How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Mackeys Imprimitivity Theorem
1 · Prerequisites
- Absolute and Conditional Convergence; Rearrangement; Products
- Analyticity of Holomorphic Functions; Liouville and Morera
- Approximation and Compactness in C(K)
- Arc Length and Rectifiable Curves
- Areas of Elementary Plane Figures
- Banach Alaoglu Goldstine and Krein Milman
- Banach Algebras Spectrum and Holomorphic Functional Calculus
- Banach Valued Integration and the Radon Nikodym Property
- Binary Operations, Monoids, Groups and Subgroups
- Bounded Linear Operators and Quotient Spaces
- Bounded Variation and the Riemann–Stieltjes Integral
- Character Groups and Elementary LCA Duals
- Compact Operators and Riesz Schauder Theory
- Compactness
- Compactness in Metric Spaces
- Complete Metrizability, Čech-Completeness, and Baire Category
- Completeness, Completion, and Uniform Continuity
- Complex Differentiability and the Cauchy–Riemann Equations
- Complex Lp Spaces and Test-Function Conventions
- Complex Power Series and Analytic Functions
- Connectedness
- Construction of the Natural Numbers
- Construction of the Real Numbers via Cauchy Sequences
- Construction of the Real Numbers via Dedekind Cuts
- Continuity, IVT, EVT, and Uniform Continuity
- Continuous Functional Calculus for Self Adjoint and Normal Operators
- Contour Integration
- Convergence: Nets and Filters
- Cosets, Index and Lagrange's Theorem
- Countability and Uncountability
- Countability Axioms and Cardinal Functions
- Density Separability and Convolution in Lᵖ
- Determinants of Matrices over a Commutative Ring
- Divisibility, Euclidean Domains, Principal Ideal Domains and Unique Factorisation
- Dual Spaces Adjoint Operators and Annihilators
- Dual Spaces, Bilinear and Quadratic Forms, and Sylvester's Law of Inertia
- Filters and Ultrafilters
- Finite Counting, Factorials and Binomial Coefficients
- Foundations of the Real Numbers for Analysis
- Fubini and Change of Variables
- Function Space Topologies and the Exponential Law
- Fundamental Trigonometric Identities
- Gaussian Elimination, Elementary Matrices and Reduced Row Echelon Form
- Gelfand Theory and Commutative C Star Algebras
- Goursat's Theorem and Cauchy's Theorem in a Convex Domain
- Group Actions, Orbits, Stabilisers and Cayley's Theorem
- Group Homomorphisms and the Isomorphism Theorems
- Haar Measure Existence and Uniqueness
- Hausdorff via the Diagonal
- Hereditary and Productive Behaviour of the Separation Axioms
- Hilbert Space Geometry and Riesz Representation
- Ideals, Quotient Rings and the Isomorphism Theorems for Rings
- Induced Unitary Representations of Locally Compact Groups
- Infinite Product Measures and Kolmogorov Extension
- Inner Product Spaces, Gram-Schmidt, Projections and Adjoints
- Lebesgue Measure on Euclidean Space
- Limits of Real Functions
- limsup, liminf, and Subsequential Limits
- Line Integrals and the Gradient Theorem
- Linear Independence, Bases and Dimension
- Linear Transformations, Rank-Nullity and Quotient Spaces
- Matrices, the Matrix of a Linear Map, and Change of Basis
- Measurable Functions and Simple Approximation
- Measurable Hilbert Fields and Direct-Integral Operators
- Measures and Their Basic Properties
- Metric Spaces
- Metrization: Urysohn, Nagata–Smirnov, Bing, Smirnov
- Mixed Partials, Taylor Formulae, and Extrema
- Modes of Convergence Egorov and Lusin
- Monotone Functions, Discontinuities, and Continuity Sets
- Monotone Sequences, Bolzano-Weierstrass, and Cauchy Completeness
- Normal Subgroups and Quotient Groups
- Normed and Banach Spaces
- Norming and Separation under Hahn–Banach
- Order, Zorn's Lemma, and the Axiom of Choice
- Ordinals, Cardinals, and Transfinite Recursion
- Orthonormal Bases, Parseval and Fourier Series
- Outer Measure and the Caratheodory Extension Theorem
- Partitions of Unity and Paracompactness
- pi: the Equivalent Characterizations
- Polynomial Rings, the Division Algorithm and Roots
- Power Series and Real-Analytic Functions
- Product Measures and the Fubini Tonelli Theorems
- Properties of the Integral and the Working FTC
- Radon Measures and the Riesz Markov Kakutani Theorem
- Relations, Functions, and Quotients
- Rings, Subrings, Integral Domains and Fields
- Rⁿ as a Normed Space; Vector-Valued Functions
- Roots, Rational Powers, and Classical Inequalities
- Semidirect Products, Automorphism Groups and Split Extensions
- Separation Axioms: the Hierarchy
- Sequences and Limits
- Sequences and Series of Functions; Uniform Convergence
- Series: Convergence and the Nonnegative Tests
- Sigma Algebras and Borel Sets
- Signed and Complex Measures Hahn and Jordan
- Simple Field Extensions and the Construction of the Complex Numbers
- Sine, Cosine, and the Definition of Pi
- Spectral Measures and Borel Functional Calculus
- Standard-Borel Real Codings and Determining Classes
- Stone–Weierstrass in General
- Subspaces, Products, and Quotients
- Suprema and Infima
- Symmetric Groups, Cycle Decomposition and the Sign Homomorphism
- The Analytic Hahn Banach Theorem
- The Ascoli–Arzelà Theorem
- The Baire Principles of Functional Analysis
- The Cantor Set, Baire Category, and Measure Zero in ℝ
- The Complex Exponential and Euler's Formula
- The Derivative and the Mean Value Theorems
- The Exponential Function
- The Fundamental Group of the Circle
- The Fundamental Theorems of Calculus
- The Lebesgue Integral and the Convergence Theorems
- The Logarithm and General Powers
- The Lᵖ Spaces Holder Minkowski and Riesz Fischer
- The Modular Function and L1 Group Algebras
- The Radon Nikodym Theorem and Lebesgue Decomposition
- The Riemann Integral in Rᵐ and Jordan Content
- The Riemann Integral: Definition and Integrability
- The Topology of Euclidean Space
- The Total Derivative in ℝᵐ → ℝⁿ
- The Tychonoff Embedding and the Stone–Čech Compactification
- The ZFC Axioms and the Basic Set Constructions
- Topological Spaces and Continuity
- Topology of ℝ
- Triangularisation, Generalised Eigenspaces and Jordan Canonical Form
- Uniform Spaces: the Three Definitions
- Unitary Representations, Positive Type and GNS
- Urysohn's Lemma and the Tietze Extension Theorem
- Vector Spaces, Linear Subspaces, Span and Direct Sums
- Weak and Weak Star Topologies
2 · Summary
Mackey's imprimitivity theorem classifies the transitive systems of imprimitivity of a second-countable locally compact group on a homogeneous space : they are exactly the systems induced from a strongly continuous unitary representation of the closed subgroup , and the classification is a bijection of unitary equivalence classes. The page builds the machinery from the definition of a system of imprimitivity and its transformation (covariance) algebra, through the -spectral measure of a representation of an abelian normal subgroup, the multiplicity model of a projection-valued measure over a standard Borel base, Borel cross-sections and Haar lifts on , and the regularization of transitive unitary cocycles by the stabilizer representation. It ends with the imprimitivity theorem, its uniqueness clause, and the little-group reduction for an abelian normal subgroup with regular dual orbits, which expresses every irreducible representation of a topological semidirect product as an induction from irreducible stabilizer data. The standing hypothesis is the Axiom of Choice, used through the rho-function, Fubini, Bochner and spectral-multiplicity suppliers.
3 · Logical flowchart
4 · Definitions, theorems and proofs
Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space
Definition
Let be a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff topological group (Locally compact topological space: every point has a compact neighbourhood; and what this says in a metric space, Second countability: an at most countable basis for the topology, Topological group: multiplication and inversion are continuous) acting measurably on a standard Borel space (Standard Borel spaces), that is, the map is -measurable (Left group actions, transitive actions, and faithful actions, A measurable function between measurable spaces, Measurable spaces and measurable sets), and let be a separable complex Hilbert space (Hilbert space, Separability: the existence of an at most countable dense subset). A system of imprimitivity for the action is a pair in which is a strongly continuous unitary representation (Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners) and is a projection-valued measure on the Borel -algebra of (Projection valued measure) such that
The family of -null Borel sets is the null-set class of the system; the system is ergodic when every Borel with for all satisfies or , and is nonzero when and .
Well-definedness. The covariance relation is a condition on the given pair: for fixed the map is a projection-valued measure because is a -algebra automorphism of , and is the projection with the same range as transported by the unitary , so both sides of the displayed identity are orthogonal projections (Projection valued measure); since is unitary, throughout. The null-set class is a -ideal of : a projection vanishes exactly when the finite scalar set functions () all vanish, and these are countably additive because the series in clause 4 of the projection-valued measure definition converges in norm and the inner product is continuous (Projection valued measure). No regularity of is assumed, no topological condition beyond measurability of the action is imposed, and the definition itself makes no choice.
The transformation (covariance) algebra
Definition
Assume AC (The Axiom of Choice). Let be a locally compact Hausdorff topological group (Topological group: multiplication and inversion are continuous, Locally compact topological space: every point has a compact neighbourhood; and what this says in a metric space) acting continuously on a locally compact Hausdorff space (Left group actions, transitive actions, and faithful actions, Continuity of a map of topological spaces at a point and globally, Locally compact topological space: every point has a compact neighbourhood; and what this says in a metric space), with a fixed left Haar measure (Left Haar integral and left Haar measure) and modular function (Modular function of a locally compact group). The transformation algebra of the action is the complex vector space of continuous complex functions with compact support (Compact support, , and ), equipped with the twisted convolution
and the involution
Well-definedness: support and continuity. Let , be compact sets with (). If then and , while forces ; hence the integrand of is supported in the compact set , which is nonempty only for , and the integral is a finite number by finiteness of Haar measure on compacta. For in a compact neighbourhood of a fixed the -support lies in the fixed compact set , and in a compact neighbourhood of a fixed ; the map is continuous on as a composition of the continuous group operations and the continuous action (Topological group: multiplication and inversion are continuous, Left group actions, transitive actions, and faithful actions), so it is uniformly continuous on the compact set . Given there is a neighbourhood of with for all and ; both integrands vanish off , so , where is the finite Haar measure of . This proves continuity of ; its support is contained in , a compact set, so . The product is bilinear in by linearity of the Haar integral.
Well-definedness: associativity. Fix and put ; it is continuous and compactly supported in , with support in the compact set by the support computation above. Writing each convolution as its defining integral, the left-hand side of at is the iterated integral , while the right-hand side is ; by Compactly supported kernels admit commuting radon integrals applied to the continuous compactly supported kernel the order of the first iterated integral may be interchanged, and the inner substitution , which preserves the left Haar integral by Left Haar integral and left Haar measure and changes , , , identifies them. Hence is associative.
Well-definedness: involution. The function is continuous, since and are continuous (Modular function of a locally compact group, The modular function is a continuous homomorphism), and its support is the image of the compact set under that homeomorphism, hence compact; so . Applying twice and using that is a continuous homomorphism into the positive reals, so that , gives that is, . In the same way, for the products one computes and substituting in the defining integral of turns its modular factor into because , so . Together with the conjugate-linearity of this says that with and is a complex associative algebra with involution; the involution of the group convolution is the special case of the published definition (Compactly supported convolution on a group).
Trivial action. If for all , then the twisted product becomes , which is convolution in the group variable with pointwise multiplication in the base variable, with the factor order of Compactly supported convolution on a group.
AC is inherited through Compactly supported kernels admit commuting radon integrals, which commutes the two Radon integrals in the associativity computation; no independent choice step is used, and the support, continuity and involution computations themselves make no choice.
Characters of the L1 algebra of an abelian group
Statement
Assume AC. For a second-countable LCH abelian group with Haar measure, every nonzero complex-linear multiplicative functional on is uniquely for a continuous unitary character . This bijection from with its compact-open topology to the character space with its pointwise-evaluation topology is a homeomorphism. No Pontryagin duality or Fourier inversion theorem is assumed.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, a second-countable LCH abelian group with a fixed left Haar measure , and a nonzero complex-linear multiplicative functional .
is a complex Banach -algebra whose convolution is bilinear, associative and contractive, , and agrees with the convolution whenever both arguments lie in (L1 of a locally compact group is a Banach star-algebra, Convolution on L1 of a locally compact group).
is complete and is dense in it (Completeness of the complex Haar L1 and L2 spaces and density of Cc).
For the translation operator is linear and isometric on , , and is continuous in the norm of for every (Strong continuity of left and modular right translations on L1 and L2).
A character of a nonzero unital complex Banach algebra is unital and satisfies (Characters on a unital Banach algebra are continuous).
A strongly measurable Banach-valued function with is Bochner integrable, and its integral obeys ; a bounded linear commutes with the Bochner integral, (Bochner integrability criterion, Bochner integral norm inequality, Bounded linear maps commute with Bochner integration, Strongly measurable Banach-valued function).
For -finite measure spaces and the two iterated integrals agree with the product integral; the compactly supported instances used below satisfy the -finiteness hypothesis because on a compact subset of the restricted Haar measures are finite (Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product, Compactly supported kernels admit commuting radon integrals).
Haar measure is positive on nonempty open sets and finite on compact sets, and compact sets admit nonnegative compactly supported cutoffs equal to one on them (Haar measure is positive on nonempty open sets and finite on compact sets, LCH Urysohn cutoff).
is the group of continuous homomorphisms with the compact-open topology, and the character space of carries the topology of pointwise evaluation (The Pontryagin dual with the compact-open topology, Character and maximal ideal space).
AC is the standing hypothesis (The Axiom of Choice).
Proof
Given: AC, a second-countable LCH abelian group with left Haar measure, and a nonzero complex-linear multiplicative on .
