of smooth functions with nonzero denominators, so they extend smoothly in the local Euclidean extensions of [F3], including at boundary points. Their inverse formulas have the same property. Thus these charts make a smooth manifold with boundary of dimension , and is smooth. It is Hausdorff: different base points separate in , and points over one base point separate in a local product because is Hausdorff. It is second-countable: [F5] gives a countable subcover of the frame charts, and the products of their restricted countable base with the finite affine-chart countable base of projective space form a countable base after a countable union. Its tautological line is smooth by the local representative and the same smooth transition formulas.
Consider one stage with rank and first suppose is connected. Manifold charts are locally path-connected, so is path-connected. Its projective bundle is numerable: the numeration of from [F4] projectivizes using the same cover and partition, as required by [F11]. The CW-type extension [F6] supplies . For each , pullback to the fiber identifies with the tautological Euler class by [F7]; [F7] says its powers form the integral basis of . Write for the image of under the coefficient map. The homomorphism is postcomposition on cochains by [F9]. Since coefficient inclusion is multiplicative and the cup product uses the front/back formula, it sends to .
Each stage is proper. In a smooth chart contained in a projective trivializing domain, shrink a relatively open ball or half-ball so its closed coordinate ball lies in the chart domain; let be the image of that closed ball, intersected with the closed half-space in a boundary chart. In dimension zero use the single-point chart and . The coordinate set is closed and bounded in Euclidean space, so Heine–Borel [F12] makes compact; since is Hausdorff, [F12] makes closed. The family of all such pairs covers . Given compact , choose a finite subcover of . Each is closed in the compact space , hence compact by [F12], and the cover . In the product chart, , which is compact by [F6] and [F12]. Their finite union is and is compact by [F12]. Thus is proper.
By [F1] choose a Hermitian metric on . Put and . If has rank , use step 1.2 to form and its smooth tautological line . Pull back the Hermitian metric and let . In a local nonvanishing frame of , the orthogonal projection is ; it is a smooth complex-linear idempotent of rank one. The images of on vectors forming a basis of its kernel at one point remain independent nearby, so is a smooth complex bundle of rank . Fiberwise orthogonality gives the smooth bundle isomorphism . Repeating this finite construction until rank one gives and the decomposition . The tower fiber is the space of ordered orthogonal line splittings; the maps and identify it smoothly with the complete flag manifold.
The cell dimensions in [F6] imply that the cellular chain groups of are in degrees and zero in odd degrees; all cellular differentials are zero. By [F8], its integral homology is consequently in those even degrees and zero in odd degrees. The universal-coefficient sequence [F8] has zero Ext terms because these homology groups are free, so evaluation identifies with . The restricted powers from step 1.3 are integral generators; naturality of this sequence sends each such generator to or in that copy of . Hence restrict to an -basis on every fiber. This is the coefficient step needed here; no real-coefficient conclusion is assumed from the integral projective bundle theorem.
Choose a homotopy equivalence from a connected CW complex, as provided by [F4]. The pullback is a projective bundle; pulling back the numeration of makes it numerable, and [F11] makes it a Serre fibration. The pulled-back classes still restrict to the fiber basis of step 2.2. Apply Leray–Hirsch [F11] with coefficient ring : its module isomorphism has the summand for the basis element equal to , so is injective. If for , pullback functoriality [F9] gives . Thus ; since is a homotopy equivalence, [F10] implies that is an isomorphism, and . This proves injectivity for a connected base.
A manifold chart can be shrunk to a path-connected open ball or half-ball, so its connected components are open and path-connected. For a disconnected manifold, the projective total space decomposes into the open-and-closed preimages of those components. Every singular simplex has connected image and therefore lies in one such piece. Thus each singular chain complex is the direct sum of the component chain complexes, and its cochain complex is their product. Kernels are componentwise; AC in [A1] chooses a cocycle representative for each component class and a primitive for each component coboundary, so the cohomology is the product of the component cohomologies. The pullback is the product of the connected-stage maps from step 3.1, hence injective. The same argument includes the empty base, whose cohomology groups are zero.