Put with and . The product is bilinear and associative, , and is complete, so it is a nonzero unital complex Banach algebra with unit ; the map is complex-linear, multiplicative because is multiplicative, and , so it is a character. By [F4], for every .
Since there is with ; fix such a and set for .
For all and all one has : for both sides are continuous functions computed by the pointwise convolution formula, and substituting in uses left invariance of to give ; both sides are bounded bilinear in by [F1] and [F3], and is dense in by [F2], so the identity extends to all .
For all , as a Bochner integral. Approximate in by and pass to a subsequence with a.e.; each is continuous and compactly supported hence strongly measurable, and a diagonal selection of their defining simple approximants shows that the a.e. limit is strongly measurable; since , it is Bochner integrable by [F5]. The assignment is bounded linear, and for pairing with any and commuting the bounded functional through the Bochner integral reduces the identity to , which follows from [F6] because the kernel is compactly supported; the pairing with all of separates points of , and both sides are bounded linear in with dense by [F2], so the identity holds for all ; repeating the same density argument in the second variable gives it for all as well.
Conversely, for a continuous character define . Then is complex-linear with , and it is multiplicative: for the double integral equals by [F6] the iterated integral after the substitution and using ; both and are bounded bilinear in , so density of ([F2]) extends multiplicativity to all . And : by continuity of at there is a nonempty open set with on , and by [F7] there is with , , supported in ; then , so .
Multiplicativity of applied to [step 1.3] with this gives , hence for every and every .
If in the compact-open topology, then for every : given choose with ([F2]); then , and uniformly on the compact set directly from the compact-open subbasis, while the Haar measure of is finite by [F7]. Thus the map is continuous for the two stated topologies.
is multiplicative: since and , applying [step 2.1] to gives , so ; in particular and .
is continuous: for in one has by [step 1.1] and [F3].
Apply the bounded functional to [step 1.4] and commute it through the Bochner integral: by [step 2.1]; since , dividing gives the classification formula for every .
Conversely, suppose in the pointwise-evaluation topology of the character space. Fix the of [step 1.2] and a compact . The set is norm compact in as the continuous image of under [F3], so for each it has a finite -net . For all sufficiently large one has for every and , using [step 1.1] for the bounds and ; then for every and the corresponding one gets , and division by the eventually nonvanishing gives uniformly on for a constant depending only on and . Hence pointwise implies uniformly on compacta, that is, the inverse map is continuous.
for every : [step 1.1] gives , and applying [step 3.1] to the powers gives for all , whence ; replacing by and using gives as well. Thus is a continuous character.
If , choose with . Substitution in the defining integral gives for . Hence for every , so . Together with step 3.3 this proves the bijection.
Steps [2.2] and [3.4] show that is a homeomorphism from with the compact-open topology onto the character space with the pointwise-evaluation topology, and [step 3.3] with [step 5.1] shows every nonzero complex-linear multiplicative functional is uniquely of the form .
Remarks
The proof uses no Pontryagin duality and no Fourier inversion: the characters are produced from itself through the translation identity, and the only harmonic-analytic inputs are translation continuity, Haar positivity and the Bochner/Fubini calculus.
Direct integrals transport along bimeasurable base isomorphisms
Statement
Assume AC. Let and be -finite standard Borel measure spaces, let be a bimeasurable bijection with , and let be a measurable complex Hilbert field over with direct integral . Then is a measurable Hilbert field over with the pulled-back fundamental family, and pullback of sections is a unitary that intertwines multiplication by with multiplication by . A decomposable operator field over corresponds to the decomposable field over with the same essential norm and the same fibrewise adjoint and product identities.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, -finite standard Borel measure spaces , , a bimeasurable bijection with , and a measurable Hilbert field with countable fundamental family and direct integral .
The field datum means exactly: a separable Hilbert space for each , vectors spanning a dense subspace of , Borel Gram coefficients ; a section is measurable when all coefficients are Borel, and sections are identified when they agree off a Borel null set (Measurable Hilbert field from a countable fundamental family).
is the quotient of the square-integrable measurable sections by almost-everywhere agreement, with inner product , and it is a Hilbert space (Direct integral of a measurable Hilbert field, Direct integrals of measurable Hilbert fields are Hilbert spaces).
For a section, coefficient measurability is equivalent to measurability of all pairings with measurable sections; such sections are closed under measurable scalar combinations and pointwise norm limits, and is measurable (Measurable sections have measurable pointwise inner products).
Precomposition with the Borel maps and preserves Borel measurability (Composition with a Borel measurable outer map preserves measurability, Standard Borel spaces, Measurable spaces and measurable sets).
An operator field is weakly measurable when its fundamental matrix coefficients are Borel; it is essentially bounded when , and a bounded operator on is decomposable when it acts by such a field, (Measurable and decomposable operator fields).
Proof
Given: AC, the base spaces and the field of the statement, with fundamental family over .
Define in . The Gram coefficients are Borel by [F1] and [F4], and for each the span of equals the span of , which is dense in ; hence with this pulled-back family is a measurable Hilbert field with countable fundamental family over .
A section over has Borel coefficients if and only if the section over has Borel coefficients : one direction is [F4], and the converse applies [F4] to , which is bimeasurable; by [F3] the same equivalence holds for all pairings, and is measurable whenever is.
Change of variables: for every nonnegative Borel function on , , because is the pushforward; consequently for a measurable section one has , so is square-integrable exactly when is.
Define on the direct integral. It is well defined on classes: if outside a Borel -null set , then outside , and ; it is complex-linear because the fibre operations are pointwise and pullback is linear; and it preserves inner products, , by [step 3.1]. It is surjective: for a measurable square-integrable section over , the section is measurable over by [step 2.1] applied to and has and the same integral by [step 3.1]. Hence is a complex-linear surjective isometry between the two direct integrals, that is, a unitary.
A weakly measurable, essentially bounded operator field over pulls back to the operator field on the fibres : its fundamental matrix coefficients are , Borel by [F4], so the pulled field is weakly measurable, and has -measure , so the two operator-norm functions have the same essential supremum; moreover, for a square-integrable section over , the pulled section is the pullback of the square-integrable section , so the decomposable action is transported. Fibrewise adjoint and product identities are preserved because for each the fibre operator is itself, and .
Finally intertwines multiplication: for and a square-integrable section , pointwise. Together with [step 4.1] and [step 4.2] this proves that is a measurable field, that is a unitary intertwining the two multiplication algebras, and that decomposable fields transport with the same essential norm and fibrewise algebraic identities.
Nondegenerate representations of C0 have regular PVMs
Statement
Assume AC. Let be LCH and a nondegenerate star representation. Then a unique regular PVM on with satisfies for every . The zero Hilbert space has the zero PVM.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, an LCH space , a complex Hilbert space , and a nondegenerate star representation .
The one-point compactification is compact Hausdorff, is an open subspace carrying its own topology, and is the point at infinity ( is compact and contains as an open subspace; is dense in exactly when is not compact; and is Hausdorff exactly when is locally compact and Hausdorff, The one-point (Alexandroff) compactification , whose open sets are the open sets of together with the complements in of the closed compact subsets of ).
For a nonempty compact Hausdorff and a nonzero , every unital star homomorphism is for a unique regular PVM on (Continuous functional calculus produces a regular PVM).
For a PVM on a measurable space, the bounded Borel integral is linear, multiplicative, conjugation preserving and unital; and if is a PVM on with scalar measures , then is finite (Bounded borel pvm integral, Pvm integral is a star homomorphism).
A star representation is complex-linear with and ; nondegeneracy means the closed linear span of equals (the convention of Continuous functional calculus produces a regular PVM).
Proof
Given: AC, the LCH space , the Hilbert space and the nondegenerate star representation .
If , let be the zero PVM, for every Borel ; then and for every , and it is the only PVM on . So assume from now on.
Extend to a unital star homomorphism by , where is regarded as an element of through the open inclusion : it is continuous on and tends to at because does. The map is linear, so is linear and ; and is multiplicative and conjugation preserving because for , writing , with , and , one has with , so , and .
By [F2] applied to the nonempty compact Hausdorff space and the unital star homomorphism there is a unique regular PVM on with for every .
For every one has : since as a bounded Borel function on and the bounded integral is multiplicative, .
Nondegeneracy forces : suppose and pick in its range; then for every and , by [step 4.1], so is orthogonal to the linear span of , which is dense by nondegeneracy; hence , a contradiction.
Define for Borel . This is a PVM on : the Borel sets of the open subspace are exactly the traces of Borel sets of , the values are orthogonal projections with , by [step 5.1], multiplicativity and countable additivity are inherited from . For , , since vanishes at and .
is regular: for each , the finite measure on is the restriction of the regular Borel measure on ; inner regularity holds because each compact subset of in the subspace topology is compact in , and outer regularity holds because open subsets of are open in .
Uniqueness: if is any regular PVM on with for all , let be its extension by zero at infinity, for Borel . This is a regular PVM on : values are orthogonal projections, and , countable additivity and multiplicativity are inherited from , and its finite scalar measures are inner regular on all Borel sets, including those containing , by compact approximation inside . Outer regularity follows by applying inner regularity to complements in the compact space ; thus the extension is regular. For write with and ; then , so represents and the uniqueness in [F2] gives and hence .
Thus for nonzero there is exactly one regular PVM on with and , namely the restriction of ; for the zero PVM is the unique one by [step 1.1]. Both cases together prove the claim.
Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel
Statement
Assume AC. Every second-countable locally compact Hausdorff space is Polish, hence standard Borel. Consequently, if is a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff topological group and is a closed subgroup, then the homogeneous space with its quotient topology is Polish and the quotient Borel structure together with the left action is a standard Borel -space with Borel action.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, a second-countable LCH space ; later a second-countable LCH group and a closed subgroup .
For a locally compact Hausdorff space : every point and open neighbourhood admit an open with and compact; the open sets with compact closure form a base of ; and is regular (In a locally compact Hausdorff space every open set containing a point contains an open set containing it whose closure is compact and still inside; such a space is regular, Countably compact, Lindel"of, sequentially compact, limit point compact and -compact spaces, and relatively compact subsets, Locally compact topological space: every point has a compact neighbourhood; and what this says in a metric space).
AC implies DC and DC implies Countable Choice (AC implies DC implies countable choice); AC implies the ultrafilter lemma, as recorded by the locally proved upper bound in the choice ledger.
Every regular second-countable space is metrizable (Under choice, every regular second-countable space is metrizable); in particular so is (Second countability: an at most countable basis for the topology, Topology on a set, open and closed sets, clopen sets, the closed-set axiomatisation, and the coarser/finer comparison).
Every locally compact Hausdorff space is Čech-complete (Every locally compact Hausdorff space is Čech-complete), and a metrizable space is Čech-complete if and only if it is completely metrizable (Under the ultrafilter lemma and the Axiom of Choice, a metrizable space is Čech-complete exactly when it is completely metrizable).
For a completely metrizable space, separability is equivalent to second countability; a Polish space is a separable completely metrizable space, and a standard Borel space is a measurable space Borel isomorphic to a Polish space (For completely metrizable spaces, the separable and second-countable definitions of Polish space agree under countable choice, Polish spaces are separable completely metrizable spaces, Standard Borel spaces).
If is closed in an LCH group , then with the quotient topology is locally compact Hausdorff and the quotient map is open; every compact subset of lies in for a compact (Compact lifts and averaging onto C_c(G/H), Left and right cosets and of a subgroup, The quotient topology of a surjection, quotient maps, saturated sets, and the quotient of a space by an equivalence relation with its canonical projection, Topological group: multiplication and inversion are continuous).
Multiplication is continuous, and the left action of a group on a quotient by a subgroup is induced by it (Topological group: multiplication and inversion are continuous, Left group actions, transitive actions, and faithful actions, Left and right cosets and of a subgroup).
Proof
Given: AC; a second-countable LCH space , later a second-countable LCH group with closed subgroup .
Let be a countable base of and let be the members of whose closure is compact. This is a base: given and an open , [F1] yields an open with and compact, and then some satisfies , so is compact and . Hence every point of lies in a member of , whose closure is compact, and the closures of the countably many members of cover ; thus is a countable union of compact sets.
is regular by [F1] and because it is Hausdorff, so with its countable base it is metrizable by [F3]; fix a compatible metric .
is Čech-complete by [F4], and being metrizable it is completely metrizable by the equivalence in [F4]; the choice hypotheses of [F4] are DC and the ultrafilter lemma with AC, which hold by [F2] under the standing AC. Since is second countable, [F5] makes it Polish, and then standard Borel by [F5]. This proves the first assertion.
Now let be a second-countable LCH group and closed. By [F6] the quotient is locally compact Hausdorff and is open, so the images of the members of a countable base of form a countable family of open sets; it is a base of because for and an open the preimage is open and contains a basic through some point of the fibre, whence . Thus is second-countable LCH, and [step 2.1] applied to shows that is Polish and its Borel structure is standard Borel.
The left action , , is continuous: the composite is continuous on by [F7], it factors through the surjective open map (because implies ), and a continuous open surjection is a quotient map, so is continuous; in particular is Borel for the product of the Borel structures.
Combining the two parts: every second-countable LCH space is Polish and standard Borel, and for a second-countable LCH group with closed subgroup the homogeneous space is Polish with standard Borel structure and the left action is continuous and hence Borel. The empty space is Polish and standard Borel by the same definitions, consistently with the vacuous case of the first assertion.
Steinhaus and Pettis: Borel homomorphisms of second-countable locally compact groups are continuous
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff topological group with left Haar measure . (i) If is Borel with , then contains an open neighbourhood of the identity. (ii) If is a second-countable topological group and is a Borel-measurable group homomorphism, then is continuous. In particular, a Borel homomorphism from a second-countable locally compact group into the unitary group of a separable Hilbert space, with the strong operator topology, is strongly continuous.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, a second-countable LCH group with left Haar measure ; in part (ii) a second-countable topological group and a Borel homomorphism .
carries a nonzero left Haar measure , positive on nonempty open sets and finite on compact sets; left translates of Borel sets preserve (Existence of a left Haar integral, Left Haar integral and left Haar measure, Haar measure is positive on nonempty open sets and finite on compact sets).
For the map , , is norm continuous; hence so is (Strong continuity of left and modular right translations on L1 and L2).
In a topological group, inversion is continuous, multiplication is continuous, every neighbourhood of the identity contains a symmetric neighbourhood, and a homomorphism continuous at the identity is continuous everywhere (Topological group: multiplication and inversion are continuous).
The Borel -algebra is generated by the open sets, and a Borel homomorphism is a group homomorphism measurable for the Borel structures; preimages of open sets are Borel (The Borel sigma-algebra of a topological space, A measurable function between measurable spaces).
A second-countable space is Lindelöf: for an open cover, the members of a fixed countable base contained in some member of the cover form a countable refinement, and choosing one containing cover member for each of them uses Countable Choice, which follows from AC (Second countability: an at most countable basis for the topology, Compact implies countably compact, Lindel"of and limit point compact; countably compact together with Lindel"of implies compact; and, at the cost of countable or dependent choice, sequentially compact implies countably compact, countably compact implies limit point compact, and the converse holds when every singleton is closed, AC implies DC implies countable choice, The Axiom of Choice).
The strong operator topology on is the initial topology of the maps , (Strong and weak operator topologies); is the group of unitary operators on (Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners).
A separable Hilbert space has a finite or countable orthonormal basis, which may be padded by zero vectors to a sequence indexed by (A Hilbert space with a dense sequence has a finite or countable orthonormal basis).
is locally compact Hausdorff, so points have compact neighbourhoods and the open sets with compact closure form a base (Locally compact topological space: every point has a compact neighbourhood; and what this says in a metric space).
Proof
Given: AC, the group with Haar measure , and in part (ii) the group and the Borel homomorphism .
Part (i): let be Borel with and put . For , , so ; by [F2] this function of is continuous and equals at . Hence there is an open neighbourhood of with , hence , for every ; writing with gives . Thus .
Part (ii), reduction: is a homomorphism, so for , ; since multiplication and inversion in are continuous by [F3], is continuous at every point as soon as it is continuous at . It therefore suffices to show that is a neighbourhood of for every neighbourhood of .
A second-countable space is Lindelöf, with the argument of [F5]: fixing a countable base, the basic open sets contained in some member of an open cover form a countable refinement, and Countable Choice (a consequence of AC) selects a cover member for each of them. We apply this to with the subspace topology, which is second countable as a subspace of .
The unitary group of a separable Hilbert space is second countable in the strong operator topology: fix a finite or countable orthonormal basis padded to a sequence by [F7] and consider , . It is injective (a unitary vanishing on a complete orthonormal system is zero) and continuous for the SOT by [F6]; conversely, if in the initial topology of the coordinate maps , then for and choose with ; then for all beyond a suitable index, so strongly. Thus the SOT on is the initial topology of the countable family , making it homeomorphic to a subspace of the second-countable space , hence second countable.
with the strong operator topology is a topological group: if and strongly, then ; and if strongly with unitary, then , so inversion is continuous.
Fix a neighbourhood of and choose a symmetric neighbourhood of with , using continuity of multiplication at and symmetry of neighbourhoods ([F3]). The family is an open cover of , because ; by [step 1.3] it has a countable subcover with centres , , chosen with .
The preimage has positive measure: it is Borel by [F4], and if , then for every the left translate is null by [F1] and the sets cover , since gives , that is, and . A countable cover of the nonempty open set by null sets would give , contradicting positivity of on the nonempty open set in [F1].
Choose a Borel set with : by [F8] and second countability, the members of a countable base with compact closure cover , so with compact; if for every then countable additivity would give , contrary to [step 3.1], so some is Borel with by [F1].
By part (i), [step 1.1], the set contains an open neighbourhood of , and , because is a homomorphism and is symmetric. Hence is a neighbourhood of ; by [step 1.2] is continuous. This proves (ii).
Let be a Borel homomorphism from the second-countable LCH group into with the strong operator topology. By [step 1.4] is second countable and by [step 1.5] it is a topological group, so part (ii) proved in [step 5.1] applies and is strongly continuous. Together with part (i) of [step 1.1] this proves every assertion of the statement.
Remarks
The proof of (ii) uses only the positive measure of the preimage of a neighbourhood of the identity, extracted through a countable subcover of the orbit cover; no countability of the group of values is assumed beyond second countability of the target.
Unitary intertwiners preserve fibre multiplicity over a standard Borel base
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a standard Borel space, a nonzero finite Borel measure on , and let be Borel multiplicity functions. If there is a unitary with for every bounded Borel , then -almost everywhere. Consequently a multiplicity model of a projection-valued measure over a fixed base is unique in multiplicity, and a unitary intertwiner of two such models is a decomposable operator whose fibres are unitary almost everywhere.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, a standard Borel space with a nonzero finite Borel measure , Borel multiplicity functions , and a unitary with for all bounded Borel .
For a Borel function the field with fibre and fundamental family the -th coordinate vector for and otherwise has Borel Gram coefficients and spans a dense subspace of each fibre; its direct integral is a Hilbert space of measurable square-integrable sections, and in the constant case the fibre family is orthonormal and complete, so Parseval in each fibre makes an isometry onto the vector-valued -space (Measurable Hilbert field from a countable fundamental family, Direct integral of a measurable Hilbert field, Measurable sections have measurable pointwise inner products, Parseval equivalences for an orthonormal family).
For the multiplication is a bounded operator on , , and for a Borel the operator is the orthogonal projection onto the closed subspace of sections supported in (Direct integral of a measurable Hilbert field, Hilbert space).
On a -finite standard Borel base with a measurable Hilbert field, the commutant of the diagonal multiplications is exactly the set of decomposable operators; an operator commuting with is induced by a weakly measurable, essentially bounded field of fibre operators, and that field is unique up to a null set (Decomposable operators are the commutant of diagonal multiplication, Measurable and decomposable operator fields, Measurable essentially bounded operator fields act decomposably).
A unitary between complex inner product spaces is a bijective linear isometry, so it exists only between fibres of equal dimension in : a finite-dimensional cannot be linearly isomorphic to , and for distinct finite (Hilbert space, Separability: the existence of an at most countable dense subset, Orthonormal families, complete orthonormal systems and Hilbert bases).
The sets are Borel for a Borel , and is the countable disjoint union of the Borel sets , so measures on are countably additive over this partition; the standard Borel base is -finite for the finite measure (Standard Borel spaces, Monotone convergence for the integral, A sigma-finite signed measure that is absolutely continuous with respect to a sigma-finite positive measure has a unique almost-everywhere density).
Proof
Given: AC, the data and the unitary of the statement.
For each Borel set , the identity and unitarity of give , so carries the range of the projection onto the range of ; restricting to these closed subspaces yields a unitary from the sections of supported in to the sections of supported in .
Fix and put , a Borel set by [F5]. The supported subspace of over is, by [F1], the direct integral over of the constant field with fibre ; similarly the target over is the constant field with fibre . The unitary of [step 1.1] intertwines the multiplication operators for all bounded Borel on , because is the restriction of and preserves the supported subspaces.
Assume . Apply [F3] to the sum field and its block operator whose only nonzero block is from the first summand to the second. This operator commutes with all diagonal multiplications, so its off-diagonal block is decomposable: there is a weakly measurable, essentially bounded operator field with acting by fibrewise; the same applies to , and since and , the uniqueness of decomposable fields in [F3] gives and for -almost every . Thus for almost every the fibre map is a unitary between and .
Hence whenever : by [step 3.1] a unitary exists for some , and [F4] says this forces .
Therefore is a countable union of sets of -measure zero, hence -null by countable additivity; that is, -almost everywhere.
The intertwiner itself is decomposable: its block operator on the direct sum of the two fields commutes with all diagonal multiplications, so [F3] represents its off-diagonal block by a weakly measurable essentially bounded field. Applying the same to , whose field is the fibrewise adjoint up to a null set by the uniqueness clause of [F3], and using as in [step 3.1], its fibres are unitary almost everywhere. Thus every unitary intertwiner of two multiplicity models over the fixed base has unitary fibres a.e., and the multiplicity is unique, which is exactly the rigidity statement a multiplicity model of a projection-valued measure over a fixed base invokes.
A system of imprimitivity integrates to a nondegenerate representation of the transformation algebra
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a system of imprimitivity on a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff -space with continuous action, as required by the transformation-algebra definition. For define by the scalar pairing where . Then is a bounded operator, , the map is a -representation of the transformation algebra , and it is nondegenerate: the closed span of is .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the system of imprimitivity on the second-countable LCH -space with continuous action, and .
For a bounded Borel and the operator satisfies , , , and ; is a finite complex measure with ; if bounded Borel pointwise -a.e. and then strongly (Bounded borel pvm integral, Scalar and complex measures from a pvm, Pvm integral is a star homomorphism).
is a strongly continuous unitary representation together with a PVM satisfying for all and Borel ; equivalently for every bounded Borel , i.e. (Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space).
The transformation algebra has product and involution (The transformation (covariance) algebra , Modular function of a locally compact group, Compactly supported convolution on a group).
The Haar integral is left invariant and finite on compacta, and for nonnegative Borel (Left Haar integral and left Haar measure, Haar change of variables under inversion, Haar measure is positive on nonempty open sets and finite on compact sets).
A continuous function with compact support is uniformly continuous on compacta: for compact there is for each a neighbourhood of every on which ; consequently is continuous in the supremum norm on a neighbourhood of each , with supports in a fixed compact subset of and vanishing outside the compact projection of (Compact support, , and ).
Bochner calculus in the Hilbert space : a strongly measurable -valued function with finite integral of the norm is Bochner integrable, , and bounded linear maps commute with (Bochner integrability criterion, Bochner integral norm inequality, Bounded linear maps commute with Bochner integration). Scalar iterated integrals of bounded integrable kernels agree (Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product).
There is a contractively bounded approximate identity , , , , directed by identity neighbourhoods of , with in (L1 group algebras have a contractively bounded approximate identity).
is second-countable LCH, so it is the union of an increasing sequence of compact sets (replace a countable compact cover by its successive finite unions) and for each there is with and on (Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel for the Polish/compact-exhaustion structure, LCH Urysohn cutoff).
Proof
Given: AC, the system and a test function .
For fixed put ; by [F1] this is a bounded operator and . The map is norm continuous: if is the compact group projection of , then for and uniform continuity of on the compact set gives for all once is close to , whence ; and for . Consequently is strongly continuous for every (product of a norm-continuous and a strongly continuous factor) and supported in the compact set .
Covariance in operator form: conjugating by the unitary and using gives , that is for every bounded Borel and .
Nondegeneracy, first factor: for every , along the approximate identity of [F7], where is the Bochner integral in ; indeed and, given , strong continuity gives an identity neighbourhood with for , while for the support condition and make the last integral at most .
Define as a Bochner integral: strong measurability follows from [step 1.1], and with because the integrand vanishes off and is bounded there by on a compact set of finite Haar measure. Hence is a well-defined bounded operator with for every , so . Pairing with and commuting the bounded functional through the Bochner integral gives exactly the displayed identity . The map is complex-linear because the integrand is bilinear in and the Bochner integral is linear.
Nondegeneracy, second factor: strongly for the sequence of [F8], by the pointwise dominated convergence of [F1], since pointwise on and . For the product function one has , because the bounded operator commutes with the Bochner integral . Given and choose with and then small enough that ; then . Hence the closed span of contains every , so is nondegenerate.
Multiplicativity: for , using [step 2.1] twice, [step 1.2] with and , and the left-Haar substitution (so , ) one computes ; the scalar kernel is integrable on the compact support, so Fubini's theorem turns the iterated integral into , using the identification of the inner Bochner integral of multiplication operators through its pairings and the definition of the twisted product in [F3]. As is arbitrary this gives .
Adjoint: taking adjoints in the defining Bochner integral and using and , , where the second equality is [step 1.2] with and . Substituting in the Haar integral and using [F4] in the form gives , with the modular involution of [F3].
Steps 2.1, 3.1 and 3.2 show that is a bounded -representation of the transformation algebra with the stated norm bound, and step 2.2 shows it is nondegenerate. The homogeneous-space case of the pair satisfies the added topological hypotheses, since is second-countable LCH with continuous left action (Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel).
Remarks
The pairing definition and the operator definition agree, and no regularity of beyond the PVM axioms is used; the continuous action is needed only to make vary continuously in the supremum norm.
Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff topological group, a closed subgroup, and the quotient map. Then there is a Borel cross-section with , and for every there is a unique with , where ; the map is Borel into . Consequently the map , , is a Borel isomorphism onto , and the quasi-invariant measure class on may be transported to a -finite measure on along .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, a second-countable LCH group , a closed subgroup , and the quotient map .
and are Polish, is continuous and open, and is locally compact Hausdorff (Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel, Compact lifts and averaging onto C_c(G/H)).
A Polish space carries a compatible complete metric ; convergent sequences, Cauchy sequences, closed sets, diameters and compactness are read in this metric (Polish spaces are separable completely metrizable spaces, Convergence of a sequence in a metric space: iff in , Bounded subset, diameter, distance from a point to a set, and distance between two sets in a metric space, Complete metric space: every Cauchy sequence converges in the space).
has a countable base of relatively compact open sets, and for every point and open there is a base element with and compact closure, with as small as prescribed (Second countability: an at most countable basis for the topology, In a locally compact Hausdorff space every open set containing a point contains an open set containing it whose closure is compact and still inside; such a space is regular, Locally compact topological space: every point has a compact neighbourhood; and what this says in a metric space, Countably compact, Lindel"of, sequentially compact, limit point compact and -compact spaces, and relatively compact subsets).
By [F1], and are Polish and hence standard Borel; their Borel structures are generated by their open sets (Standard Borel spaces, The Borel sigma-algebra of a topological space).