The composition of proper maps is proper: the inverse image of a compact set under the last stage is compact, and taking its inverse image under each preceding proper stage preserves compactness. The same finite composition of smooth stage projections is smooth by [F3]. Each stage pullback on real cohomology is injective by steps 3.1–4.1, so their composite is injective. If , the flag space is , the pulled-back bundle is the empty direct sum, and ; if , , , and the sole summand is . Identity maps are proper and induce identity cohomology maps. For the tower and all cohomology groups are empty or zero as stated. Boundary charts were retained in step 1.2, so the construction and properness proof include boundary points.
∎
Source notes
Hatcher, Vector Bundles & K-Theory, §3.1, Proposition 3.3, printed pp. 80–81, constructs the real splitting tower by projectivizing and splitting off a tautological line, applies Leray–Hirsch for injectivity, and then adapts the argument to complex bundles with integral cohomology. The present proof supplies the smooth half-space charts, properness, and the coefficient bridge from integral fiber generators to the real-coefficient basis required here.
Characteristic forms represent topological characteristic classes over the reals
Statement
Assume full Axiom of Choice. Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly with boundary or empty, and let be induced by . Write for the natural de Rham isomorphism from real de Rham cohomology to singular cohomology with real coefficients.
For every finite-rank smooth complex bundle with a Hermitian metric and Hermitian connection , and every , For every finite-rank smooth real bundle with any real connection , and every , For every oriented Euclidean bundle of even rank with a metric-compatible connection , and its Thom-normalized Euler class, Here , , and use the normalizations in Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler characteristic forms, while , , and are the published topological classes. In particular for a complex line and . These are equalities after passage to real coefficients; no equality with integral torsion is asserted.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: Full AC, the stated smooth bundles and connections, and the supplied metric and orientation wherever the Hermitian or Euler clause requires them.
Full AC is the choice-function principle: every family of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Choice).
The Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler forms are the determinant coefficients and Pfaffian curvature evaluations with the stated rank-zero and degree conventions; Hermitian Chern forms and all Pontryagin forms are real (Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler characteristic forms).
For a fixed invariant polynomial, Chern–Weil classes are natural under pullback and independent of the compatible connection on the same supplied -reduction (Connection independence and naturality of Chern–Weil classes).
A complex bundle on pulls back to an orthogonal sum of complex lines along a smooth flag projection whose pullback on real cohomology is injective (Complex flag splitting with injective real pullback on smooth bases).
An oriented Euclidean bundle on pulls back to an ordered orthogonal sum of oriented real two-plane bundles (and, in odd rank, one trivial line) along a smooth flag projection inducing an injection on real cohomology (Oriented real two-plane splitting with real-cohomology injection).
Such smooth manifolds, including the smooth flag spaces, have CW homotopy type, and their smooth finite-rank bundles are numerable (Smooth manifolds have CW homotopy type).
The natural de Rham map is a ring isomorphism, compatible with smooth pullback, also when has boundary (The de Rham theorem).
Topological Chern classes are natural, satisfy the Whitney sum formula, and obey the rank conventions on CW-type bases (Naturality, normalization, and Whitney sum for Chern classes).
The projective-relation definition fixes and the published integral Chern classes on CW-type bases (Chern classes from the projective-bundle relation).
The published Pontryagin classes are defined by , with and the rank cutoff (Pontryagin classes by complexification).
Thom-normalized Euler classes are natural under oriented pullback and satisfy the Whitney product formula for the ordered-sum orientation (Naturality, orientation sign, and Whitney product for Euler classes).
The Euler class is the pullback of the normalized Thom class along the zero section (Euler class by zero-section pullback of the Thom class).
Under full AC, each smooth real bundle admits a Euclidean metric and a compatible connection, and each supplied compatible metric admits a compatible connection (Existence of compatible connections).
The connection definitions give complex-linear connections, Hermitian connections, Euclidean-compatible connections, and their local connection matrices (Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections).
For a Hermitian connection on a complex line, the real de Rham class of its normalized first Chern form maps to the real coefficient image of c1(L)=e(L_R) (First Chern form agrees with the topological line class).
Proof
Proof technique: Pull back to the supplied smooth flag towers, compute on line and oriented two-plane summands, and descend by the proven cohomology injections.