The quotient map satisfies for all , and is the stabilizer of the identity coset; multiplication and inversion of are continuous, so composites of Borel maps with the group operations are Borel (Left and right cosets and of a subgroup, Topological group: multiplication and inversion are continuous, The Borel sigma-algebra of a topological space).
Countable Choice, a consequence of the standing AC, selects one point from each member of a countable family of nonempty sets, and in particular fixes a point in each member of a countable base of (The Axiom of Choice, Compact implies countably compact, Lindel"of and limit point compact; countably compact together with Lindel"of implies compact; and, at the cost of countable or dependent choice, sequentially compact implies countably compact, countably compact implies limit point compact, and the converse holds when every singleton is closed).
Proof
Given: AC, the second-countable LCH group , the closed subgroup , and the quotient map .
Fix a compatible complete metric on by [F2]. By second countability and [F3], choose a countable base of relatively compact open sets such that for every open , every , and every there is a with and : for each basic open set and each positive integer , the refinements supplied by [F3] cover that basic open set, and second countability gives a countable subcover. By [F6] choose a point for every .
For define indices by recursion: is the least with and ; such an index exists by choosing any and applying [F3] inside . Having defined , let be the least with , , and . This index exists by choosing and applying [F3] inside with the prescribed diameter. Each is Borel: for each candidate condition on is membership in the open set , and inductively the set of with is the union over countably many with of ; intersecting with and the fixed diameter condition gives Borel candidate sets. Selecting the least index in a Borel family is Borel.
The points are Borel functions of and converge: for , , so . Completeness gives a limit , whose diameter is zero. The map is Borel: for each nonempty closed , iff ; this condition is a countable intersection of countable unions of Borel sets because is Borel and distance to is continuous. The empty closed set has empty preimage.
is a cross-section: for each choose with , which is possible because by [step 1.2]. Both and lie in , a set of diameter at most , so and the sequence converges to ; continuity of gives , and since the left-hand sequence is constant, .
Transport of measures: for a -finite Borel measure on , define for Borel . This is a Borel measure because is Borel. It is carried by the Borel image : the latter is Borel since is Borel and the diagonal of the Polish space is closed. If with , then is Borel and , since . The sets together with cover , and the last set has -measure zero, so is -finite. Equivalent measures have equivalent pushforwards by the definition of , so the measure class is transported along .
For and one has by [step 3.1], so . Thus is the unique element of with . The map is Borel as a composite of the Borel map (composition of with the continuous action map) with the continuous group operations.
The map , , is Borel and so is , ; they are mutually inverse: and , while . Hence is a Borel isomorphism onto .
We have constructed a Borel cross-section of [step 3.1], the unique Borel section cocycle [step 4.2], the Borel isomorphism [step 4.3], and the transported -finite measure [step 4.1]. AC is inherited through the Polish-space input [F1], whose complete-metrization proof uses DC and the ultrafilter lemma, and supplies Countable Choice for the countable-base refinements and base points in step 1.1 and the fibre points in step 3.1. The least-index recursion and the Borel cocycle and product formulas add no choice requirement.
Remarks
The section is constructed from a countable base by a deterministic least-index recursion, so its Borelness is proved rather than assumed; the compatibility of the presented metric with the group topology is the only metric input.
LCA Fourier transforms form a dense algebra in C0 of the dual
Statement
Assume AC and let be a second-countable LCH abelian group. With , each has , and the functions form a self-adjoint separating nowhere-vanishing algebra whose uniform closure is . No injectivity or inversion claim is needed.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC and a second-countable LCH abelian group with Haar measure.
is a complex Banach -algebra with convolution and involution ; the classification result for its characters says that is a homeomorphism from with the compact-open topology onto the character space of with the pointwise-evaluation topology, and distinct characters give distinct characters of (L1 of a locally compact group is a Banach star-algebra, Involution on L1 of a locally compact group, Characters of the L1 algebra of an abelian group).
The sum-norm unitization is a nonzero unital complex Banach algebra, and every character of is unital and norm-bounded by ; its unit ball is weak-star compact by Banach–Alaoglu, and the character space is closed in that unit ball, hence compact Hausdorff (Characters on a unital Banach algebra are continuous, Banach–Alaoglu, Character and maximal ideal space).
On a compact Hausdorff space, a self-adjoint separating subalgebra of containing the constants has uniform closure (Complex Stone–Weierstrass dichotomy for separating self-adjoint algebras; the unital case is dense).
A continuous function on a locally compact Hausdorff space vanishing at infinity extends by zero at the point at infinity to a continuous function on the one-point compactification (The one-point (Alexandroff) compactification , whose open sets are the open sets of together with the complements in of the closed compact subsets of ).
Product and conjugation of Fourier transforms follow from Fubini and the involution: for in the dense subspace one has and , and both sides are bounded bilinear in with , so the identities hold on all of (Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product, Completeness of the complex Haar L1 and L2 spaces and density of Cc).
Nonnegative compactly supported cutoffs exist near any point, and Haar measure is positive on nonempty open sets, so there is with and for a prescribed (LCH Urysohn cutoff, Haar measure is positive on nonempty open sets and finite on compact sets, The Pontryagin dual with the compact-open topology).
AC is the standing hypothesis (The Axiom of Choice).
Proof
Given: AC, the second-countable LCH abelian group , its dual , and .
The Fourier transform is well defined and bounded: , and is continuous, since compact-open convergence gives uniform convergence on a compact set carrying all but of after choosing a compactly supported -approximant of .
Let be the sum-norm unitization and its character space, a compact Hausdorff space by [F2]. Every is unital; if does not vanish on its restriction is a character of , hence equal to for exactly one by [F1], and then ; otherwise and for all , so with . Thus , the map is a homeomorphism onto the open subset (openness because ), and is the one-point compactification of in the sense of [F4].
Each lies in : the evaluation function is continuous on by its pointwise-evaluation topology, equals on , and is zero at . Hence its closed superlevel set is compact and misses , for every . This is a compact superlevel set of in , proving the required vanishing at infinity.
The algebra of continuous functions on contains the constants, is self-adjoint and separates points: corresponds to the -function up to constants, by [F5], distinct points of are separated by some by [F1], and is separated from any by a with , which exists by [F6]. By [F3] its uniform closure is .
The transforms alone have uniform closure : if , regard it as an element of with by [F4] and choose with ; evaluating at gives because and , so ; hence is a uniform limit of Fourier transforms.
By [step 4.1] the Fourier transforms are uniformly dense in ; by [step 2.1] each lies in ; by [F5] the family is a self-adjoint algebra; it separates points by the separation used in [step 3.1]; and it vanishes nowhere by the bump construction of [F6], which at each supplies with . No injectivity of the transform and no inversion formula were used.
Multiplicity model of a projection-valued measure over a standard Borel base
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a standard Borel space, a projection-valued measure on acting on a nonzero separable complex Hilbert space , and let be a finite Borel measure on that is -faithful, i.e. iff . Then there exist a Borel function and a unitary such that for every Borel . Such a exists for every nonzero separable : for any dense sequence with , is finite, -faithful and Borel. Any two -faithful measures are mutually absolutely continuous.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the standard Borel space , the PVM on the nonzero separable Hilbert space , and a finite -faithful Borel measure on .
For bounded Borel , satisfies and , with and ; each is a finite complex measure; projections commute (Bounded borel pvm integral, Pvm integral is a star homomorphism, Scalar and complex measures from a pvm, Projection valued measure).
Every standard Borel space admits a bimeasurable injection onto a Borel subset of (Standard borel spaces admit bimeasurable real codings, Standard Borel spaces).
The operator is bounded and self-adjoint, hence normal; it has a spectral PVM on the compact with and for Borel given by the bounded Borel functional calculus. If is a regular PVM on a nonempty compact with , then and for Borel (Bounded normal operator abstract spectral theorem, Continuous functional calculus for bounded self adjoint operators, Continuous functional calculus produces a regular PVM, Borel functional calculus for a bounded normal operator, Support and uniqueness of the spectral measure, Self-adjoint, positive, unitary and normal operators).
For an abelian concrete von Neumann algebra on a nonzero separable and a bounded self-adjoint generator with , the spectral multiplicity construction produces a nonzero finite regular Borel measure on , a Borel multiplicity , and a unitary with and ; the construction (the cited proof's steps 1.2–1.9 and 2.1) uses only that is a prescribed bounded self-adjoint generator, its initial selection step being immaterial for a given ; for a fixed generator the measure class and multiplicity function are unique (Spectral multiplicity model for separably acting abelian von Neumann algebras, Von Neumann algebras and commutants, Direct integral of a measurable Hilbert field).
In the model of [F4] the fibre is nonzero for every and is faithful for : iff , because multiplication by is the zero operator exactly when the indicator vanishes almost everywhere (Spectral multiplicity model for separably acting abelian von Neumann algebras, Measurable Hilbert field from a countable fundamental family, Direct integrals of measurable Hilbert fields are Hilbert spaces).
Finite Borel measures on the second-countable LCH space are regular; the Radon–Nikodym theorem gives densities for mutually absolutely continuous finite Borel measures and the corresponding isometry of spaces intertwines multiplication operators (Locally finite Borel measures on second-countable LCH spaces are regular, A sigma-finite signed measure that is absolutely continuous with respect to a sigma-finite positive measure has a unique almost-everywhere density).
Direct integrals transport along bimeasurable base isomorphisms, and multiplication operators transport accordingly (Direct integrals transport along bimeasurable base isomorphisms).
The commutant of the diagonal multiplications on a direct integral consists of the decomposable operators; measurable sections and operator fields obey the usual calculus (Decomposable operators are the commutant of diagonal multiplication, Measurable and decomposable operator fields, Measurable essentially bounded operator fields act decomposably, Measurable sections have measurable pointwise inner products, Composition with a Borel measurable outer map preserves measurability).
AC is the standing hypothesis (The Axiom of Choice, Separability: the existence of an at most countable dense subset, Hilbert space).
Proof
Given: AC, the PVM , the separable nonzero , and a finite -faithful measure ; also the density construction of the statement.
Existence of a faithful measure: for a dense sequence with put . This is a finite Borel measure, and forces for every , so for every ; density of and boundedness of give ; the converse is immediate. Hence is -faithful. If are -faithful, then , so they are mutually absolutely continuous.
Let be a bimeasurable injection onto the Borel set by [F2], and put , a bounded self-adjoint operator by [F3]. Then for Borel is a projection-valued measure on , because preserves the Boolean operations: , , , and countable additivity transfers. Its coordinate integral is : by [F1] and change of variables for the PVM, . For , the bounded integral of against is a two-sided inverse of by [F1], so . Each scalar measure of is a finite Borel measure on the compact metric space , hence regular by [F6], so is a regular PVM.
Spectral identification: by the uniqueness clause of [F3] applied to the regular PVM on , one has and for every Borel . Extend by zero outside when writing it on . Consequently, since , with Borel by bimeasurability; in particular is carried by because . Set ; it is abelian because polynomials in the self-adjoint commute and commutation with a fixed bounded operator is WOT closed, so their WOT closure still commutes pairwise. Thus is a prescribed self-adjoint generator to which [F4] applies.
Apply the spectral multiplicity model of [F4] to the pair : there are a finite regular Borel measure on , a Borel function and a unitary with and . Since , the operator is the multiplication by , so is -faithful: iff iff iff , the middle equivalence using that every fibre is nonzero so that a multiplication operator is zero exactly when its symbol vanishes a.e.
The pushforward restricted to is likewise -faithful: for Borel one has iff , using -faithfulness of and being carried by from [step 2.1]. Extend by zero off , restrict both measures to , and extend by on , which is null. Identify the integrals over and by restriction and zero extension, since . Hence and are mutually absolutely continuous finite Borel measures on the standard Borel space and have Radon–Nikodym densities; the isometry , , is unitary and commutes with every bounded Borel scalar multiplier by [F6]. Thus is a unitary with and .
Transport along : the map is a bimeasurable bijection with , so by [F7] pullback of sections is a unitary intertwining multiplication by with multiplication by . Define , a Borel function by [F8].
The composite is a unitary , and for every Borel , , using from [step 2.1] and the intertwining property of .
Steps 1.1, 5.1 and 6.1 produce the faithful finite measure , the Borel multiplicity and the unitary with ; any two -faithful measures are mutually absolutely continuous by [step 1.1]. The uniqueness of the multiplicity is the rigidity statement of the intertwiner lemma: two models over the same base with a unitary intertwining all multiplications have the same multiplicity almost everywhere, and such an intertwiner is decomposable with unitary fibres a.e. (Unitary intertwiners preserve fibre multiplicity over a standard Borel base).
Ergodic systems with regular orbits concentrate on one orbit
Statement
Assume AC. Let be an ergodic system of imprimitivity for a Borel action of a group on a standard Borel space , acting on a nonzero separable Hilbert space, and suppose the orbit equivalence relation of the action is regular: there is a countable family of -invariant Borel subsets of such that every orbit is the intersection of the sets that contain it. Equivalently, some countable family of invariant Borel sets separates distinct orbits, which is the condition that the orbit space is countably separated. Then there is an orbit with .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the Borel -space , the ergodic system of imprimitivity on a nonzero separable Hilbert space, and a countable family of invariant Borel sets as in the statement.
is a strongly continuous unitary representation together with a PVM with , and ergodicity means that every Borel with for all satisfies or ; for invariant Borel one has invariant (Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space, Left group actions, transitive actions, and faithful actions, A measurable function between measurable spaces).
Projections in the range of a PVM satisfy ; a projection is zero exactly when the scalar measures vanish for all ; and is strongly countably additive (Scalar and complex measures from a pvm, Bounded borel pvm integral).
is standard Borel, so Borel sets are closed under countable unions and intersections; invariance of a Borel set means for all and implies invariance of its complement (Standard Borel spaces).
AC is the standing hypothesis; it is inherited from the ambient system (The Axiom of Choice, Multiplicity model of a projection-valued measure over a standard Borel base).
Proof
Given: AC, the ergodic system and the countable invariant family .
The two regularity formulations are equivalent. If every orbit is the intersection of the invariant Borel sets containing it, the family separates distinct orbits: if lie in different orbits and belonged to every containing , then would lie in the intersection defining the orbit of . Conversely, adjoin the complements to a countable separating family and reenumerate it as . Then for every the intersection is contained in the orbit of : a point is separated from by some , and replacing by its complement if necessary (also invariant Borel by [F3]) gives , ; the reverse inclusion holds because each is invariant.
Each is or : since is invariant, for every , so ergodicity applies.
Define if and if ; each is invariant Borel and . For one has with ; strong countable additivity gives and the scalar measures of each finite union vanish, so .
is nonempty because on the nonzero Hilbert space, and is invariant. Choose . Its orbit satisfies since is invariant. Conversely, if and , then either , in which case ; or and , a contradiction. Hence belongs to every containing , so by regularity . Therefore is a single orbit and is Borel as a countable intersection.
Combining [step 2.1] and [step 3.1]: the invariant Borel set is exactly one orbit and , which is the concentration claim.
Haar null classes and Borel descent on a homogeneous space
Statement
Assume AC. Let be second-countable LCH, closed, , and a Borel section. Every nonzero -finite quasi-invariant Borel measure on is equivalent to a rho-derived quotient measure. The coordinates carry the product quotient/Haar measure class to the Haar measure class on . In particular iff is Haar null. If a Borel map for separable satisfies for every and almost every , then almost everywhere for a Borel .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the second-countable LCH group , the closed subgroup , the quotient map , and a Borel section with its cocycle as in Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups.
The map , , is a Borel isomorphism with Borel inverse , and for every (Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups).
Fix left Haar measures on and and a rho-function , continuous, with . The Weil formula holds for ; is a full-support nonzero Radon measure that is strongly quasi-invariant, and is a Radon measure equivalent to Haar (Weil formula with a rho-function, Existence of rho-functions and quotient measure classes, Rho-function for a closed subgroup, Quasi-invariant Radon measure on G/H).
Every Borel measure finite on compact sets on the second-countable LCH space is regular, so two such measures agreeing on agree on Borel sets (Assuming Dependent Choice, uniqueness of the RMK representing measure among Radon measures, Radon measure on an LCH space, Locally finite Borel measures on second-countable LCH spaces are regular).
Completed-product Tonelli/Fubini applies to -finite measures and nonnegative measurable functions; the left Haar measure is invariant under left translations on , so the homeomorphism of preserves the completed product (Tonelli and Fubini for the completed product, with only almost-everywhere section measurability, Monotone convergence for the integral, Right translation scales left Haar measure).
A separable has a finite or countable orthonormal basis, and matrix coefficients of operators in against it are bounded Borel functions on ; integration of a bounded Borel -valued function against a probability density produces the matrix of a bounded operator, and the unitary conditions are countably many Borel equations (A Hilbert space with a dense sequence has a finite or countable orthonormal basis, Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners).
AC implies DC and Countable Choice, which are the choice principles used by the Tonelli, monotone-convergence and RMK interfaces (The Axiom of Choice, AC implies DC implies countable choice).
Proof
Given: AC, the data of the statement, and a rho-function with its measure .
Extension of the Weil formula to Borel sets: for every Borel , Both sides are -finite Borel measures on the -compact space that are finite on compacta (the right side because is continuous; the left side by sandwiching indicators of a compact set between functions). They agree on by [F2], so by [F3] they agree on every Borel set.
Descent, first reduction: let be as in the statement. The set is a Borel subset of the triple product, and its measure is zero: by Tonelli its measure is the integral over of the measures of the sections , each of which is null by hypothesis. Hence Fubini gives that for a.e. the section is a null subset of .
The coordinate map pushes the product measure to : by [step 1.1] and left invariance of (which lets be replaced by any representative of the coset in ), for every Borel one has . Since pointwise, the classes of and coincide; hence the product class maps to the Haar class and, by [F1], is Haar null iff iff .
For such an , the homeomorphism preserves the completed product by [F4], so its image of , namely , is null. Hence is -a.e. constant for a.e. .
Equivalence of two rho measures and of any quasi-invariant measure with : if is a nonzero -finite quasi-invariant Borel measure on , replace it by an equivalent probability (still written ), choose a probability with Haar-a.e., and set for Borel . The integrand is Borel in for fixed , and is a probability on . Each translate is equivalent to , so ; and by Tonelli . For fixed with representative , the substitution gives by the right-translation scaling of the Haar integral; since Haar-a.e. and is right--invariant, this is positive exactly when by [step 2.1]. Hence iff , so . This proves the first assertion and, with [step 2.1], the null-class assertion Haar null.
Borel selection of the constant: fix a strictly positive integrable Borel probability density on : take a countable compact cover , each of finite Haar measure, and normalize , which is positive everywhere and has finite nonzero integral and a finite or countable orthonormal basis of by [F5]; set . Each is Borel in by Tonelli, and for a.e. the matrix is the matrix of the a.e. constant unitary value of , hence unitary. The set of where the countably many Borel unitary equations and column completeness fail is Borel and null; put there and equal to the operator with matrix otherwise. Then is Borel and for a.e. .
Collecting the steps: every nonzero -finite quasi-invariant is equivalent to [step 3.1]; the coordinate map carries the product class to the Haar class, so a Borel is -null exactly when its full preimage is Haar null [step 2.1, step 3.1]; and every -invariant Borel -valued function descends to a Borel almost everywhere [step 3.2]. These are the three assertions of the statement.
Spectral measure of a unitary representation of an abelian group, covariance, and ergodicity
Statement
Assume AC, and let be a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff abelian group, a strongly continuous unitary representation on a separable Hilbert space , and a second-countable locally compact group acting continuously on by automorphisms , with dual action on . If is a strongly continuous unitary representation with , then there is a unique regular projection-valued measure on with for every Borel . If in addition the representation , of is irreducible, then the measure class of is ergodic for the action of on : every Borel with invariant under satisfies or .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the groups , the strongly continuous representations with the covariance relation, and a separable .
is a commutative complex Banach -algebra with convolution and involution ; is dense; there is a contractively bounded approximate identity; the Haar integral satisfies the inversion formula ; nonnegative compactly supported functions exist near every point and Haar measure is positive on nonempty open sets (L1 of a locally compact group is a Banach star-algebra, Involution on L1 of a locally compact group, Haar change of variables under inversion, L1 group algebras have a contractively bounded approximate identity, Convolution on L1 of a locally compact group, Complex Haar L^p spaces and compactly supported functions, LCH Urysohn cutoff, Haar measure is positive on nonempty open sets and finite on compact sets).
Bochner calculus in : strong measurability plus finiteness of gives Bochner integrability; ; bounded linear maps commute with the Bochner integral; norm dominated convergence holds; scalar Fubini applies to iterated integrals of integrable kernels (Bochner integrability criterion, Bochner integral norm inequality, Bounded linear maps commute with Bochner integration, Bochner dominated convergence theorem, Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product, Bochner-integrable function).
Every nonzero complex-linear multiplicative functional on is for a unique , and the Fourier transforms form a self-adjoint separating algebra with uniform closure ; is locally compact abelian (Characters of the L1 algebra of an abelian group, LCA Fourier transforms form a dense algebra in C0 of the dual, The dual of a locally compact abelian group is locally compact abelian, The Pontryagin dual with the compact-open topology).
For a commutative C*-algebra , the Gelfand transform is an isometric -isomorphism onto , so (Nonunital commutative Gelfand Naimark, Gelfand transform).
A nondegenerate star representation on a separable Hilbert space is for a unique regular PVM with (Nondegenerate representations of C0 have regular PVMs, Projection valued measure).
PVM integral calculus: is a unital -homomorphism of bounded Borel functions, , scalar measures are finite complex measures with , and bounded pointwise convergence gives strong convergence (Bounded borel pvm integral, Pvm integral is a star homomorphism, Scalar and complex measures from a pvm, Dominated convergence).
is Polish and a countable union of compacta, so Haar measure is -finite. Its scalar space is separable by the direct-integral Hilbert-space theorem; step 1.1 derives separability and hence second countability of the dual (Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel, Second countability: an at most countable basis for the topology, Left Haar integral and left Haar measure, Direct integrals of measurable Hilbert fields are Hilbert spaces).
AC implies DC and Countable Choice for the Bochner, Fubini and Gelfand interfaces (The Axiom of Choice, AC implies DC implies countable choice, Complex Stone–Weierstrass dichotomy for separating self-adjoint algebras; the unital case is dense, Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners, Hilbert space).
Proof
Given: AC, and the covariance relation.
If , the zero PVM uniquely satisfies the statement, and the irreducibility premise does not hold. Assume . Let be increasing compact sets covering . The closed subspace of supported in is separable by [F7], and its inclusion into is continuous, with norm at most . Choosing a countable dense family in each such subspace gives a countable -dense family: for any , the truncations lie in these subspaces and converge to in as . Thus is separable. On its dual unit ball, evaluation on a countable norm-dense family induces the pointwise-evaluation topology, because the norm bounds uniformly control the error of replacing any argument by a dense one. This embeds that ball into a countable product of complex lines. By [F3] the dual is homeomorphic to its character subspace and therefore second countable; since it is LCH, it is standard Borel by [F7].
For define . The integrand is strongly measurable (a.e. limit of -approximants times the continuous map ) and , so is a bounded operator with ; is linear and multiplicative: for Fubini, applicable since the Haar measure is -finite by [F7], gives , and both sides extend by density; and by the adjoint computation and the inversion formula of [F1]. Nondegeneracy: for the approximate identity one has because and strong continuity makes the integrand small on eventually.
Let be the norm closure of in ; it is a commutative C*-algebra (the image of the commutative is a commutative -algebra) and it is nonzero when by [step 2.1]. For the composite is a nonzero complex-linear multiplicative functional on : if it vanished on the dense subalgebra then by continuity. Hence by [F3] there is with ; therefore, using the isometry of [F4], .
The assignment is well defined and linear because forces by [step 3.1], and it is bounded for the uniform norm; since the Fourier transforms are uniformly dense in by [F3], it extends uniquely to a bounded linear map with . Multiplicativity and -preservation extend from the dense subalgebra of Fourier transforms, using continuity of the products, so is a nondegenerate star representation: is dense because for the approximate identity.
By [F5] there is a unique regular PVM on with for all ; in particular for every , and .
Put , using the PVM just constructed. The PVM calculus gives and . For every sequence , by dominated convergence; since is metrizable, this proves strong continuity. The zero Hilbert space has the zero PVM throughout, so the same conclusions hold there.
For one has : the evaluation is jointly continuous: restrict to a compact neighbourhood of and use uniform convergence of characters there together with continuity of the limiting character. Thus the kernel below is jointly Borel. Pairing with and commuting the bounded functional through the Bochner integral, , and Fubini, applied to the product of the -finite Haar measure and the finite measure by [F7], identifies this with by [step 5.1]. Hence the continuous function satisfies for every ; if , rotate by a scalar of modulus one so its value at has positive real part; a nonnegative compactly supported cutoff supported where that real part remains positive has a nonzero integral against , a contradiction, so . As were arbitrary, for every , i.e. .
Uniqueness of : if is another regular PVM on with for all , then for every , as above, so for all in the uniformly dense algebra of Fourier transforms; both sides are bounded linear in , so the equality holds on all of , and [F5] applied to the common representation gives .
Covariance: fix . The map is a homeomorphism of , so is a regular PVM, and is again a regular PVM. Its integrated representation is for every , where the change of variables in the dual and the covariance relation were used. By [step 7.1] , that is .
Ergodicity: suppose is Borel and is invariant under , for all . For every , , since is a spectral projection of and . Hence the range of is a closed subspace invariant under both and ; if the semidirect-product representation is irreducible, or . This is precisely the ergodicity of the measure class of for the dual action.
Steps 5.1, 7.1 and 8.1 give existence, uniqueness and covariance of the regular PVM , and [step 9.1] gives ergodicity under irreducibility; the zero-dimensional case is the zero PVM and is immediate.
Transitive systems of imprimitivity and their normalized measure class
Definition
A system of imprimitivity on a standard Borel -space (Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space, Standard Borel spaces) is transitive when is -equivariantly isomorphic to a homogeneous space with closed, the isomorphism carrying the Borel structure of (Left group actions, transitive actions, and faithful actions, Left and right cosets and of a subgroup, Topological group: multiplication and inversion are continuous); hence then is second-countable locally compact, the action on is the left-coset action, and the stabilizer of the identity coset is . For a transitive system one fixes the base identification .
Assume AC for the following normalized-measure existence and uniqueness assertions: a normalized representative is a strongly quasi-invariant Radon measure on built from a rho-function (Rho-function for a closed subgroup, Quasi-invariant Radon measure on G/H, Existence of rho-functions and quotient measure classes). The normalized homogeneous measure class is the unique class of nonzero quasi-invariant Radon measures on ; the system is called transitive on .
Well-definedness. The equivariant-isomorphism clause is a condition on the given system and selects the conjugacy class of : if is the image of the identity coset under a -equivariant Borel isomorphism, then by the computation (Left and right cosets and of a subgroup); conversely a homogeneous space for second-countable locally compact and closed is a standard Borel -space with Borel action (Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel, Compact lifts and averaging onto C_c(G/H)). The normalized class exists and is unique: the rho-function theorem supplies a full-support strongly quasi-invariant Radon representative (Existence of rho-functions and quotient measure classes), two rho-functions give representatives in the same class (their densities are positive continuous), and every nonzero -finite quasi-invariant Borel measure is equivalent to (Haar null classes and Borel descent on a homogeneous space); in particular the class does not depend on the chosen rho-function, on the normalization of Haar measure, or on the choice of the base-point identification. Consumers that use only the definitional term transitive do not consume the normalized-measure existence assertion.
The definition names no choice; AC is used exactly by the quoted rho-function and Haar-lift suppliers for existence and uniqueness of the normalized class.