Prove componentwise: every component is open in a manifold chart and inherits the stated smooth scope; its singular cochains are the product across components, and full AC supplies componentwise cocycles and primitives, so equality on components is equality on ; the same componentwise reasoning applies to each smooth flag space below. By [F5], the topological classes in [F7]–[F11] are defined, and [F6] gives the real de Rham ring isomorphism. If , all singular and de Rham groups are zero, so the assertions hold there as well.
For a complex bundle of rank with Hermitian connection , take on each component the complex flag projection from [F3]; it has injective real-cohomology pullback and orthogonally. The flag space is in the smooth scope of [F5], ranks use the identity map, and is Hermitian.
Let be a real rank- bundle with arbitrary real connection . For a real matrix , is a real -invariant polynomial. Writing , the complexified-curvature formula [F1] gives , hence as actual real forms . Chern–Weil connection independence [F2] for the real general-linear reduction compares all real connections in real de Rham cohomology.
On one oriented two-plane summand, take a positive orthonormal frame with , where is its orientation complex structure. Metric compatibility gives and , so the curvature matrix is and the library Pfaffian convention [F1] gives . The associated complex line with induced Hermitian metric has connection form , curvature , and first Chern form . By [F14] and [F8], its real class is the coefficient image of the Thom-normalized Euler class of the plane.
Let be the smooth orthogonal projection onto and set for sections of . Since , the projected operator obeys the connection Leibniz rule; since for , the Hermitian metric identity for restricts to the same identity after projection. Thus is Hermitian on the same complex bundle as . By [F2], connection independence and naturality identify the de Rham classes of and with those of and , respectively.
The curvature of is block diagonal, so [F1] gives . For each line, [F8] and [F14] give ; multiplicativity of [F6] and the topological Whitney formula [F7] then give for every . Naturality in [F2] and [F6] makes the pullback of zero. Injectivity in [F3] proves the complex assertion.
Let be an oriented Euclidean bundle of rank with metric-compatible connection . The real flag projection [F4] gives with injective pullback and an ordered orthogonal splitting into oriented two-planes. Pull back and project orthogonally to each summand; the Euclidean metric identity restricts under orthogonal projection by , so the projected connections and their direct sum are metric-compatible on the same oriented Euclidean bundle as . This is the same projection calculation as in step 2.1. By [F2], the Pfaffian classes of these two connections agree.
By [A1] and [F12], choose a Euclidean metric on and a compatible connection ; its complexification is Hermitian for the induced metric. The complex result in step 3.1 identifies with . Multiplying by and using [F9] and step 1.3 proves the Pontryagin equality for , while step 1.3 permits replacing by in the Pontryagin de Rham class. If , both sides vanish by [F1] and [F9]; if , both are the unit.
The Pfaffian of the block-diagonal curvature in step 3.2 is the product of the rank-two Pfaffians. Step 1.4, the ring isomorphism [F6], and the Euler Whitney product [F10] give . Naturality of the Euler class [F10] and characteristic form [F2] identifies this with the pullback of the difference on ; injectivity in [F4] proves the Euler assertion.
The degree-zero classes in the total forms are units; rank-zero Chern and Pontryagin bundles have no positive-degree coefficients, and a rank-zero oriented Euclidean bundle has Euler form and class equal to the unit by [F1] and [F11]. A complex line is covered by steps 1.2, 2.1, and 3.1; the rank-two Euler sign by step 1.4; and the rank cutoffs for by [F1], [F9], and step 4.1. Boundary points are covered by the half-space flag, connection, pullback, and de Rham suppliers [F2]–[F6]. There is no odd-rank Euler-form clause or if-and-only-if assertion. Full AC is used in step 1.1 for componentwise cohomology, through the flag and characteristic-class/Thom/Euler suppliers [F3]–[F5], [F7]–[F11], and in step 4.1 for compatible-connection existence; the curvature algebra and supplied-connection comparisons are choice-free.
Source notes
Haller, The Atiyah–Singer Index Theorem, §II.4.1, Proposition II.4.1(b)–(c), printed pp. 88–89, proves connection independence and pullback naturality for trace power series; §II.4.5, Example II.4.5, printed pp. 91–92, uses the normalization and gives the total determinant Chern form. This is corroboration for those formulas, not a source for arbitrary invariant polynomials or the real and oriented Euler branches; [F2] supplies the broader connection theorem used here.