A transitive Borel -space with a quasi-invariant measure class is ergodic
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff topological group, a closed subgroup, and a nonzero quasi-invariant Radon measure on . If is Borel with for every , then or . Equivalently, any transitive system of imprimitivity on whose measure class is the quasi-invariant class is ergodic.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the group , closed subgroup , the quotient , a nonzero quasi-invariant Radon measure on , and a Borel with for all .
is continuous and open, is a standard Borel -space with Borel action, for the left action, and a Borel set is -null if and only if is Haar null (Compact lifts and averaging onto C_c(G/H), Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel, Haar null classes and Borel descent on a homogeneous space, Left group actions, transitive actions, and faithful actions).
There exists a full-support strongly quasi-invariant rho-measure whose class is the quasi-invariant class, and every nonzero quasi-invariant -finite Borel measure is equivalent to ; Radon measures on the -compact space are -finite (Existence of rho-functions and quotient measure classes, Quasi-invariant Radon measure on G/H, Haar null classes and Borel descent on a homogeneous space, Radon measure on an LCH space, Countably compact, Lindel"of, sequentially compact, limit point compact and -compact spaces, and relatively compact subsets, Second countability: an at most countable basis for the topology, In a locally compact Hausdorff space every open set containing a point contains an open set containing it whose closure is compact and still inside; such a space is regular).
Tonelli applies to nonnegative product-measurable functions on sigma-finite measure spaces (Tonelli's theorem for nonnegative measurable functions on a sigma-finite product). Right translation by scales left Haar measure by a positive scalar, so it preserves Haar-null Borel sets; this holds at the Borel-measure level, not only for integrals (Modular function of a locally compact group, Borel-level form). Left Haar measure on is sigma-finite because is sigma-compact by [F1].
For a transitive system of imprimitivity on , invariance of a spectral projection under the representation means for all , and is strongly countably additive, so whenever (Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space, Scalar and complex measures from a pvm).
AC is the standing hypothesis (The Axiom of Choice, Topological group: multiplication and inversion are continuous).
Proof
Given: AC, the data and the invariant Borel set of the statement.
Lift the indicator: . For every , applying the hypothesis to gives , so by [F1] the set is Haar null. Since , one has , which equals at every outside ; hence Haar-a.e. for every .
The function is Borel and hence product-measurable, since multiplication is continuous and the Borel sigma-algebra of a product of second-countable spaces is the product Borel sigma-algebra. By step 1.1 each integral in is zero. Tonelli therefore gives , so for Haar-almost every , for Haar-almost every .
Choose with the preceding property; the conull set is nonempty since Haar measure is nonzero. The exceptional set of is Haar null, and its right translate by remains null by [F3]. Substituting therefore gives for Haar-almost every . Since , is Haar-a.e. zero or Haar-a.e. one.
By the null-class equivalence of [F1], Haar-a.e. gives and Haar-a.e. gives . This proves the first assertion.
Equivalence with ergodicity of transitive systems: let be a transitive system on whose null class (the class of -null Borel sets) is the quasi-invariant class, and let be invariant under . Then for all , so by [F4] and hence is null for every measure in the quasi-invariant class; applying [step 4.1] to a representative gives or , and translating back gives or . Thus the system is ergodic.
Haar regularization of transitive unitary cocycles
Statement
Assume AC. Let be as in the Haar-lift lemma, separable, and Borel with for each pair and almost every . Suppose is continuous in local convergence in measure in the strong topology of . Then there exist a strongly continuous unitary representation and a Borel with for every and almost every . This formula gives a strict Borel cocycle on all of . The representation is unique up to unitary equivalence under Borel changes of fibre gauge.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, a second-countable LCH group , a closed subgroup , the quotient with a Borel section , a nonzero quasi-invariant measure class (a representative ), a separable Hilbert space , and a Borel cocycle .
The Haar-lift lemma supplies: is Haar null iff ; the coordinate map is a Borel isomorphism; and every Borel satisfying for all and a.e. equals a.e. for a Borel (Haar null classes and Borel descent on a homogeneous space, Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups).
Steinhaus–Pettis: for a separable , in the strong topology is a second-countable topological group and every Borel homomorphism is strongly continuous (Steinhaus and Pettis: Borel homomorphisms of second-countable locally compact groups are continuous, Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners).
Completed-product Tonelli/Fubini for -finite measures; left translations preserve the Haar measure and right translations scale it by the modular function; Haar null sets of the completed product are preserved by the coordinate changes used below (Tonelli and Fubini for the completed product, with only almost-everywhere section measurability, Strong continuity of left and modular right translations on L1 and L2, Monotone convergence for the integral).
For a Borel -valued function on and , the translates are continuous in local measure: on a fixed finite-Haar-measure set one has . This follows by approximating on relatively compact sets by continuous compactly supported -valued functions (using a countable orthonormal basis and the density of in ) and then applying the translation continuity, uniformly over in a compact neighbourhood, where the modular factor is bounded (Strong continuity of left and modular right translations on L1 and L2, Completeness of the complex Haar L1 and L2 spaces and density of Cc, A Hilbert space with a dense sequence has a finite or countable orthonormal basis, LCH Urysohn cutoff).
Finite measures absolutely continuous with respect to a -finite measure have Radon–Nikodym densities (A sigma-finite signed measure that is absolutely continuous with respect to a sigma-finite positive measure has a unique almost-everywhere density). AC implies DC and Countable Choice for the Tonelli, density and selection interfaces (The Axiom of Choice, AC implies DC implies countable choice, Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel).
Proof
Given: AC, the cocycle and the continuity hypothesis.
Lift to : put , a Borel -valued function on . For the cocycle law applied at , in the second variable , the equivariance of the quotient map gives , so wherever the a.e. cocycle identity of holds at that triple. The set of triples for which it may fail is the preimage of the cocycle law's null set under the homeomorphism of , whose Jacobian is a positive modular factor; by [F3] that preimage is null. Hence for Haar-a.e. .
Choose by Fubini so that for Haar-a.e. , and set , a Borel -valued function. Then for Haar-a.e. , i.e. for Haar-a.e. .
Upgrade to every fixed : let be the conull set of for which the identity of [step 2.1] holds for a.e. ; it is dense because Haar measure is positive on nonempty open sets, so every is a limit of a net in . Along that net the left-hand classes converge in local measure to by the continuity hypothesis: for a finite-Haar-measure set , the finite measure is absolutely continuous with respect to by [F1]; truncating its Radon–Nikodym density and exhausting the -finite base shows that local convergence in -measure implies convergence for this finite measure. Thus pullback is continuous in local Haar measure. The right-hand classes converge in local measure to by [F4]; multiplication by the fixed field preserves this convergence, as follows by approximating on each finite-measure set by finite-valued vectors and using the uniform norm bound on unitaries. Since the two sides agree at each , uniqueness of local-measure limits gives for a.e. . As was arbitrary, the identity holds for every fixed and Haar-a.e. .
Stabilizer constants: for put . For every and Haar-a.e. , [step 3.1] applied to and to , together with and the cocycle law, gives ; Tonelli and the measure-preserving change show that for Haar-a.e. , so is Haar-a.e. constant, equal to some ; hence for Haar-a.e. .
is a homomorphism: applying [step 4.1] twice, a.e., so . It is Borel: integrating the matrix coefficients of the Borel -valued function against a fixed positive probability density on returns the matrix coefficients of (because a.e.) and is Borel in by Tonelli; by [F2], applied to the second-countable group and the target , is strongly continuous.
Descent: define . For , up to the a.e. statements of [step 5.1]; hence by [F1] there is a Borel with for Haar-a.e. .
Substituting [step 6.1] into [step 3.1] at the points and gives, for every fixed , for a.e. ; using and the exact section identity this is the displayed formula for a.e. ; the strict section identity then makes the displayed expression an exact Borel cocycle on all of .
Uniqueness of : if both factorize , set ; then for every and a.e. , so [step 4.1] makes a constant unitary , and right- covariance gives for every . Since a change of gauge multiplies the lifted factorizations on the left, the class of is unchanged.
Steps 5.1, 6.1, 7.1 and 7.2 give a strongly continuous , a Borel with the displayed factorization, its exact cocycle form, and the uniqueness up to gauge, as claimed.
Remarks
The continuity hypothesis is used only in the upgrade step [3.1]; the a.e. cocycle law and the left-invariance arguments are pure Haar-Tonelli computations. No value of an a.e. class is ever evaluated at a prescribed null coset.
Unitary equivalence of systems of imprimitivity and of the induced representations
Definition
Two systems of imprimitivity on and on for the same Borel -space (Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space) are unitarily equivalent when there is a unitary (Hilbert space) with for every and every Borel ; if both are transitive on (Transitive systems of imprimitivity and their normalized measure class), such a is called an equivalence of transitive systems. Two strongly continuous unitary representations of a common group (Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners) are unitarily equivalent when there is a unitary intertwiner between them.
Well-definedness. For a fixed base the relation is the natural isomorphism of pairs (strongly continuous unitary representation, projection-valued measure): it is reflexive with , symmetric with , and transitive with a composite, because conjugation by a unitary preserves the defining identities; the base isomorphism is suppressed from the notation exactly because transitivity fixes the identification . The definition introduces no choice and no new existence assertion.
An induced representation carries a canonical system of imprimitivity on
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff topological group, closed, and a strongly continuous unitary representation on a separable Hilbert space . Let be the induced representation on the covariant completion with rho-measure . For a Borel set define on the covariant model by . Then is a projection-valued measure on , is well defined on the completed space of measurable covariant sections, for all and Borel , and is a system of imprimitivity on with . If the base is one point and ; if one may normalize so that the system is the multiplication system on with the left regular action .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the second-countable LCH group , closed , a strongly continuous unitary on separable , and the induced representation on the covariant completion with rho-measure .
The covariant model consists of (classes of) functions with , compactly supported modulo , with the norm obtained by integrating the descended pointwise norm against ; the dense subspace of continuous covariant sections with compact support modulo generates the completion, and continuous compactly supported covariant generators are dense (Continuous covariant model and measurable completion, Density of averaged covariant generators, Well-defined induced inner product).
The induced action is with ; it preserves the inner product, satisfies , and extends to a unitary on the completion (Unitary cocycle-corrected left action, Unitary induction from a closed subgroup, Continuous quotient translation cocycle).
is a full-support strongly quasi-invariant Radon measure, so the descended norm integral is a genuine integral over the standard Borel -space ; multiplication by the indicator of a Borel set of finite -measure is a bounded self-adjoint idempotent on the completed space, and dominated convergence gives strong countable additivity (Existence of rho-functions and quotient measure classes, Quasi-invariant Radon measure on G/H, Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel, Bounded borel pvm integral).
The induced representation is strongly continuous and the system of imprimitivity axioms require the covariance identity (Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners, Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space).
For the quotient is a point and the covariant model is with the action ; for the rho-measure may be taken to be Haar measure, covariant functions are unconstrained, and the induced space is with action (Left and right cosets and of a subgroup, Unitary induction from a closed subgroup, Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups).
AC is the standing hypothesis, inherited through the rho-measure and induction suppliers (The Axiom of Choice).
Proof
Given: AC, the group, subgroup, representation and the induced model of [F1].
Identify the covariant completion with the square-integrable measurable covariant sections using the density of the continuous covariant generators in [F1]. Thus a Borel-indicator multiple of a section remains in the completed model. On this measurable model, is covariant: , since . It is idempotent and self-adjoint for the induced inner product because pointwise, and it is a contraction: the pointwise norm of is at most that of everywhere. Hence extends uniquely to a bounded self-adjoint idempotent on .
, , and follow pointwise from the same identities for indicators, hence hold on the completion by density; strong countable additivity holds because for a disjoint union the partial sums converge pointwise to and are bounded, so dominated convergence in the -integral gives for every . Thus is a projection-valued measure on the Borel -algebra of .
Covariance: by [F2], , so for all and Borel , first on the dense model and then everywhere by continuity.
Consequently is a system of imprimitivity: is a PVM by [step 2.1], is a strongly continuous unitary representation, and the covariance identity is [step 2.2], with .
Boundary cases of the statement: if then is a singleton and the only Borel sets are and the point, so and the system is the given representation with the trivial base. If then , covariant functions are arbitrary, and with the Haar normalization the induced action is on while is pointwise multiplication by ; this is the multiplication system of the statement.
Steps 2.1, 3.1 and 3.2 prove that is a well-defined projection-valued measure on the completed space, that the pair is a system of imprimitivity on , and the two boundary identifications.
Spectral multiplicity model of a transitive system of imprimitivity
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff topological group, a closed subgroup, and let be a transitive system of imprimitivity on acting on a nonzero separable Hilbert space . Then there exist a finite Borel measure on in the quasi-invariant class, a nonzero separable Hilbert space , and a unitary such that for every Borel . Moreover is quasi-invariant under every , and the multiplicity is constant almost everywhere; any two such normalizations differ by a decomposable unitary, so is determined up to isometric isomorphism and up to equivalence.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the transitive system on with nonzero separable .
The base is a standard Borel space, and the quasi-invariant class is the unique class of nonzero quasi-invariant measures; a Borel set invariant up to null sets for the class is null or conull (Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel, Transitive systems of imprimitivity and their normalized measure class, Quasi-invariant Radon measure on G/H, Existence of rho-functions and quotient measure classes, A transitive Borel -space with a quasi-invariant measure class is ergodic).
Multiplicity model over a standard Borel base: for a PVM on and a -faithful finite Borel measure there are a Borel and a unitary with for all Borel ; -faithful measures exist and any two are mutually absolutely continuous (Multiplicity model of a projection-valued measure over a standard Borel base, Direct integral of a measurable Hilbert field, Measurable Hilbert field from a countable fundamental family, Direct integrals of measurable Hilbert fields are Hilbert spaces).
Unitary intertwiners preserve fibre multiplicity: if is unitary with for all bounded Borel , then a.e.; two normalizations of one model over a fixed base therefore differ by a decomposable unitary with unitary fibres a.e. (Unitary intertwiners preserve fibre multiplicity over a standard Borel base).
Transport and Radon–Nikodym: for bimeasurable base homeomorphisms and mutually absolutely continuous finite measures there are unitaries of the associated -direct-integrals intertwining the multiplication actions, with multiplication by the square root of the appropriate density; the diagonal commutant identifies the intertwining operators as decomposable (Direct integrals transport along bimeasurable base isomorphisms, A sigma-finite signed measure that is absolutely continuous with respect to a sigma-finite positive measure has a unique almost-everywhere density, Decomposable operators are the commutant of diagonal multiplication).
For a Borel , , because and conjugation by a unitary preserves zero projections; hence any -faithful is quasi-invariant (Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space, Scalar and complex measures from a pvm, Bounded borel pvm integral).
AC is the standing hypothesis (The Axiom of Choice, Separability: the existence of an at most countable dense subset, Hilbert space).
Proof
Given: AC, the transitive system on .
Choose a -faithful finite Borel measure on by [F2] and apply the multiplicity model: there are a Borel and a unitary with for every Borel . By [F5] is quasi-invariant, so lies in the normalized class of .
Conjugate the representation: is a unitary of the model with for every bounded Borel , because conjugates to and .
For each , form the unitary where is the transport unitary associated with the base homeomorphism ; here sends to , from the model over to the pulled-back model over , and intertwines with , so is a unitary with . Since is equivalent to by [F5], the Radon–Nikodym isometry of [F4] converts it into a unitary with for all bounded Borel .
By the rigidity lemma [F3] applied to , the multiplicities agree: -almost everywhere, for every (replacing by gives the form stated in the strategy). Therefore each level set is invariant under the action up to -null sets.
Ergodicity forces one level set to be conull: the countably many level sets partition , each is invariant up to null sets, so by [F1] each is null or conull; since is nonzero and finite, exactly one level set is conull, and . Restrict the model to : the restriction of is a unitary and, viewed on by zero extension outside , a unitary with ( if ), nonzero and separable, and for every Borel .
This proves existence with constant multiplicity and quasi-invariant . Uniqueness: if and are two such normalizations, is a unitary intertwining the two multiplication actions over any common base; taking as the base and using mutual absolute continuity, [F3] gives isometrically and identifies the intertwiners as decomposable with unitary fibres, while by mutual absolute continuity of -faithful measures.
Steps 4.1 and 5.1 establish the model and the constancy of the multiplicity, and step 6.1 gives the stated uniqueness; the measure is quasi-invariant by [step 1.1].
Measurable cocycle fields for a multiplicity-normalized system
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a transitive system of imprimitivity on and fix a normalization with , second countable locally compact, closed, separable, a nonzero -finite quasi-invariant Borel measure. For let be the canonical translation operator and put . Then commutes with all multiplications and is therefore multiplication by an essentially bounded measurable operator field ; the field may be chosen so that is Borel on for in a fixed dense countable subset of and so that is unitary for almost every and every , with the cocycle identity holding for every and almost every .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the transitive system with its normalization and the data of the statement.
The normalization is unitary with ; for every bounded Borel one has for , and may be taken to be a finite measure in the quasi-invariant class with the direct integral of the constant field (Spectral multiplicity model of a transitive system of imprimitivity, Direct integral of a measurable Hilbert field).
The translation operators are unitary and is strongly continuous on the induced model: is the induced action of the trivial representation of , and the criterion for strong continuity of unitary representations applies (Unitary cocycle-corrected left action, Continuity criteria for unitary representations, Independence of rho and equivalent quotient representative).
The commutant of the diagonal multiplications on a direct integral is exactly the set of decomposable operators, and an essentially bounded weakly measurable field acts decomposably and is unique up to a null set; multiplication by a unitary operator corresponds to a field that is unitary almost everywhere (Decomposable operators are the commutant of diagonal multiplication, Measurable essentially bounded operator fields act decomposably, Measurable and decomposable operator fields, Unitary intertwiners preserve fibre multiplicity over a standard Borel base).
The base is standard Borel. Its constant-field direct integral is separable; AC fixes a countable norm-dense sequence with Borel section representatives and a countable orthonormal basis of . Tonelli applies to sums of squared errors (Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups, Standard Borel spaces, Measurable sections have measurable pointwise inner products, Composition with a Borel measurable outer map preserves measurability, Direct integrals transport along bimeasurable base isomorphisms, Direct integrals of measurable Hilbert fields are Hilbert spaces, A Hilbert space with a dense sequence has a finite or countable orthonormal basis, Tonelli and Fubini for the completed product, with only almost-everywhere section measurability).
Radon–Nikodym densities of the quasi-invariant measure class are measurable and finite a.e., and the resulting -multiplications are measurable in the parameters (A sigma-finite signed measure that is absolutely continuous with respect to a sigma-finite positive measure has a unique almost-everywhere density, Monotone convergence for the integral).
AC is the standing hypothesis (The Axiom of Choice).
Proof
Given: AC, the normalized transitive system and the operators .
If , choose the sole operator on each fibre; all conclusions are immediate. Assume . By the Haar-lift lemma, is equivalent to a rho-derived Radon measure . Put , choosing a finite positive Borel version off a null set, and . The set-integral formula shows that is unitary and that a.e. Hence . The latter is the strongly continuous scalar induced translation tensored with , as verified first on finite sums of scalar sections times fibre vectors and then by density. Thus is a strongly continuous unitary representation, and so is ; their product is strongly continuous and unitary.
commutes with all : both and conjugate to , so . The commutant theorem therefore gives a measurable field representing ; the fibrewise identities for make its fibres unitary almost everywhere.
Construct a joint representative without changing the fixed measure. Choose a finite-measure Borel partition of and put on ; then is Borel and belongs to . Fix an orthonormal basis of and a countable norm-dense sequence of Borel sections by [F4]. For each , choose the least with . Its level sets are Borel in by step 1.1, so is jointly Borel. For each fixed , the sum of squared errors is finite. Tonelli, using any representative of , makes the pointwise squared errors summable a.e.; hence the approximants converge a.e. Their limits divided by are the columns of the field from step 2.1. The set where any column limit fails, or where the columns fail to be a complete orthonormal family, is jointly Borel: convergence, Gram identities, and Parseval on the fixed basis are countably many Borel conditions. Set the field to there. This gives a jointly Borel -valued field representing for every fixed .
For every finite-measure Borel and basis vector , strong continuity of gives . Chebyshev's inequality then gives local convergence in measure of each basis column. Finite linear combinations approximate every fibre vector uniformly under unitaries, so this is convergence in measure in the strong topology of .
Expanding and gives . The first conjugated multiplier has field . Uniqueness of decomposable fields therefore gives for every fixed pair and a.e. .
Steps 2.1, 3.1, 4.1 and 4.2 give the decomposable unitary fields, a jointly Borel representative, local-measure continuity, and the pairwise a.e. cocycle law, respectively. No representative has been evaluated at a prescribed null coset.
The stabilizer acts unitarily on an imprimitivity fibre
Statement
Assume AC and let be a transitive system on on a separable Hilbert space, with multiplicity-normalized model and source-variable cocycle fields as above. Fix a Borel section with . There exist a Borel unitary field and a strongly continuous unitary representation , unique up to unitary equivalence, such that for every and almost every , where . The representatives can be replaced by this strict formula on all pairs and normalized with , so that and . Changes of fields or section give equivalent . If one recovers the original representation; if is trivial the recovered representation is trivial.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the normalized transitive system, its cocycle fields , a Borel section with , and the section cocycle .
The cocycle fields may be chosen jointly Borel on , unitary for every and a.e. , with the a.e. cocycle law and with continuous in local measure in the strong topology; they represent the operators (Measurable cocycle fields for a multiplicity-normalized system).
Haar regularization: every such Borel -valued cocycle factors as for a Borel unitary field and a strongly continuous unitary , and is unique up to unitary equivalence under Borel gauge changes (Haar regularization of transitive unitary cocycles).
The section satisfies , , and the section cocycle satisfies the strict identity ; moreover for and (Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups, Left and right cosets and of a subgroup, Left group actions, transitive actions, and faithful actions).
Unitary fields over a standard Borel base may be modified on null sets, conjugated pointwise, and evaluated at points after being placed in strict form; changes on null sets do not change the a.e. class of the field, and conjugating the whole factorization by a fixed unitary does not change the equivalence class of (Standard Borel spaces, Hilbert space, Separability: the existence of an at most countable dense subset, Hilbert-adjoint identities, Unitary equivalence of systems of imprimitivity and of the induced representations).
with the strong topology is a second-countable topological group, and Borel homomorphisms from the second-countable group into it are strongly continuous (Steinhaus and Pettis: Borel homomorphisms of second-countable locally compact groups are continuous).
Proof
Given: AC, the transitive system with normalized model, the cocycle fields, and the section .
The assignment is a Borel -valued cocycle on satisfying the a.e. cocycle law and the local-measure continuity of [F1]; hence [F2] applies and produces a Borel unitary field and a strongly continuous unitary with for every and a.e. .
Normalization at : if is -null, redefine ; this changes on a null set and the factorization remains valid a.e. If is an atom, replace by and by , which is a unitary equivalence of representations and makes the new field equal to at . In both cases the factorization holds for every and a.e. , and .
Uniqueness and gauge: if and both factorize the same cocycle, the uniqueness clause of [F2] gives a single unitary with for all ; a Borel gauge change multiplies the lifted trivializations on the left and does not change the equivalence class. A change of section changes by the corresponding -factor and leaves the class of fixed.
Place the formula in strict form: define ; by [step 1.1] a.e. for every , and the right-hand side is jointly Borel in ; the strict section identity of [F3] makes an exact cocycle on all of , so replacing the original fields by changes nothing in the a.e. class and gives the displayed formula for every pair.
Evaluating the strict formula at : for one has , so because ; and for , gives . Thus the recovered data are exactly and .
Boundary cases: if then is a point, , and the factorization collapses to , so is unitarily equivalent to the original representation carried by the fields. If then is the trivial group and is a strongly continuous unitary representation of the trivial group, hence the identity representation on its given fibre ; nothing more is asserted.
Steps 1.1, 2.1 and 3.1 give existence of with the strict factorization and the two evaluation identities; [step 1.3] gives uniqueness up to unitary equivalence and gauge; [step 4.1] gives the two boundary cases. This proves the statement.
The imprimitivity reconstruction map is isometric and intertwining
Statement
Assume AC. In the normalized model of a transitive system on , take the Borel unitaries and the stabilizer representation supplied by the preceding lemma. Multiplication by is unitary and This is the canonical induced action of . Moreover for all Borel . Hence is unitarily equivalent to the canonical induced system by an isometric map intertwining both and .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the normalized transitive system with multiplicity model , cocycle fields , Borel unitaries and stabilizer representation .
The multiplicity-normalized model is with , and the source-variable cocycle fields satisfy , where (Spectral multiplicity model of a transitive system of imprimitivity, Measurable cocycle fields for a multiplicity-normalized system, Direct integral of a measurable Hilbert field).
The stabilizer lemma supplies, after the strict normalization, the identity for every and every , with (The stabilizer acts unitarily on an imprimitivity fibre, Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups).
The canonical induced model of on the covariant completion with rho-measure has action on covariant and is independent of the choice of rho-function and of the equivalent measure representative in the class (An induced representation carries a canonical system of imprimitivity on , Continuous covariant model and measurable completion, Unitary cocycle-corrected left action, Unitary induction from a closed subgroup, Independence of rho and equivalent quotient representative).
Multiplication by a Borel field of unitary operators is unitary on the direct integral and commutes with every ; the commutant of the multiplications consists of the decomposable operators (Decomposable operators are the commutant of diagonal multiplication, Direct integral of a measurable Hilbert field).
Proof
Given: AC, the normalized model with and the cocycle fields.
Multiplication by the Borel unitary field is a unitary of by [F4], and it commutes with every because commutes with the operator in every fibre.
Action computation: for in the model, using [F1] and then the strict factorization [F2] evaluated at the source point , where , so the -factors cancel and the result is . By [F3] this is exactly the canonical induced action of in section coordinates: identifying a square-integrable section with the covariant function determined by and , one has because and , so the induced formula becomes the displayed action; the measure lies in the class used by the induced model by [F3].
PVM transport: commutes with , so for every Borel .
Consequently the composite is a unitary (a composite of unitaries), and by [step 2.1] and [step 2.2] it intertwines with the canonical induced action and with multiplication by . Being unitary, is isometric; the target is identified with the induced space of by [F3].
Thus the transitive system is unitarily equivalent to the canonical induced system of by the isometric intertwiner , which is the reconstruction map of the statement.
Mackey's imprimitivity theorem
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a second-countable locally compact Hausdorff topological group, a closed subgroup, and a transitive system of imprimitivity on acting on a separable Hilbert space . Then there exist a strongly continuous unitary representation on a separable Hilbert space and a unitary onto the induced space of such that where is multiplication by the indicator of on the covariant model. Conversely, for every strongly continuous unitary on a separable Hilbert space , the induced representation together with multiplication by indicators on is a transitive system of imprimitivity, and the two constructions are inverse up to unitary equivalence. The uniqueness theorem records the corresponding bijection of equivalence classes.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the transitive system on with separable , and the induced-system construction of An induced representation carries a canonical system of imprimitivity on .
The multiplicity model of a transitive system provides a finite quasi-invariant measure in the normalized class, a separable nonzero , a Borel multiplicity constant a.e., and a unitary with (Spectral multiplicity model of a transitive system of imprimitivity, Transitive systems of imprimitivity and their normalized measure class, Direct integral of a measurable Hilbert field).
For and the canonical scalar translation , the operators are multiplication by jointly Borel, a.e. unitary fields , with for each pair and almost every (Measurable cocycle fields for a multiplicity-normalized system).
If the fields of [F2] are continuous in local measure in the strong topology, Haar regularization gives a Borel unitary field and a strongly continuous unitary with for every and almost every . The formula defines a strict Borel cocycle, and is unique up to unitary equivalence (Haar regularization of transitive unitary cocycles, Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups).