Milnor–Stasheff, Characteristic Classes, Appendix C, printed pp. 193–196, derives the split-sum Chern calculation, Pontryagin coefficient formula, and Pfaffian Euler theorem. Its printed p. 192 warns that readers using classical sign conventions should replace by . The rank-two calculation in step 1.4 independently fixes the Pfaffian sign for this library's stated curvature and orientation conventions; no sign is imported from that source.
Direct-sum and pullback formulas for characteristic forms
Statement
Assume full Axiom of Choice. Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly empty or with boundary, and let all bundles below have finite rank. Use the characteristic-form conventions of Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler characteristic forms, including and the rank-zero unit forms.
- For complex bundles with complex connections , give the direct-sum connection. Then
- For oriented Euclidean bundles of even ranks with metric connections, give the product metric, the direct-sum connection, and the orientation ordered as then . Then
- For real Euclidean bundles with metric connections, This is an equality of forms.
- If is smooth, pullback of any Chern, Pontryagin, or defined Euler characteristic form agrees exactly with the corresponding form of the pulled-back bundle and connection.
- For arbitrary real connections on real bundles and any real connection on , the associated total Pontryagin forms need not obey the direct-sum identity pointwise, but their real de Rham classes satisfy The real characteristic-class comparison theorem identifies these classes with the real coefficient images of the topological Pontryagin classes. No integral Whitney product formula is asserted here.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The stated bundles, connections, metrics and orientations; for the pullback assertion, a smooth map between manifolds in the stated scope.
Full AC is assumed: every family of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Choice).
The total Chern form is the determinant of the normalized curvature; the Pontryagin forms are its signed even coefficients on the complexified real connection. They are closed, real-valued, and have rank-zero value . Odd Chern forms of a metric real connection vanish pointwise, and under full AC odd Chern forms of any real connection are exact (Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler characteristic forms).
A Whitney sum has block-diagonal transition matrices, with the fiberwise sum convention (Whitney sum, tensor, dual, Hom, and exterior-power bundles).
In a local frame, curvature is (Curvature two-form structure equation).
Evaluating an invariant polynomial on curvature is multilinear in the even-degree form entries (Evaluation of an invariant polynomial on curvature).
The pullback connection has local matrix in the pulled-back frame (Pullback connection).
If frames satisfy , their connection matrices obey (Connection one form transformation law); local matrices obeying this rule glue to a unique connection (Local connection forms glue exactly when they obey the transformation law).
On manifolds with boundary, pullback preserves wedges and commutes with the exterior derivative, using local smooth extensions in boundary charts (The de Rham complex and pullback extend to manifolds with boundary).
For two connections on the same general-linear reduction, every Pontryagin curvature-polynomial difference is exact by transgression (Explicit Chern–Simons transgression between two connections).
For every real connection on , the de Rham class of maps under the de Rham isomorphism to the real coefficient image of ; the statement includes empty and boundary cases and makes no integral torsion claim (Characteristic forms represent topological characteristic classes over the reals).
The de Rham map for the stated manifolds is a natural ring isomorphism (The de Rham theorem).
A connection on a real vector bundle obeys the Leibniz rule (Connection on a smooth vector bundle); the product real line is the rank-one trivial smooth bundle (Smooth vector bundles, rank, fibres, and trivial bundles).
Proof
Proof technique: compute in common local frames, then use exactness and transgression for the arbitrary-connection class statement.
In concatenated local frames, the direct-sum connection has block-diagonal curvature. [F2, F3] On a common trivializing neighbourhood, concatenate frames of and . The connection matrix is . The structure equation shows that both exterior derivative and matrix wedge product preserve this block form, so the curvature matrix is .
Pullback of the connection transformation law glues the local pullback matrices, including in boundary charts. [F5, F6, F7] Let be smooth and let be a frame change on a target trivializing overlap. The connection forms satisfy the transformation law [F6]. Pull it back. By [F7], pullback preserves matrix products and wedges and commutes with , so the pulled-back matrices satisfy the same transition law with transition matrix . Thus they glue to the pullback connection in boundary as well as interior charts. This supplies the local connection calculation without assuming that is an immersion, submersion, or maps interior points only to interior points.