The reconstruction map is a unitary onto the canonical induced space of intertwining with and with multiplication by indicators (The imprimitivity reconstruction map is isometric and intertwining, Continuous covariant model and measurable completion, Unitary induction from a closed subgroup).
Conversely, the induced representation together with is a transitive system of imprimitivity on with the same normalization, and for (one-point base) and (multiplication system) the boundary clauses hold (An induced representation carries a canonical system of imprimitivity on ).
Integrating a system of imprimitivity gives a nondegenerate representation of the transformation algebra, so the choice of PVM is not an extra datum once the system is fixed; the zero Hilbert space carries the zero system (A system of imprimitivity integrates to a nondegenerate representation of the transformation algebra, Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space).
Unitary equivalence of systems and of representations is the relation of Unitary equivalence of systems of imprimitivity and of the induced representations, and AC is the standing hypothesis (The Axiom of Choice, Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners, Hilbert space, Separability: the existence of an at most countable dense subset).
The finite quasi-invariant is equivalent to a rho-derived Radon measure ; a positive finite Borel version of exists, and scalar unitary induction is strongly continuous. Borel homomorphisms are strongly continuous when is separable (Haar null classes and Borel descent on a homogeneous space, A sigma-finite signed measure that is absolutely continuous with respect to a sigma-finite positive measure has a unique almost-everywhere density, Unitary induction from a closed subgroup, Steinhaus and Pettis: Borel homomorphisms of second-countable locally compact groups are continuous).
Proof
Given: AC, the transitive system on and a strongly continuous unitary on separable in the converse direction.
Zero case: if , take , the zero representation of and the zero unitary; the induced space is , the canonical system has , and the displayed identities hold; the same data give the zero system from the zero representation. Hence assume .
Apply [F1] to obtain and put ; [F2] gives the Borel source-variable cocycle fields. Choose and from [F8] and set . Then is unitary. Pushing the equality through the base translation gives almost everywhere, so . The scalar is induction of the trivial representation of and is strongly continuous by [F8]; this extends to -valued sections first on finite sums and then by their density and unitarity. Hence is strongly continuous. Since is strongly continuous, so is , by the triangle inequality and unitary norm bounds.
Reverse direction: given on separable , [F5] endows the induced representation on its covariant completion with the multiplication PVM , which is a projection-valued measure with and the covariance identity, hence a transitive system of imprimitivity on ; this is the converse construction.
Fix , a Borel with , and . Since and , step 1.2 gives . Therefore . On the unitary group, the strong topology is determined by a countable dense set of vectors in separable : finite-vector tests pass to every vector using . Finite unions of the displayed exceptional sets thus prove local convergence in measure in the strong topology. This is the continuity hypothesis required in [F3].
Now [F3] applies with its continuity hypothesis verified by step 2.1 and supplies . In the Haar proof the lifted coboundary has for each and almost every . Thus ; integrating the Borel matrix coefficients of against a fixed Haar probability density makes every coefficient of Borel. Since is separable, [F8] applies to this Borel homomorphism and gives strong continuity. Invariant Borel descent of gives , and the resulting section-cocycle formula is strict on all pairs after replacing the fields by their equal a.e. representatives.
Multiplication by the Borel unitaries is unitary and commutes with indicator multiplications. Put . Substituting the factorization from step 3.1 at the source point gives and . This is the section-coordinate form of the canonical induced action, as in [F4], so is the required unitary and may be denoted in the statement.
Start with the canonical system of . Its source-variable cocycle is , so is already a factorization. Any recovered representation is unitarily equivalent to by the uniqueness clause of [F3]. Conversely step 4.1 reconstructs a system unitarily equivalent to the starting . Thus the constructions are inverse up to unitary equivalence.
Steps 1.2, 2.1, 3.1 and 4.1 prove the forward direction, including the local-measure continuity and strongly continuous stabilizer action; steps 1.3 and 5.1 give the converse and inverse character up to unitary equivalence. The zero case is covered by step 1.1.
Uniqueness in the imprimitivity theorem
Statement
Assume AC and keep the hypotheses of the imprimitivity theorem. If and are strongly continuous unitary representations, then the canonical transitive systems of and on are unitarily equivalent if and only if and are unitarily equivalent. Consequently the map of the imprimitivity theorem is a bijection between unitary equivalence classes of transitive systems on and unitary equivalence classes of strongly continuous unitary representations of .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the second-countable LCH group and closed subgroup , and strongly continuous unitary representations , on separable spaces.
The canonical system of is the induced representation on its covariant completion together with the multiplication PVM ; the induced action in section coordinates is (An induced representation carries a canonical system of imprimitivity on , The imprimitivity reconstruction map is isometric and intertwining, Unitary induction from a closed subgroup).
A system equivalence between two multiplicity-normalized models intertwines the diagonal multiplications, so it is decomposable with unitary fibres almost everywhere, and the fibre dimensions agree a.e.; equivalently, over a fixed base the unitary intertwiners of two models are precisely the decomposable unitaries (Unitary intertwiners preserve fibre multiplicity over a standard Borel base, Decomposable operators are the commutant of diagonal multiplication, Spectral multiplicity model of a transitive system of imprimitivity).
The cocycle fields of the canonical model of factor through a trivialization : writing at the source variable, the Haar regularization uniqueness argument shows that if two trivializations of the same cocycle differ by a gauge , then is left-translation invariant for a.e. , hence a constant unitary , and right- covariance gives for all (Haar regularization of transitive unitary cocycles, Measurable cocycle fields for a multiplicity-normalized system, The stabilizer acts unitarily on an imprimitivity fibre).
The imprimitivity theorem gives the forward and inverse constructions and the zero cases: zero fibres induce exactly the zero system, and a nonzero fibre induces a nonzero space because the quotient measure has full support and nonzero square-integrable sections exist (Mackey's imprimitivity theorem, Transitive systems of imprimitivity and their normalized measure class, Unitary equivalence of systems of imprimitivity and of the induced representations).
Proof
Given: AC, the two representations and their canonical systems.
If and are unitarily equivalent via , define on the covariant completion of pointwise, . Then is unitary, preserves covariance (), and intertwines the induced actions and the multiplication PVM: and . Hence the canonical systems are unitarily equivalent.
Conversely, suppose the canonical systems are unitarily equivalent by . Then intertwines all multiplications by indicators, and by [F2] it is multiplication by a Borel unitary field between the two constant fibres, whose dimensions agree. Fix unitary identifications of the fibres and use [F3]: the two cocycle fields of the canonical models are related by the gauge , and lifting the gauge to produces a constant unitary with for every . Thus and are unitarily equivalent.
Zero cases: if then the canonical system is the zero system and acts trivially; two zero systems are unitarily equivalent, and the zero representation of is unitarily equivalent only to the zero representation; if both are nonzero the argument [step 2.1] applies verbatim, and a nonzero fibre induces a nonzero system by [F4], so the zero and nonzero classes do not mix.
Steps [1.1], [2.1] and [3.1] show that the canonical construction induces a well-defined bijection between unitary equivalence classes of strongly continuous unitary representations of and unitary equivalence classes of transitive systems on , in both directions; the map of the imprimitivity theorem is that bijection.
Mackey little-group reduction for an abelian normal subgroup
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a topological semidirect product with continuous automorphism action and product topology, abelian and closed normal, second countable locally compact, and let the dual action of on have regular orbits in the sense of the preceding lemma (equivalently, the orbit space is countably separated). For let and . Then every irreducible strongly continuous unitary representation of is unitarily equivalent to for some and some irreducible strongly continuous unitary representation of , where denotes the representation of .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the semidirect product with abelian closed normal , an irreducible strongly continuous unitary representation of on a separable Hilbert space, and the regular-orbit hypothesis on the dual action.
Restricting to and letting act through satisfies the covariance hypothesis of the spectral lemma: there is a unique regular PVM on with and for all , with the dual action (Spectral measure of a unitary representation of an abelian group, covariance, and ergodicity, The external semidirect product , The Pontryagin dual with the compact-open topology, Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners, Left group actions, transitive actions, and faithful actions).
If is irreducible, the system is ergodic: an invariant spectral projection commutes with and is invariant under , hence carries an invariant closed subspace; irreducibility forces it to be or (Spectral measure of a unitary representation of an abelian group, covariance, and ergodicity, Schur lemma for complex unitary representations).
Under the regular-orbit hypothesis, an ergodic system of imprimitivity on concentrates on a single orbit: there is with , and the orbit is Borel (Ergodic systems with regular orbits concentrate on one orbit).
The dual is second countable and standard Borel by the spectral lemma’s proof step 1.1. The dual action is jointly continuous: for a compact and a compact neighbourhood in , the images , , lie in one compact set; uniform convergence of characters there and continuity of the action give compact-open continuity. For the stabilizer is closed, the orbit map is a continuous bijection onto the Borel orbit, and ; these homogeneous spaces are Polish standard Borel with Borel actions (Spectral measure of a unitary representation of an abelian group, covariance, and ergodicity, The dual of a locally compact abelian group is locally compact abelian, Continuity of a map of topological spaces at a point and globally, Left and right cosets and of a subgroup, Compact lifts and averaging onto C_c(G/H), Second-countable locally compact Hausdorff spaces are Polish, and homogeneous quotients are standard Borel).
Mackey's imprimitivity theorem applies to the transported transitive system: there are a strongly continuous unitary and a unitary intertwining with (Mackey's imprimitivity theorem, Transitive systems of imprimitivity and their normalized measure class, Unitary equivalence of systems of imprimitivity and of the induced representations).
In the normalized induced model of the system concentrated on , the action of is multiplication by the character evaluated at the source point, the gauge commutes with the scalar action of , and the induced formula for gives for a.e. ; since is normal, conjugation by maps onto itself, and strong continuity extends the identity from a countable dense subset of to all of (Haar null classes and Borel descent on a homogeneous space, An induced representation carries a canonical system of imprimitivity on , Borel cross-sections for closed subgroups of second-countable locally compact Hausdorff groups, Strongly continuous unitary representations, invariant linear subspaces and intertwiners).
AC is the standing hypothesis (The Axiom of Choice, Systems of imprimitivity for a Borel -space).
Proof
Given: AC, the semidirect product, the irreducible , and the regular-orbit hypothesis.
The representation space is separable even if this was not assumed. For , the closed span of is invariant and hence is the whole space by irreducibility. A countable dense subset exists because is second-countable LCH; strong continuity makes dense in the orbit. Its finite rational-complex linear combinations are countable and dense in the Hilbert space. Thus [F1] applies. It produces , which is ergodic by [F2] and concentrates on a Borel orbit by [F3].
The continuous orbit bijection of [F4] is bimeasurable. Indeed, every open subset of the second-countable LCH quotient is a countable union of compact sets contained in : use a countable base with compact closures and shrink inside . Their images under are compact, hence closed in the Hausdorff dual, so is Borel. This proves measurability of without assuming that is a homeomorphism. Transporting gives a transitive system for on ; acts trivially on the base. By [F5], for a strongly continuous .
Choose the Borel section in with values . For every , the spectral formula makes multiplication by on the orbit, and the reconstruction gauge commutes with this scalar multiplier. Since fixes the base, the induced Radon–Nikodym factor is one and the induced formula gives for a.e. . Intersect these conull sets over a countable dense subset of and fix one in the intersection. Continuity of both sides extends the identity to all at this . Conjugation by maps onto itself, so for all . Put ; it is strongly continuous and . Stabilizer invariance of verifies multiplicativity of this formula in the semidirect product.
is irreducible: if had a nontrivial closed invariant subspace, inducing it would produce a nontrivial closed invariant subspace of , because the quotient measure class has full support so a nonzero fibrewise subspace induces a nonzero closed subspace; this contradicts irreducibility of .
Therefore is unitarily equivalent to with and an irreducible strongly continuous unitary representation of , as claimed; the orbit is the one selected by the spectral PVM, and the inducing class is determined by the system uniqueness theorem.
5 · Examples, counterexamples and false statements
None yet.
Sources
- G. W. Mackey, Imprimitivity for Representations of Locally Compact Groups I, PNAS 35 (1949) 537-545 (Internet Archive capture of the PubMed Central scan)
- G. Misra, E. K. Narayanan and C. Varughese, Mackey Imprimitivity and commuting tuples of homogeneous normal operators, arXiv:2402.15737
- M. A. Rieffel, Induced representations of C*-algebras, Advances in Math. 13 (1974) 176-257, §1 (covariance algebras)
- V. S. Sunder, Notes on the Imprimitivity Theorem (ISIBangalore/IMSc lecture notes, 22 pp.)
- Lynn H. Loomis, An Introduction to Abstract Harmonic Analysis, §34A–34C, printed pp. 134–137
- J. Dixmier, Von Neumann Algebras, Chapter II §1 (direct integrals and measurable fields)
- G. B. Folland, A Course in Abstract Harmonic Analysis, Chapter 2 (locally compact groups and homogeneous spaces, Polish structure)
- A. Putman, Lie groups and automatic continuity, proof of Pettis theorem via Steinhaus, pp. 1-2
- J. B. Conway, A Course in Functional Analysis, 2nd ed., Chapter IX §10, Propositions 10.17-10.19 (multiplicity rigidity)
- G. W. Mackey, Induced representations of locally compact groups I, Ann. of Math. 55 (1952) 101-139 (Borel sections of homogeneous spaces)
- C. Anantharaman and S. Popa, An Introduction to II_1 Factors, Chapter 8 §8.1 (spectral multiplicity model)
- D. P. Williams, Lecture Notes on the Spectral Theorem, Example 3.10, printed p. 9
- B. Bekka and P. de la Harpe, Unitary Representations of Groups, Duals, and Characters, arXiv:1912.07262 (AMS Mathematical Surveys and Monographs 250)
- G. B. Folland, A Course in Abstract Harmonic Analysis, Chapter 2 §2.6 (transitive quasi-invariant actions are ergodic)