Strict form-level Pontryagin multiplicativity can fail without metric compatibility; two trivial real lines witness the failure. [F1, F3, F11, algebra] On , take trivial real line bundles with connections and . Expanding verifies the connection Leibniz rule [F11]. Their curvature forms are and . Each rank-one total Pontryagin form is . On the direct sum, the complexified curvature is block diagonal and the determinant convention gives Thus this chosen total form differs from , so strict form-level multiplicativity fails in this explicit example.
The block determinant factors over even-degree curvature entries, giving the total Chern product. [F1, F4, step 1.1, algebra] The curvature entries have even degree and commute in the exterior algebra, so Taking each homogeneous degree gives the total Chern form identity. The empty determinant gives the rank-zero unit.
For the ordered-sum orientation, the block-diagonal Pfaffian is the product of the two Pfaffians. [F1, F2, step 1.1, algebra] In oriented orthonormal frames, metric compatibility makes the curvature matrices skew-symmetric. The concatenated frame has the ordered-sum orientation, and the direct-sum curvature is block diagonal by step 1.1. In the Pfaffian alternating-sum formula, every nonzero term pairs indices inside one block; because the block precedes the block, the surviving terms factor with no permutation sign. Thus , also when a block has rank zero and its Pfaffian is . The normalizing powers of respect the product, proving the Euler form identity.
The local curvature equation gives , hence every characteristic form pulls back exactly. [F3, F4, F5, F7, step 1.2, algebra] In the pulled-back frame, [F3], [F5], and [F7] give Invariant-polynomial evaluation [F4] is a finite sum of scalar coefficients times wedges of curvature entries, and [F7] preserves those wedges; hence every such curvature form pulls back exactly. This includes Chern and Pontryagin determinant coefficients and the oriented Euler Pfaffian. Pullback preserves the supplied metric and orientation, so the Euler clause stays in its stated domain.
For metric-compatible real connections, total Pontryagin forms multiply strictly. [F1, step 2.1, algebra] Each complexified curvature matrix is skew-symmetric, so its odd Chern forms vanish pointwise by [F1]. Apply step 2.1 to the complexifications of : only even-indexed Chern components remain. In degree , write their indices as with . Since , the signed even Chern coefficient of the direct sum is exactly . This proves the total Pontryagin form identity in every degree.
For arbitrary real connections on the summands, odd-odd Chern cross terms change the product only by exact forms. [A1, F1, step 2.1, algebra] Let be arbitrary real connections and first use their direct-sum connection . By step 2.1 applied to the complexifications, the degree- Pontryagin form of the sum expands into even-even and odd-odd Chern terms. The even-even terms are precisely for . For an odd-odd term , [F1] and full AC give a primitive for its first factor; the second factor is closed by [F1]. Thus the term is . There are only finitely many such terms in each rank, so the difference is exact and
Any real connection on has Pontryagin forms cohomologous to those of the direct-sum connection. [F8, step 3.2] For any real connection on , apply [F8] degree by degree to the invariant polynomial defining each . For the curvature evaluation is the constant unit; for transgression shows is exact. Consequently , which with step 3.2 proves the class formula.
The comparison theorem identifies the class formula with multiplicativity of the real coefficient images of topological Pontryagin classes. [F9, F10, step 4.1] Apply [F9] to , and on the stated smooth bases. The de Rham ring isomorphism [F10] carries the equality in step 4.1 to multiplicativity of the real coefficient images of the topological Pontryagin classes. This comparison is over only; no integral torsion equality is asserted.
Empty, zero-rank, rank-one, degenerate-map, boundary, choice, and non-iff cases are covered as stated. [A1, F1, F7, step 2.1, step 2.2, step 2.3, step 3.1, step 3.2, step 5.1, cases] On an empty base each equality is the equality of the unique empty form. Rank-zero Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler forms are units, so a zero-rank summand contributes the multiplicative unit. A complex line has only and components; a real rank-one bundle has by the rank cutoff, and there is no odd-rank Euler form in this definition. Forms of degree exceeding the base dimension vanish. Steps 1.2 and 2.3 apply to constant and rank-deficient maps as written; for constant , and positive-degree curvature forms pull back to zero. All calculations extend to boundary points by [F7]. No statement is an iff. Full AC is used through [F1] in step 3.2 for exact odd Chern forms and through [F9] in step 5.1 for the topological comparison. The direct-sum, Pfaffian, pullback and explicit counterexample calculations are choice-free once the data are supplied.
Source notes
Bott, Lectures on Characteristic Classes and Foliations, §5, Proposition (5.6) and the total Pontryagin form immediately following it, printed pp. 31–33, identifies the metric skew-curvature vanishing and the total Pontryagin determinant and records the Whitney product. That passage concerns real characteristic classes; the form-level metric identity in step 3.1 is also checked directly from the block determinant.
Milnor–Stasheff, Characteristic Classes, Appendix C, the split-sum Chern calculation and Corollary C.10, printed pp. 310–312, give the curvature normalization, the Chern–Weil comparison for real Pontryagin classes, and exactness of odd curvature coefficients for arbitrary real connections. Lemma C.12 and its curvature application, printed pp. 313–314, give the Pfaffian covariance and normalization. Their convention is not imported blindly: step 2.2 uses the library's stated ordered orientation and Pfaffian normalization.
Miller, Algebraic Topology II, Lecture 36, printed pp. 135–136, explains that odd Chern classes of a complexified real bundle are two-torsion and that Pontryagin multiplicativity follows after passing to coefficients in which is invertible. This corroborates why step 5.1 asserts only the real-coefficient conclusion. The strict-form counterexample in step 1.3 is computed directly and does not come from that source.
Real characteristic forms do not detect integral torsion
Remark
Assume full AC. Let be a finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold, possibly empty or with boundary, and let be the coefficient map. Every integral torsion class maps to zero. Under the comparison theorem's respective hypotheses (a Hermitian connection for Chern forms, any real connection for Pontryagin forms, and a metric-compatible connection on an oriented even-rank Euclidean bundle for Euler forms), these forms determine only the real coefficient images of the integral characteristic classes. A zero real characteristic class does not imply that the integral class is zero.
This loss occurs for a flat bundle: the complexification of the tautological real line over has a flat Hermitian connection, while has exact order two. Its first Chern form is identically zero.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: Full Axiom of Choice, the characteristic-form comparison theorem, and the standard inclusion .
Full AC is the choice-function principle: every family of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Choice).
For Hermitian complex connections and real connections, the Chern–Weil comparison theorem identifies the de Rham classes of the characteristic forms with the real coefficient images of the corresponding integral Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler classes (Characteristic forms represent topological characteristic classes over the reals).
A coefficient homomorphism induces a map on singular cohomology, and that map commutes with pullback (Singular cohomology is contravariantly functorial).
Integral Chern classes are natural under pullback between the stated CW bases (Naturality, normalization, and Whitney sum for Chern classes).
The odd Chern classes of a complexified real bundle are two-torsion. The mod-two reduction of is ; total Stiefel–Whitney classes multiply over real direct sums. For the universal real line , its is the tautological degree-one class (Odd Chern classes of a complexified real bundle are two-torsion, Mod-two reduction of Chern classes, Whitney sum formula for Stiefel–Whitney classes, Stiefel–Whitney classes from the projective-bundle relation, Tautological degree-one class on a real projective bundle, The tautological degree-one class is well defined and fiber generating).
Restriction along is an isomorphism in mod-two cohomology through degree two (Mod-two cohomology ring of infinite real projective space).
Smooth nonzero transition functions satisfying the cocycle identities construct a smooth line bundle (Construction of a vector bundle from a smooth cocycle).
Complexification is and uses the real transition matrices as complex-linear transition maps; tensoring commutes with pullback (Complexification is conjugation invariant).
If frames obey , connection matrices obey (Connection one form transformation law); local matrices obeying this rule glue to a unique connection (Local connection forms glue exactly when they obey the transformation law).
A complex connection obeys the complex Leibniz rule and is Hermitian when it satisfies the metric derivative identity (Complex-linear and metric-compatible bundle connections).
The curvature matrix in a local frame is (Curvature two-form structure equation).
For a complex line, the normalized first Chern form is (Chern, Pontryagin, and Euler characteristic forms).
Cohomology with coefficients in a commutative-ring module is itself a module over that ring (Singular cohomology with coefficients).
Proof
Every integral torsion class maps to zero under the real coefficient map. [F2, F12, algebra] Let satisfy for a nonzero integer . The coefficient map is additive, so . By [F12], is a real vector space, it has no nonzero element annihilated by ; hence . This also covers negative by replacing it with .
The complexified tautological real line on has first Chern class of exact order two. [F2, F3, F4, F5, F6, F7] Let be the skeletal inclusion, put and . By the odd-class theorem in [F4], . The fiberwise real-linear map , , is an isomorphism. Thus [F4] gives By [F4, F5], is the polynomial generator and . Naturality of coefficient change [F2] gives The canonical fiberwise map , , identifies the complexification with the pullback of . The restricted real line is the standard tautological line by its fiber description. Naturality [F3] therefore identifies with . Thus and , so has exact order two.
Constant sign transitions on normalized frames give a flat Hermitian connection. [F6, F7, F8, F9, F10, F11, algebra] On each standard affine chart , let be the unique representative with th coordinate . The transition from to is the smooth nonzero coordinate ratio; the cocycle identity holds because these are rescalings of one vector. Thus [F6] gives the smooth tautological line with fibers . Set . These are smooth unit frames of . On each component of , the sign of is constant and the frames satisfy for a locally constant . Their complexifications are unitary frames of with the same constant transitions. In the underlying real frames the transition matrices are . Set the real connection matrices in every frame. Since , the transformation law [F8] holds and the local gluing theorem gives a global real connection. In these frames the complex structure has constant matrix, so the connection commutes with it; its zero matrices also satisfy the Hermitian metric derivative identity. Thus [F9] makes it a complex-linear Hermitian connection. The structure equation [F10] gives , so the determinant normalization [F11] yields pointwise.
The comparison theorem shows that the flat form misses this integral torsion. [F1, step 1.1, step 1.2, step 1.3] By step 1.1 the order-two class from step 1.2 maps to zero in real cohomology. Step 1.3 constructs a Hermitian connection with zero first Chern form. The comparison theorem [F1] identifies its de Rham class with that same zero real image, while remains nonzero by step 1.2. This is the promised explicit failure of real characteristic forms to detect integral torsion.
Empty, zero, rank-one, choice, endpoint, and iff cases are covered. [A1, F1, step 1.1, step 1.2, step 1.3, step 2.1, cases] The empty manifold has zero singular and de Rham groups, so the coefficient-map assertion is vacuous there; the witness is the fixed nonempty . The zero integral class maps to zero, while the exhibited degree-two class has exact order two. The witness is rank one and has a nonzero first Chern class. The exact-order argument in step 1.2 uses the nonzero reduction to exclude the zero class. No parameterized path or endpoint claim occurs. AC is assumed in [A1] and inherited through the characteristic-class suppliers used above; the normalized frames and flat connection in step 1.3 are explicit and choice-free. The remark states no biconditional.
Source notes
Miller, Lectures on Algebraic Topology II, Lecture 36, “Pontryagin classes,” printed pp. 135–136, explains that complexification of a real bundle is isomorphic to its conjugate and therefore its odd Chern classes are 2-torsion. This corroborates the torsion mechanism only. The nonzero order-two restriction to is established from [F2]–[F5], and the flat unitary connection is constructed directly from the local frames in step 1.3.
5 · Examples, counterexamples and false statements
None yet.
Sources
- Raoul Bott, Lectures on Characteristic Classes and Foliations
- John Milnor and James Stasheff, Characteristic Classes
- Stefan Haller, The Atiyah–Singer Index Theorem
- Stefan Haller, The Atiyah–Singer Index Theorem, Vienna lecture notes (2013)
- Allen Hatcher, Algebraic Topology
- Allen Hatcher, Vector Bundles & K-Theory
- Kaiwen, Talk 13: Cohomology of Projective Bundles (2025)
- John W. Milnor and James D. Stasheff, Characteristic Classes
- Haynes Miller, MIT 18.906 Algebraic Topology II, Lecture 36